Comments on: India, Pakistan and the Afghan army

By: ammarah

ammarah — Mon, 31 May 2010 16:25:55 +0000

kyani should solve his country problems 1st. then he is allowing to use his power for any other country. the new policy of Pakistan govt. about education sector is v.v.v.v bad. this policy is about the summer vocations that schools will remain closed from 1st June to 12 September. kyani should realize his responsibilities about his country. he is not a show peace. plzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz sir take an action and relief the strength of country means that the poor for whom this country is being in existence. thnxxxxxxxxxxxxx

By: Ali Khan

Ali Khan — Sun, 18 Apr 2010 10:55:18 +0000

India has no ethnic,cultural or religious ties with afghanistan and its a well known fact tht 71 indo-pak war was a result of indian proxy mukti bhani which resulted in collapse of east pakistan through civil war etc.
Iwas amazed how an indian says PA lost 3 wars?When 48,65 and kargil were won by Pakistan…In48 india was being supported by 18 ordinance factories whole Pakistan didnt even have 4 rice mills.Still u had to run to UN for a cease fire where nehru promised refrendum for Kashmir in offer to Pakistan to stop ceaswe fire.Same happened in 65 when indian head of state went to Tashkent requesting a cease fire while half IAF was destroyed and major landmarks like rajhistan fort,munabad ,khemkaran,ran of kuch were captured by PA…..I hope u guys remember ACEs like M.M Alam 5 kills in less then 1 minute?
Pakistans govt at the time agreed for not going forward in turn Z.A Bhutto became the president for opposing the cease fire?
Also in 71 it was not 90000 POWS it was 4oooo rest were civilians caught by the newly carved bengladeshi,indians and with USSR help…In face to face war u never won a war….
So how can we forget the proxy mindset of indian establishment?when there leaders were creating Mukti bhani terrorists causing a civil war and threatning of using Sindh card?
We cant.Thts why we dont want an indian mindseted army on our North as well as east…also its a positive step in development of our TWIN BROTHER AFGHANISTAN.

By: rex minor

rex minor — Sun, 28 Mar 2010 16:45:30 +0000

I am sorry the article has brought out so many emotional commentry. Let us cool down for a minute. No one has asked our opinion or the agreement. Our comments should be constructive. Let me try.
Neither Afghanistan nor India and Pakistan have national armies. All three armies were raised to suppress their own citizens and are not able to protect their own country borders. The Indian army massacre of the sikhs and criminal suppression of kashmirirs is in their bag, the Pakistan army is not innocent either and have suppressed and lost the eastern wing and have lately been engaged in areal bombimg and use of long range artillery destroying the home land of Pashtoons.
The first order of the day would be to rid afghanistan of the foreign armies which would facilitate the reconcilation of the Afghan folks among themselves. Mr Karzai in my viw is not the ideal but definitely capable of achieving it. After this action it should be easier to raise the Aghan National army, imposing consciption on the Pashtoons as well as the other ethnic groups.
Provided there is peace and reconciliation, the military from Turkey would be the best choice to train the new Afghan army which could take up the security in cities and protect its borders. Pakistan should be politely told to nationalise the structure of their own army which is as of this date basted on the colonial times, some of their muslim regiments are even proud today of having marched against Afghans. Indians should do like wise.

By: Mr. Objective

Mr. Objective — Wed, 17 Mar 2010 16:26:14 +0000

Guys, comparing Pakistan with India is like comparing David with Goliath. India is like that big, burly and strong wrestler whose comparison with a smaller, leaner and weaker person is a defeat in itself for the big guy. If India wins, civilized world will call it a regional bully who picks on smaller (and admitedly weaker) nations to feed its ambition and if India looses in a stand off then the world at large would ridicule India of having been out-witted by a smaller yet smarter country.
Hence my suggestion to Indians is to compare themselves with similar countries like China, USA and Russia and see how many strides they still need to make to come at par with its competitors who are way ahead. Leave Pakistanis to fend for itself for now. They are still a very young nation who are passing through an identidy crises yet faring well against all odds. Unless Pakistanis dont reach the pits of despair they wont come out as a more stronger, resilient and aware nation. Peace be on all of you.

By: Jones

Jones — Wed, 17 Mar 2010 14:42:07 +0000

Its too funny to see Pakistanis, from a country that cannot live without US aid, talking crap about India and Indian Army. Well, looking at the figures like GDP it is evident that which country is REALLY doing good. I would like to advise those people to wake up and come out of their li’l small hole that they dug up!

By: Khan

Khan — Wed, 17 Mar 2010 09:31:16 +0000

Regarding POW, your army having no constraints on supply and having mass deployment in 62 got run by chinese army and more than 5000 got prisoned and thousands ran away while leaving their weapons in few days only.

By: Khan

Khan — Wed, 17 Mar 2010 09:14:10 +0000

@ you are so sure as if you made that video
Please grow up – PA lost 3 war against IA , Should I remind of 1971 war and 90,000 PAW
Afganistan was once India too till Khandar !!, but I am glad the we got rid of pakistan and afganistan and the people who live there on time .
All the Best and I hope still have a country to talk about in next ten years !!

This is another class mate of Mr.Rajeev. Even dont know about the fake video scandals of IA. Or he pretending to be un aware. Mr. Wolf ask Mr. Rajeev about the matter.

You also have your right to console yourself that you won 3 wars but remember lying hardly bring consolation.

We accept our troops got POW in 71. That situation was inevitable for any force of the world keeping in view the geographic constraints, resources, long and disrupted supply line under the enemy’s belly. And after getting independence, creation of Bangladesh was the desirable objective as it was not feasible in practice.

Yes its true once india was Afghanistan and Pakistan or vice versa, little confuse here. Its good to hear that Pakistan came into being and you are happy hmmm oh sorry you dont want it again after ten years in your wet dream.

By: Khan

Khan — Wed, 17 Mar 2010 08:18:05 +0000

And i would not mentioned that only 2 freedom fighters penetrate into indian army camp and fighting for days inside and in the end whole camp get destroyed. I think this you will teach to Afghan Army?

By: Khan

Khan — Wed, 17 Mar 2010 08:06:50 +0000

Pakistan using its gunship, tanks and every available source to fight against terrorist funded by foreign consulates on the border. But you will not find our soldiers whining like children unlike IA when they came under attack in Lal Chowk and caught by camera.

By: Khan

Khan — Wed, 17 Mar 2010 07:55:50 +0000

@I asked you to check PA, not about medals but about the fact that they faced India in wars. They will tell you tales.

Rajeev: Its school time, beta late ho gao ge. You again and again throwing these laughable and childish questions i.e they will tell you etc etc. Better they dont tell me and i dont narrate it here. If you console yourself its another matter.