Obama and the vexed issue of immigration

May 6, 2011

Bernd Debusmann is a Reuters columnist. The opinions expressed are his own.

WASHINGTON, May 6 (Reuters) — It was a pledge that helped Barack Obama win the presidency. “I cannot guarantee that it is going to be in the first 100 days. But what I can guarantee is that we will have in the first year an immigration bill that I strongly support and that I’m promoting.”

That was on May 28, 2008, and it went down well with the largest and fastest growing minority in the United States, Americans of Latin American descent. Of the around 10 million Latinos who went to the polls in November 2008, more than two thirds voted for Obama. For many of them, he has been a disappointment. Once in office, he put immigration on the back burner. He did not push the issue when Democrats had solid majorities in both houses of Congress.

Instead, in the first two years of the Obama presidency, around 1,100 illegal immigrants were deported every day, on average, a pace without precedent. According to the Department of Homeland Security, deportations totaled 387,790 in 2009 and 392,000 in 2010. These are not figures that have endeared Obama to immigrant communities.

Which is why a parade of prominent Latinos, from celebrities (actress Eva Longoria, music producer Emilio Estefan, Maria Elena Salinas of Univision) to business leaders, were invited to meetings at the White House in April and May where Obama talked about immigration and promised renewed efforts to push for Congressional action on immigration reform.

In addition, the White House launched a new website devoted to “President Obama and the Hispanic Community.” Hispanic members of the administration set up a series of conference calls with community leaders to reassure them that Latinos are “an integral part” of Obama’s vision to “out-innovate, out-educate and out-build the rest of the world.”

It’s a hearts-and-minds campaign driven by numbers — census figures released in March showed the Hispanic population at 50.5 million, 12 million of whom are expected to vote in 2012, two million more than in 2008. Another reason for the courtship: reminders that Obama’s 2008 campaign promise has not been forgotten. In the words of Luis Gutierrez, a Democratic congressman from Obama’s home state, “there was a compact. You came to us and you said. ‘elect me president and I will be champion for immigration reform.'”

That stood for a package that would have provided better control of the 2,000-mile border with Mexico, a new visa system, and a path to legal status for the estimated 11 million illegal immigrants, most of them Mexicans, who are already in the country. Prospects for that kind of reform are virtually zero – its Republican opponents insist that before any other changes, the border must be “secure.” They mean entry-proof, something no border ever has been.


The arguments on both sides have not changed since George W. Bush tried to fix the country’s dysfunctional immigration system in his second term in office. His attempt died in the Senate in June 2007 because he could not convince legislators in his own Republican party that illegal immigrants in the country should have the possibility to fix their status.

Last December, a much narrower bill fell five votes short of the 60 votes it needed for passage in the Senate. The DREAM Act (short for Development, Relief, and Education for Alien Minors) would have given legal status to hundreds of thousands of students who were brought to the U.S. by parents who entered the country illegally or overstayed their visas. Many of those the DREAM ACT would have covered have lived almost their entire lives in the country.

Allowing them to stay, in the eyes of immigration hardliners, would be tantamount to amnesty. That is the argument that killed Bush’s reform plan, too.

The word amnesty tends to end rational debate but in April, 22 Democratic Senators wrote a letter to Obama suggesting that he, as “the nation’s chief law enforcement officer”, could exercise his executive powers to suspend deportations and allow the youths to stay. Obama shrugged off the idea. He may come to regret that.

For Latinos to affect the president’s chances of winning a second term, they don’t have to switch allegiance to the Republican party. It’s enough for a substantial number to just sit out the vote. If that happened, his electoral chances would be diminished.

So, Latin leaders can expect more invitations to the White House and more reassuring words. Deeds are another matter.

(You can contact the author at Debusmann@Reuters.com)


We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/

I’m confused. How do illegal immigrants become an increasing part of the electorate? Unless they are also voting illegally.

Posted by Viaphacops | Report as abusive

Viaphacops: Unless you think that each and every one of the 50.5 million Latinos counted in the census are in the U.S. illegally, your statement makes no sense whatsoever. In 2008, about 10 million Latinos voted, in 2012 that number is forecast to rise to 12 million. How does that NOT make them a growing part of the electorate?

Posted by Komment | Report as abusive

Leaders in Mexico and Central America need to get their “stuff” together (kill corruption) so that they can grow their economies and provide jobs.

That will ease the whole illegal immigration issue significantly.

Posted by Parker1227 | Report as abusive

[…] Chronicle (blog)Hispanic Lawmakers To Obama: Do More On Immigration PolicyHuffington PostObama and the vexed issue of immigrationReuters Blogs (blog)NPRall 19 news […]

Posted by 5/8/2011 News Update « PresObama | Report as abusive

This whole post completely ignores, o I don’t know, the whole enormous nearly world ending economic collapse that sapped Obama’s attention. Oh ya, and those wars he’s trying to end, and getting binLaden, and making sure that the Latinos get healthcare reform. Bloody hell people are so self-centered and naive it’s painful… it’s no wonder that the radical right is so strong in America, at least they stand up for their leaders instead of tear them down if they don’t get their pork. I swear you people just look for excuses to be offended!

Posted by CDN_Rebel | Report as abusive

[…] Michelle …Los Angeles TimesObama set for Texas visit on TuesdayBusinessWeekABC News (blog) -Reuters Blogs (blog) -AFPall 489 news articles […]

Posted by Hispanic Lawmakers To Obama: Do More On Immigration Policy – Huffington Post | Presidential-Race.net | Report as abusive

[…] Michelle …Los Angeles TimesObama set for Texas visit on TuesdayBusinessWeekABC News (blog) -Reuters Blogs (blog) -AFPall 489 news articles […]

Posted by Hispanic Lawmakers To Obama: Do More On Immigration Policy – Huffington Post | Hate Trump | Report as abusive

The Slave of the Husband…

Looking for ahead to finding out added from you afterward!……

Posted by Willy Brizeno | Report as abusive