Adam Pasick

Adam Pasick's Profile

Crunching the numbers on a vegan in a Hummer

October 26, 2009

Photo by Kris Krüg

(Updated below with Michael Pollan’s response)

You want some petroleum with that Big Mac?

Journalist and food writer Michael Pollan broke down the hidden cost of America’s best-known burger on Saturday to an eager audience at the Poptech conference. He traced the Big Mac’s origins all the way back to the oil fields, used to make fertilizer that is crucial to the corn grown for cows in massive feeds lots.

“Our meat eating is one of the most important contributors we make to climate change,” said Pollan, who is best known for his book “The Omnivore’s Dilemma.”

“A vegan in a Hummer has a lighter carbon footprint than a beef eater in a Prius.”

It’s a great line and quite a mental image, one that wowed the audience and quickly spread on Twitter. Too bad it’s not true.

Gidon Eshel and Pamela Martin of the University of Chicago published a 2005 paper in the journal Earth Interactions that looked at the relative carbon footprints of plant-based and red-meat diets.

They found that the difference between an heavy meat-eating diet and a vegan diet was about 2 tons of carbon dioxide equivalent per person per year. The difference between a Prius and an SUV (they used a Suburban, which gets about the same mileage as a Hummer) was 4.76 tons per year.

Pollan’s claim, said Eshel, “is emphatically wrong. If you’re looking at the mean American driving habits and eating habits, it’s not even close.”

“In my heart I’m flatly on the Pollan side, but I’m a scientist and I don’t like to play fast and loose with numbers,” he added. “It’s like death panels in the healthcare debate. We don’t want to get into hyperbolic statements that are numerically unsound.”

To be sure, the calculations behind food-related carbon footprints can be complex. The impact of a Big Mac includes the carbon footprint of the cattle feed and the fertilizer used to grow it, the fuel burned to get the animal to a feedlot and then to market, and the animal’s emissions of methane gas, which can be 20 times more potent than carbon dioxide as a greenhouse gas.

UPDATE: Michael Pollan has asked Poptech not to post his presentation without removing the statistic about the vegan Hummer driver.

“After digging in to it further, and consulting Gidon Eschel, I don’t feel comfortable defending it,” he wrote to Reuters in an email. “It’s much more important to keep the focus on the central thrust of the environmental case against eating industrial meat, which is not in dispute and certainly does not stand or fall on the case of the vegan Hummer driver.”

“Thanks for your doggedness on this matter, which we can hope will stop this meme before it hurts somebody,” he added.

The blogger Fat Knowledge did a separate calculation of the numbers after Eshel and Martin’s paper was published, and concluded:

Going from a Mad Meat Eater diet to a Vegan diet saves 6.5 tonnes of CO2 a year while going from a Hummer to a Prius saves 6.4 tonnes. Given a margin of error on the values, I call that a tie.

The numbers have also shifted as gas mileage improves. Using Eshel and Martin’s calculations with the current EPA mileage statistics, a 2010 model Hummer getting 14-15 miles per gallon has a carbon footprint of 4.3 to 4.7 tons per year, depending on whether it’s an automatic or manual transmission model. (The EPA’s own carbon footprint calculations, which include the manufacture of the vehicle, are significantly higher)

A 2010 Prius getting 50 miles per gallon has a footprint of 1.4 tons. The difference is 2.6 to 3.3 tons per year — not very far from the 2 ton difference between a meat-eater and a vegan.

Click her for more Poptech coverage.

Comments

Truly happy i found it on yahoo.I was talking with my friends sometime back on this topic and I have to say you cleared out a lot of stuffs

 

I thought it was going to be some boring old post, but it really compensated for my time. I will post a link to this web on my blog. I am sure my visitors will find that very useful. . . . BTW if You like poker try poker hand history

 

A spy with flatulence will always blow his cover

 

What hosting company are you using for your blog? I looking hosting for my poker minimum deposit site.

 

As a fellow skilled from the vogue market, I discovered your internet website to be useful. I’ve usually been in appreciate with vogue all my lifestyle so I’ve formulated a forum for marketplace professionals to come back collectively and discuss all issues fashion. I’ve gained a few excellent ideas for my net page from studying this

 

Ryan Conyer

 

Rosario Wienecke

 

Lekisha Yoquelet

 

Thanks for taking the time to talk about this, I think powerfully around it and love learning many on this topic.My site around this best rakeback If realistic, as You gain expertise, would you mind change your blog with much info? It is highly useful for me.

 

It is not known whether or not phentermine will damage an unborn child. Tell your physician if you are pregnant or program to grow to be pregnant although making use of this treatment.

 

Very useful reading. I appreciate your effort, looking forward to your feed updates…

 

Try to acquire Lexapro medicine at the exact same time every single day. Comply with the instructions on your doctor prescribed label.

 

Vuoi scaricare musica gratis?! Visita il qui presente sito web. Cerchi musica da scaricare gratuitamente su internet?

 

Wellbutrin may lead to seizures, particularly in men and women with certain health-related circumstances or when utilizing specific drugs. Inform your physician about all of your health-related problems and the medication you use.

 

Theron Eberspacher

 

Yet another definition for a horizontal portal is, that it is employed as a platform to various businesses in the exact same financial sector or to the exact same kind of producers or distributors.

 

It was very interesting to read this piece of writing! Thank you so much!

 

Mika Ingole

 

hello! I recovered your page on another site .Check my full tilt rakeback site. It’s very well written and it helped me a lot.

 

Sung Millbrand

 

As a fellow expert from the style market, I discovered your net web site to be useful. I’ve constantly been in enjoy with trend all my existence so I’ve created a forum for market experts to come back collectively and discuss all issues style. I’ve gained a couple awesome suggestions for my word wide web web page from studying this

 

Hi i am so happy I located your weblog, I seriously located you by mistake, although I was looking Yahoo for something else, At Any Price I am here now and would just like to say thank you for a wonderful blog posting and a all round intriguing blog (I also adore the theme/design), I don’t have time to learn all of it at the correct now but I have bookmarked it and nice info, this certainly useful for me. There is absolutely nothing to argue about.

 

Good thorough ideas here.I’d like to recommend checking out a lot around the idea of kids. What exactly are you looking for though?

 

Good thorough ideas here.I’d like to recommend checking out things like cheese. What exactly are you looking for though?

 

Good thorough ideas here.I’d like to recommend checking out things like cheese. What are your thoughts?

 

The time period interpersonal reports refers to internet sites exactly where customers submit and vote on press testimonies or other hyperlinks, thus figuring out which back links are introduced.

 

Hello, come and see my sites regarding arcade cell games Free Mobile Games famous ceolebrities Indian Movie Songs and deifferent Watch Music Videos See You

 

Valuable article and wicked website you got here! I would like to thank you for sharing your thoughts and time into the stuff you post!! Thumbs up

 

Great post! Very informative.

 

Have you actually considered adding way more videos to your weblog posts to maintain the readers far more entertained? I mean I just examine through the whole post of yours and it was quite very good but since I’m significantly more of a visual learner,I discovered that being much more helpful well let me know how it turns out! I really enjoy what you men are generally up too. Such clever work and reporting! Maintain up the amazing works guys I’ve additional you men to my blogroll. This is a outstanding post thanks for sharing this informative facts.. I will go to your weblog on a regular basis for some latest article.

 

Appreciate you for this page. Thats all I could say. You most surely have developed this blog site into something speciel. You clearly know what you are executing, youve insured so many bases.kind regards

 

I have been meaning to write about something like this on my blog and this has given me an idea. Thanks.

 

Thanks a lot you for this post. Thats all I can say. You most clearly have crafted this blog into something speciel. You clearly know what you are accomplishing, youve covered so many corners.thanks

 

Hi! :) Is it Okay if I ask anything kinda off matter? I’m wanting to view this page on my new iPad nevertheless it will not present up correctly, do you’ve any solutions? Ought to I attempt and discover an update for my computer software or anything? Thanks upfront! Jennine x :)

 

Interesting! Thanks for this… you always make so much sense to me…

 

Hi! I found your blog on Yahoo.It’s really well written and it helped me a lot. Continue the good work!

 

First time I’ve visited your blog… good find! Thanks.

 

One other nice url article. I shared things like this one going on my Facebook – you can look at adding a “like this” button how to Your website.

 

Just thought I would comment and say cool theme, did you create it for yourself? It’s really awesome!

 

I probably don’t article into sites but Your New homepage forced me To, awesome the office.. Lovely …

 

I’m having a tiny problem I can’t subscribe your feed, I’m using google reader fyi.

 

I genuinely enjoyed this post. We (as a community), appreciate it. I have a related blog on this topic. Do you mind if I link to this post on my site?

 

It is so awesome that I wouldn’t try to ditch this entirely.

 

I found your entry interesting do I’ve added a Trackback to it on my weblog

 

spa hotels in killarney ireland,hotels in killarney ontario canada

 

Interesting post and enjoy reading, he hit on Google while doing some research on this topic. I look forward to reading some more posts from you.

 

Whenever you hear the consensus of scientists agrees on something or other, reach for your wallet, because you’re being had.

 

God colored the sky worth watching, God colored love worth feeling, God colored the planet worth living, Oh dear blogger : God made your blog worth reading.

 

Hey,great post!

 

I probably don’t article into sites but Your New homepage forced me To, awesome the office.. Lovely …

 

Post Your Comment

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
  • About Adam

    "I'm a nine-year Reuters veteran who has covered a range of technology and media beats in New York and London. In 2006 I was the founding Reuters bureau chief in Second Life, a virtual world with its own currency and economy."
    Hometown:
    Ann Arbor, MI
    Joined Reuters:
    2000
    Languages:
    Spanish
  • More from Adam

  • Follow Adam