Afghan Journal

Lifting the veil on conflict, culture and politics

Reintegrating the Taliban: where does it leave Afghan women?

January 28, 2010

At Thursday’s London conference on Afghanistan, some 60 countries will to try flesh out the details for a plan to gradually hand security to Afghans, which involves strengthening and expanding Afghan security forces, improving the way donor aid to Afghanistan is spent and reintegrating Taliban fighters. But where do women fit into these plans, especially if the Taliban are to be involved?

The plan, which has been tried in the past without much success, would involve luring low-level Taliban from the insurgency using jobs and money to re-join Afghan society. There has also been much talk, particularly in the media, about the possibility of dialogue or negotiations with the Taliban.

But many Afghan women, who remember very clearly what life was like under the Taliban from 1996 to 2001, are outraged by the idea.

On Wednesday, groups representing Afghan women warned the international community against pursuing a peace deal with the Taliban. “I have great fears, and I am greatly confused … 2001 was a very clear signal that there is no more room for conservative elements to rule in Afghanistan,”  Homa Sabri of the United Nation’s agency for women, UNIFEM, told Reuters in London.

The women at the meeting, which took place on the sidelines of the conference, also called for greater female representation in any peace process and better access to jobs in the security services and the monitoring of aid which is destined for programmes promoting women’s rights.

The condition of women has improved in the past eight years, but they are still frustratingly far from being able to succeed in public life, even when they are much better qualified than men.

(Reuters/Omar Sobhani)

(Reuters/Omar Sobhani)

Earlier this month, the rejection by Afghanistan’s parliament of two women who President Hamid Karzai nominated to be ministers in his new cabinet, provided a stark and rather sobering reminder of just how difficult it still is for Afghan women to succeed independently and how, in some ways, little beyond rules about the burqa has changed.

While being allowed to go to school and getting a job are great achievements that have not only been a boon to human rights but have also helped Afghanistan’s economy, women are still severely limited in their ability to integrate into the man’s world of politics, where major decisions regarding health, education and the law are made.

The women in question, Dr Suraya Dalil and Palwasha Hassan, were chosen by Karzai after his first list of candidates was criticised for having too few women  and women’s rights advocates lobbied hard on their behalf. Dalil is a Harvard-educated medical doctor who has worked for the United Nations in Nairobi. She had her fair share of backers in parliament too. She has worked for years on issues of child and maternal health — two areas where Afghanistan has huge problems. So what happened?

Dalil was politically independent and declared to parliament when she submitted her programme for the Ministry of Public Health her lack of partiality to any group. Hassan also presented herself as an independent candidate and refrained from aligning herself with any of Afghanistan’s competing political factions. But she has a reputation for being outspoken about the importance of women’s rights. Something some lawmakers said would have also worked against her, but something which arguably would have been an asset in a job like Minister of Women’s Affairs, the portfolio Karzai chose her for.

Some campaigners have said Dalil’s and Palwasha’s transparency and their lack of allegiance to any powerbrokers or political bigwigs in Kabul — many of whom are incidentally under the spotlight in ongoing efforts to tackle widespread corruption — worked against them. But the bottom line is that they are women and that fact, above all else, decided their fate.

(Reuters/Ahmad Masood)

(Reuters/Ahmad Masood)


Isn’t one of the causes of conflict and terrorism the fact that we in the West believe we have the right to impose our beliefs and cultural standards upon other countries? I agree that the treatment of women in many traditional societies is completely unacceptable. But does that give us the right to impose our ideas upon very conservative societies in Third World countries? We can certainly help to educate and support change, but you can’t do that by force of arms. It’s their country not ours.

Posted by John Clark | Report as abusive

It is true that women will be marginalized for a considerable time as long the new crop do not get quality education. Special attention must be paid to educate both elders and kids alike so that all may know what is going on elsewhere in the world. Presently the population at large is cut off from rest of the world. Secondly it is necessary to fish-in those Taliban who have joined the extremist elements due to the poverty below the line. Necessary focus must also be on health, infrastructure, jobs opportunities and other civic related fields. Afghans are hard working people but lack opportunities which must be provided to them faithfully.

Posted by Aftab Kenneth Wilson | Report as abusive

Mutually exclusive events. Reintegrating rock and roll: where does it leave hip hop Women?

Posted by Eden and Apple | Report as abusive

Chuckle where Afghan Tribal peoples plural have always been surrounded by a Renaissance challenged western world hell bent on money slavery and much luck is required to current known square peg round hole western Childish conceptions. Immaculate excluded. But what would I know since I am only a Beekeeper of New Zealand

Posted by Eden and Apple | Report as abusive

The plight of the Afghani women is unfortunate, but also the result of cultural interpretations of Islam based upon feudal interpretations. Perhaps as long as Muslim women are forced or indirectly pressured to wear burqa and be faceless entities in the male dominated societies, their voices will remain unheard no matter the education level. Sadly, Afghanistan has one of the highest infant mortality rates in the world, a sign that the health care and concern about women is substandard.

Posted by LadyElm | Report as abusive

Unfortunately the Plight of substandard education that is forced on women is obviously the result of faceless authorized entities and conceptional legal fictions emaculate or otherwise. But what about the newly descovered huge GAS fields owned by these obviously feudal and stupid tribal people. Now that would be a problem. Much easier indeed to blame and appear to Judge VALUE

Posted by Eden and Apple with wormhole | Report as abusive

Post Your Comment

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see