Namir Noor-Eldeen and Saeed Chmagh

July 13, 2007

So frequent is the incidence of violent death in Iraq now that news media tend to report only multiple fatalities — fifty killed by a truck bomb, the bodies of thirty workmen found in a Baghdad suburb, five killed by an improvised roadside bomb. These numbers have no faces and it is left to the photographers and camera crews to show us the people behind the statistics. Even so these events are unfolding a world away from many of us but when colleagues and friends are among the victims the scale of the suffering is brought into pin sharp focus.Namir smiling

Yesterday two Reuters colleagues, photographer Namir Noor-Eldeen and driver Saeed Chmagh were killed in Baghdad. Namir was only 23 but had already produced a body of work which stands as testament to his talent and energy and the potential he will never now fulfil. Saeed, 40, married with four children was not a journalist but no less dedicated to covering the news and one of the largely unsung local heroes without whom it would be impossible to report the story on the ground.

The following are among the tributes to the two men received from colleagues and friends.

Dean Yates, Baghdad bureau chief: “Namir and Saeed were much loved members of the Baghdad bureau. They were always smiling and cheerful despite the horror in their country and the risks they took in their work. Their deaths leave a big hole in the Baghdad operation that will never be filled. We deeply mourn the loss of our colleagues and friends. The Baghdad bureau has been flooded with messages of sympathy from Reuters staff all over the world. This is a testament to the bravery and dedication of our Iraqi staff.”

Alastair Macdonald, former Baghdad bureau chief: “It seems like yesterday Namir was dancing with us in the garden, taking pictures all the while, and Saeed was smiling proudly, always seeming like he was looking after us all. We are all going to miss them both terribly. Namir was our favourite little brother with a big heart and a great talent, who achieved great things in such a short time.”

Steve Crisp, Middle East Pictures Editor: “On Namir, what can I say but such a tragic waste of such an outstanding young talent. Namir had boundless enthusiasm and always wanted to help. I will treasure the time I spent sat in the garden in 45 degrees plus heat filing pictures from my laptop over the satphone because the office comms were down and watching him work on setting up colleagues laptops and satphones into the early hours. I can still see him walking out of the compound with his cameras slung over his shoulders laughing with Saeed on his way to his last assignment.”

Tributes specifically to Saeed Chmagh:
Thaer al-Sudani, 30, Reuters photographer, Baghdad:

“Saeed was a driver who truly protected us photographers. He would always be at our side no matter how much risk he was putting himself in. Many of us felt he was a better shield than an armoured vehicle. He would always tell me that he would not hesitate to lose his life to protect one of us. Sadly, he was right.”

Saad Shalash, 28, Reuters driver, Baghdad:

“Abu Salwan had a kind heart with no sectarian hatred. He loved his work and always protected the journalists. He would never stay out of contact with his friends for too long and would always strive to be there at your time in need. He never upset anyone and was always a very quiet man.”

Muhannad Mohammed, 35, Reuters driver, Baghdad:

“He was a very simple person who avoided trouble at all costs. He helped everyone and would never let two colleagues argue. Whenever someone did he would mediate to ensure we kept a friendly atmosphere in the bureau.”

Atheer Salim, 28, Reuters driver, Baghdad:

“I knew him before the war even began. He was a man of principles and high values. He used to always think of his family, especially his mother and father who needed constant medical care after his younger brother died in an accident. He was the only man who supported them and three other families. He was the peacemaker of the office.”

Mussab Al-Khairalla, 25, Reuters reporter, Baghdad:

“Saeed was a very humble and polite gentleman. He was a very loyal friend who was there for you at every moment. Saeed supported three families as well as his parents but never complained of the burden and even committed himself to helping other families in his neighbourhood.”

——————————–

Tributes to Namir Noor-Eldeen:

Thaer al-Sudani, Reuters photographer, Baghdad:

“Namir was a brother before he was a colleague. His presence always lightened up the mood in the office. He was a very courageous man who had a great eye for a photograph. He was a very generous man who began to give away a lot of his belongings to friends. He had all the attributes of a great gentleman.”

Sattar Raheem, 40, Reuters cameraman, Baghdad:

“We always remember his smile. He was a special man who was trustworthy and always keeps his word.”

Saad Shalash, Reuters driver, Baghdad:

“However I describe this man I will not be doing him justice. If you asked him for money, he would borrow off someone else to help you out. He always felt an obligation to help the weak.”

Muhannad Mohammed, Reuters driver, Baghdad:

“I treated Namir like a younger brother. He always asked me for his opinion and I felt he was very happy with his succesful career and had huge ambitions for his future.”

Atheer Salim, Reuters driver, Baghdad:
“I loved his outgoing personality. He loved to help whenever he could. The nice thing about him was his unlimited generosity in addition to his bravery and cool head. We used to nickname him “The Tiger” in the office because the word fear doesn’t appear in his dictionary.”

Namir was one of the first Iraqi photographers that I met in Baghdads office before my embed with U.S. troops this March and he was so curious how to fix Kareem Raheems, another wide angle lens with a simple mini screwdriver. So I made him happy to check his photo equipment to tie up all his screws. Following his work over the past it was fantastic now to know personally the face behind his pictures, to talk about photography, laugh about the life during dinner in the courtyard of the Reuters office and to discuss about the daily life in Iraq. I was curious to listens when he was talking about his daily life during this terrible war. The hard working circumstances when he get out to cover a story and he was like sponge when I told him about how it is to life and work in a peaceful country, like Germany. What a gap, but both of us are journalists and Iraqi journalists are risking daily their life to witness the war for the world that we dont forget what really happens in the streets of Baghdad.

Every one of us has to have a lot of respect about their work! Saeed Chmagh was one of the drivers, who drove me back to the airport before living for Amman and before we said good bye, we said to each other: take care and be save! Sometimes its just a catchword, but when you work and live in Iraq you hope always that y return home save and alive. We lost two fantastic colleagues and persons.

Chris Helgren, Reuters Chief Photographer, Rome:

“In the world’s most dangerous country, where the deathtoll is more of a statistic than tangible reality, it would be easy to shuffle off the memories of another two journalists. But this is more difficult given the body of work produced by photographer Namir Noor-Eldeen, who was killed along with longtime and driver Saeed Chmagh. While the questions of who did it or why is up in the air, friends and colleagues are grieving, and photographers will see yet another great portfolio pass into the archives.

When he first came to my attention, Namir was an energetic teenager in the northern city of Mosul whose family was involved in photography and video. He took an interest in the trade and with training, and a few critiques, it quickly became obvious he was going to become one of the new stars in Iraqi photojournalism. He had an urgency that suited the front pages of the news business but also a tender eye that brought humanity via quiet moments to a vicious war. One of the first pictures he sent me was of bewildered U.S. Army soldiers surrounded by a flock of sheep, another I remember was of a wounded Kurdish girl with her legs in bandages while wrapped in a faux fur coat, or one of a boy picking up shards of broken plates in the family dining room after an ammunition dump blast rocked their house.

Unfortunately, instead of the sight of UK photographers arriving en masse to a football match or entertainment event, Iraqis head off to work to document tragedy. There are few “good news” stories to be had in this war, and wars by definition are tales of violence. And to get there, drivers like Saeed Chmagh are indispensible. Saeed had a reputation of being fiercely loyal, and appeared fearless to me. If you ever needed to get quickly to a dangerous area, passing chicanes of barbed wire and boobytraps, Saeed was your man. But he also had a very quiet, loving side and spoke often of his kids. He leaves a wife and four children.

The deaths of these two men will hit the small photographic community in Baghdad very hard. They are the latest in a far too long list of our colleagues, from several news agencies, who have fallen in this war. They will not be the last, but I would hope that they would be remembered as people and not numbers.”

Bob Strong, former Chief Photographer, Iraq

Namir was an editors dream. He was the best photographer in Mosul, he was on top of every story, and if he didn’t shoot the pictures himself, he knew where to find them. His nose had been broken more than once, he’d been shot in the leg, detained, harrassed and threatened, but his quick smile and energy never faded. He lived more in 22 years than most people do in a lifetime and it’s very very sad to know I’ll never get one of his bearhug greetings again.

Saeed was such a gentle man in a chaotic and violent world, I sometimes wondered how he managed to survive. He took me to the Green Zone one day in 2004, and on the way back he got a call from his wife. His face lit up as he spoke to her, and when the call ended he turned to me smiling and said by way of explaination in his broken english, ‘my habibti, my wife, my love’. In the midst of suffering and daily carnage, Saeed could still laugh and show up for work everyday.

My deepest sympathies to the families of Namir and Saeed.

A tribute to Namir’s work has been compiled by his colleagues.

Comments

dear sirs.i am afraid that the most recent deaths of your 2 members in Iraq was not an accident but a targetted murder. i am afraid that the usa has now adopted the IDF’s policy of shooting the reporters because they may 1. be terrorists in disguise or 2. traitors who may be concealing a weapon. i pass along my deepest sypathies. i understand that accidents happen in war but i do not believe this to be the case here. i do think that these deaths signal an open season on journalists in Iraq as an unspoken policy by the usa military and that we will be seeing more journalist dying with increased frequency in the future. i hope your news bosses protest strongly and publicly.again i pass on my shared sorrow in this tragity.david campbell

Posted by david campbell | Report as abusive
 

David,Thank you for your words of support and condolence, which I will pass on to the families of Namir and Saeed. We don’t yet know the full circumstances in which they died but I hope you are wrong in your suspicion that they were deliberately targeted. Rest assured we will not hesitate to take appropriate action when all the facts are known.Regards,David Viggers

Posted by David Viggers | Report as abusive
 

I known and worked with Namir and Saeed when I was in Baghdad. They are such brave dedicated men. Namir’s photos were amazing and Saeed’s efforts and courage was priceless and essential for the photographers he worked with.May God have mercy on them both and grant their families patience for their loss.They will join the Reuters convoy of Martyrs since the US invasion and they shall and should not be forgotten.May God the Almighty protect my colleagues and friends at Reuters Baghdad and all other journalists across Iraq.

Posted by Omar Anwar | Report as abusive
 

As a young photojournalist myself, I appreciated Namir’s work and looked at it every time it appear on Reuters.May God have mercy on both these mens souls.They will not be forgotten.

Posted by Ryan S. Miller | Report as abusive
 

Benjamin Franklin once said, and I am paraphrasing “I have never seen a good time of war, or a bad time of peace” My deepest condolences to the families of these two men, and may God watch over all those who find themselves in the shadow of this war.

Posted by Allen Thompson | Report as abusive
 

To david campbell,Your theories have no basis, and you should be ashamed. However, nobody bothers to read your post with any seriousness, mainly due to the fact that in your infinite wisdom, you forgot to properly spell a few key words.”targetted” = targeted”sypathies” = sympathiesand my favorite, “tragity” = tragedy.What happened was obviously a “tragity”, and i empathize with these men. But I assure you, as a personal friend of many soldiers, and as an American, it was not a planned hit. Next, people will claim car bombs and IEDs are really made by American soldiers.

Posted by Dum Bass | Report as abusive
 

I was looking through the sample of Namir Noor-Eldeen’s work that is up on your pictures section, with no prior knowledge of the tragic events that occured to him and Saeed Chmagh. As I looked through the pictures I had an overwhelming urge to contact Namir and praise him for the work he was doing, with every picture my heart ached for the fact that these atrocities are being faced by too many people every single day. People.. like me.. And then I got nearer the end and saw the picture of Saeed and I read what had happened. A pain surged through me. And I am but a stranger. More people need to see Namir’s pictures. These photos are the REALITY, not the nonsense we hear our governments blithering on about. We must do something. If only but ensure more people see his pictures.

Posted by Tamara Al-Om | Report as abusive
 

Shame on you Dum Bass. This forum is meant for tributes to the brave men who sacrificed their lives for the good of mankind. Please don’t bring petty gripes into the comments, and leave out the personalities.In my ignorance I was unaware of these men and their work and dedication, until I received an email from a member of my family. I am truly disturbed and grateful to them and all others similarly risking sacrificing themselves. God bless their families for their acceptance.

Posted by Evelyn Al-Om | Report as abusive
 

Like Tamara Al-Om, I too was looking through Namir Noor-Eldeen’s work with no knowlegde of the fact that he had been killed. His work tells the true story of Iraq to people like me & I wanted to let you know how much I admired his work. I only discovered that he had died at the end of the portfolio & it brought tears to my eyes. I feel very sad that so many innocent people like Namir Noor-Eldeen & Saeed Chmagh must pay with their lives in this senseless violence and all of the pain that their families & friends are suffering. Please keep Namir Noor-Eldeen’s work public so that the truth is seen.Thank you.

 

It turns out David Campbell was right.

May the victims rest in peace.

Posted by emanonn | Report as abusive
 

I would also like to add, if possible, that the behavior seen in the military action that killed Mr. Namir Noor-Eldeen and the other unfortunate victims is tactically wrong and in violation of the Geneva Convention on Human Rights.
The video shows clearly how the operation not only slays the initial 11-12 men but also attacks a van (yelding the last 2 adult victims and severly injuring – if not killing – 2 innocent children on board) who clearly and without any doubt was not posing any threat nor was maneuvering aggressively but was openly attempting to RESCUE a wounded man on the ground.
Attacking any person/organization/vehicle in the act of helping the wounded on a battlefield is PROHIBITED by the Geneva Convention.
I believe Mr. Obama at this point should honestly and publicly give up the Nobel Prize for Peace (….), maybe such a sorrowful act by the US President and the national shame that would come after could move something within the Pentagon and bring this “cow-boy” like army back to a decent status and behavior.
Claude

Posted by ClaudeTadolti | Report as abusive
 

David Campbell was right. The truth is different than official story.

Posted by Matthias001 | Report as abusive
 

Now that we are closer to the truth about these horrific events, it seems fair to say that these men were not “killed,” but something evidently much closer to “murdered.” Indiscriminate slaughter by American troops I call murder. The helocopter gunmen in question should be dealt with by the courts, and if the video released yesterday is accurate, they should spend the rest of their natural lives behind bars. The families of the dead should be fully compensated. The US government is not, at least yet, judgement proof.

Posted by johnlewisgrant | Report as abusive
 

If you view the full video, the camera man points his camera around a corner, taking a photo of a Bradley tank down the road, as mentioned in the radio chatter. From the helicopter, the camera looks like a rocket propelled grenade was aimed at American forces, if you listen to the radio chatter.

As the the group walks across the courtyard, the full version video shows three men, not in the shortened video, clearly carrying weapons, rifles and what appears to be a long barreled grenade launcher. Since American forces were fighting insurgents in the area, and the helicopters were providing cover, engagement was permitted.

Unfortunately, they killed the camera men, however, they did kill the other insurgents carrying weapons.

The vehicle on the ground could have contained weapons and since American forces were in the area, the helicopter crew felt engagement was necessary.

No war crimes were committed. Just an unfortunate incident for the camera crew working with insurgent forces.

Posted by johnjjt | Report as abusive
 

Granted, then gunmen who fired from the Apache helicopters were not out to kill journalists. They were out to kill (‘take out’) violent insurgents.

Yet it is obvious even to us, who are not military personnel, that there was no imminent danger and no convincing indication whatsoever that these men were violent insurgents, or that they carried dangerous weapons.

In short: the US gunmen had no reason to kill these men. Yet they killed them, ruthlessly.

Follows the incident with the black van. Even to a layman’s eye, the drivers of the van had no bad intentions: they wanted to transport the body of an injured man. Shooting at these drivers and at their car is clearly a violation of the Geneva act, thus it is a war crime.

The REAL war crime is that high up in the Pentagon and high up in NATO, such rules of engagement are handed out, and that war crimes of our own men are never sentenced in court.

Posted by hminkema | Report as abusive
 

Why are we there again?

From what I understand this country is in huge debt, should we not be saving our money instead of using it to destroy in a time were we should be building.

The audio on the video found at http://www.collateralmurder.com/ does not sound like professional personnel doing a job, but instead of some young kids playing xbox at home. Is this what we have come to, people having fun killing on our tax dollars?

Watching this video made me so sad to be a human.

Posted by Deyson | Report as abusive
 

Lockerbie set the legal standard for state sponsored killing of civilians at ten million dollars per murdered human. When the cost of “remotely” killing civilians is ten million dollars, positive identification and engagement of the “enemy” by on-the-ground soldiers becomes more cost effective. Governments must be held to the highest standards of warfare. The killing of civilians must have financial consequences for their military actions. To value one murdered group more is raceism.

Posted by hi5kenn | Report as abusive
 

Atrocities like this are a result of Americans unwillingness to face the truth about why we were attacked on 9/11. It had nothing to do with others hating our freedoms and democracy and everything to do with our policies toward the rest of the world. And yet half of America will believe the murders of Namir and Saeed are justifiable because of 9/11. It’s sickening.

Posted by poptop | Report as abusive
 

I think it may be easy for people to lose sight of common human priorities, maybe in the name of “progress,” “development,” or some other term which we come to believe in. Most of us are probably guilty of this. I for one feel that I have neglected family, friends and my emotional health, at times, for career. I am sure that the Blackhawk pilot (gunman?) had invested much of his life in developing his own military value. Let us not only become something we invest in however, especially if this might render us blind to some very fundamentals. Soldier: “Well, don’t bring children to a battle.” Wrong. “You don’t bring battle to children.” I am saddened and angered that this is happening in my world.

Posted by seanrourke111 | Report as abusive
 

It is clear from the language used by the soldiers, that they are just looking for ‘action’, any action, at any cost.A close reading of the exchanges in the dialogue, will reveal that this was not a ‘mistake’ this was a vicious ‘video game’. We can focus on the images, verey revealing as well, but the language does not leave a trace of doubt.

Posted by projectsinexile | Report as abusive
 

This is horrible news, so awful to lose such dedicated, kind men. My hopes are with their families and friends and with you, their colleagues.

Posted by aphid | Report as abusive
 
  •