Alison Frankel

In immigration opinion, 5th Circuit endorses states’ rights to sue U.S.

By Alison Frankel
November 10, 2015

In a 135-page split opinion Monday night, the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld an injunction barring the Obama administration from implementing a policy of deferring deportation actions against more than 4 million undocumented immigrants whose children are U.S. citizens or legal permanent residents of the U.S. The appellate majority, Judges Jerry Smith and Jennifer Elrod, ruled 26 states were likely to prevail in their claims that the Department of Homeland Security violated the Administrative Procedure Act when it instituted a new immigration policy by issuing a memo instead of launching the formal rulemaking process. The Justice Department said Tuesday it intends to ask the U.S. Supreme Court to review the 5th Circuit’s decision.

Labor union dissenters influence political speech more than shareholders: law profs to SCOTUS

By Alison Frankel
November 9, 2015

(Reuters) – Scathing commentary about the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2010 decision in Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission has tended to focus on the court’s refusal to restrict corporate political spending. As you know, the justices struck down campaign finance reforms as an unconstitutional violation of corporations’ free speech rights, triggering an avalanche of predictions that corporate donors would wield outsized political influence. The other free speech beneficiaries of Citizens United – labor unions also subject to the invalidated campaign finance restrictions – haven’t been the subject of nearly as much fear and loathing.

In VW class actions, three trial judges are raring to go

By Alison Frankel
November 5, 2015

On Tuesday, U.S. District Judge Liam O’Grady of Alexandria, Virginia, appointed three plaintiffs’ firms – Cohen Milstein Sellers & Toll, Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check and Cooper & Kirk – to lead the Virginia wing of the ever-expanding clean diesel emissions cheating litigation against Volkswagen.

The evil corrupt plaintiffs’ lawyers do

By Alison Frankel
October 30, 2015

(Quote in 11th paragraph may be objectionable to some readers.)

(Reuters) – If you have a few minutes, watch the YouTube video Texas plaintiffs’ lawyer Mikal Watts of Watts Guerra posted yesterday after the unsealing of a 95-count federal fraud and identity theft indictment against him and six codefendants.

In SCOTUS petition, Apple claims 2nd Circuit used wrong antitrust standard

By Alison Frankel
October 29, 2015

(Reuters) – The e-books antitrust scheme alleged by the Justice Department against Apple and five major book publishers was what’s known in antitrust lingo as a hub-and-spoke conspiracy, in which a central player supposedly enables industry competitors to fix their prices. Now Apple is asking the U.S. Supreme Court to clarify what standard of review should apply to the conduct of that central player: Is its alleged participation a per se violation of antitrust law, as price-fixing amongst competitors is deemed to be? Or should courts be required to evaluate the enabler’s actions under the more forgiving “rule of reason” standard, which takes into account the potentially pre-consumer consequences of restraints on trade?

In defense of trial lawyers advertising for clients

By Alison Frankel
October 27, 2015

The U.S. Chamber’s Institute for Legal Reform came out with a new study Tuesday, highlighting what its president, Lisa Rickard, called “some of the most sophisticated and relentless marketing campaigns in our society” – television and internet advertising by plaintiffs lawyers on the prowl for personal injury clients.

Will class action ascertainability come to SCOTUS through Tyson back door?

By Alison Frankel
October 26, 2015

This summer, the 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals explicitly renounced the reasoning of its fellow judges on the 3rd Circuit on a topic that has become all the rage in class action litigation: ascertainability. The 3rd Circuit has said in a series of cases culminating in its 2013 decision in Carrera v. Bayer that trial judges may not certify classes unless plaintiffs’ lawyers offer a “reliable and administratively feasible” way to figure out who is a class member. The 7th Circuit said the 3rd Circuit analysis throws the class action rules out of balance, giving too much weight to assuring the purity of the class.

Goldman had better brace for a bruising in Tibco market cap case

By Alison Frankel
October 21, 2015

(Reuters) – Judges in Delaware Chancery Court have been saying for years that they are not averse to shareholder M&A suits – just to ill-founded challenges to well-conducted transactions. I’ve been writing a lot lately about Chancery’s crackdown on the latter. But the flip side, as Vice-Chancellor Travis Laster said earlier this month when he rejected a disclosure-only settlement involving Aruba Network’s $3 billion sale to HP, is that judges will let promising shareholder cases move forward.

Lawyers for disgraced Facebook fugitive team up in libel suit v. company

By Alison Frankel
October 20, 2015

(Reuters) – Remember Paul Ceglia, the upstate New York wood pellet salesman who once claimed to own half of Facebook by virtue of a contract he signed with Mark Zuckerberg before Zuckerberg left Harvard? Ceglia’s claims against Facebook and its founder backfired in the most spectacular fashion imaginable. Not only was his civil suit dismissed after a succession of law firms came and went from the case but federal prosecutors in Manhattan charged Ceglia with fraud for allegedly forging the critical document. Ceglia went on the lam last March, along with his family and his dog. He is now considered a federal fugitive.

Goldman asks 2nd Circuit to re-examine price-impact rebuttal standard

By Alison Frankel
October 19, 2015

(Reuters) – As the securities class action bar continues to figure out exactly how the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2014 ruling in Halliburton v. Erica P. John Fund is going to impact shareholder fraud cases, Goldman Sachs and its lawyers at Sullivan & Cromwell want a say.