Afghan Journal

Lifting the veil on conflict, culture and politics

You got to do more, Pakistan tells United States

April 16, 2010
(Standing guard during a night operation in Kunar -  Carlos Barria)

(Standing guard during a night operation in Kunar - Carlos Barria)

The shoe’s on the other foot. The Pakistani army is saying that it’s being let down by U.S. forces in eastern Afghanistan just when it has made hard-fought gains against militants along its stretch of the border.

Some 700 militants have fled a successful military offensive in Pakistan’s Bajaur tribal agency to the Afghan province of Kunar just over the border but no action had been taken against them, according to a Reuters report from the area.

That’s the sort of criticism that U.S. military officials had repeatedly levelled against Pakistan over the past couple of years and only in recent months some of it has quietened down as Islamabad turns up the heat on the Taliban.

Is there really a lack of resolve on the Afghan side of the troubled border? Or is it that the Americans are changing strategy? Foreign troop presence has been thinning in recent months in sparsely populated Kunar under U.S. and NATO commander Lieutenant General Stanley McChrystal’s new counter-strategy focused on improving security in population centres. 

Indeed this week the United States completed its pullout from the remote Korengal outpost in Kunar after four years of trying to crush the insurgency in near daily battles in a place that came to be called the Valley of Death.

Under the new strategy it’s better to put soldiers in cities and towns where they could protect people and help them connect to the Afghan government instead of fighting for isolated mountain regions such as the Korengal.

“The area was once very operationally important, but appropriate to the new strategy, we are focusing our efforts on population centers,”  said U.S. Army Col. Randy George according to a NATO statement announcing the pullout. He said they will still be able to conduct operations there even without the base.

But how will the withdrawal impact Pakistan in its fight with the Taliban? The army says many of its problems in Bajaur where it deployed in late 2008 are now caused by fighters coming over from the border belt where they can find sanctuary and buy arms in a large swathe  of territory up to the Kunar river.

“Afghanistan is the breeding ground for problems in Pakistan, and not the other way around,”  army Col Nauman Saeed said.

Some people are saying the withdrawal of forces undermines Afghan security as much as it does Pakistan’s. Insurgents could use Korengal as a haven to plan attacks in other parts of Afghanistan the Washington Post writes.

It could also offer proof to other Afghans that U.S. troops can be forced out. Though sparsely populated, Kunar and Nuristan provinces have a long history of strident resistance to outsiders. Kunar was one of the first places to rise up against the Soviet occupation in the 1980s, giving the area the label of “cradle of jihad”.  Among the groups that have operated here in the past is the Lashkar-e-Taiba,  long seen to have links with Pakistan’s Inter-Services Intelligence which probably makes the Pakistani task a bit more difficult.


This war can only be ended with authentic talks or dialogs. People who are fighting against Pakistan and US armies have been made terrorist, because of these armies’ terrorism. As on the name of insurgency operations when you kill someone’s family who is indeed innocent, either in Pakistan or in Afghanistan, and do not considered them as human so they react in such a way. I believed terrorist exists, but not only in Muslims, also among all religious groups or nations, so when you target one nation and for sack of victory you kill innocent people so the terrorism couldn’t be withdrawn its instead rise. So I advice to both governments to stop fight against these people but instead develop your defend more crucial for terrorists and do dialogs with those who want to leave weapon, dialogs should not be in a way which recently have been made, where after dialogs killing of innocents again started. And regarding, blaming to each other it is indeed wrong because both armies now are responsible for this fight have a duty to ensure that terrorist of their territories should not be escaped or if does, so other area army should be informed.

Posted by Furqan | Report as abusive

The US needs to pull out completely from Afghanistan


Will Rogers said something like, peace will be had when big countries stop messing with little ones. I was as relevent then as now. It seems strange that the mightiest military ever assembled should be wrapped up in all these little wars, where all we seem to do is generate more terrorism. (these small countries would call them something on the order of freedom fighters).
It’s a pity really that we missed our chance at benevolence.

Posted by Dane | Report as abusive

Interesting piece in the NYT on why the Korengal Valley matters : n/21junger.html?ref=global


Post Your Comment

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see