Just don’t tell markets it’s not a V-shape

October 15, 2009

In a speech earlier this week, the Federal Reserve’s No. 2, Donald Kohn, couldn’t have been plainer when he said he does not expect the economy to snap back in a classic V-shape recovery.

The markets have a much rosier view. The Dow Jones industrial average has pushed through 10,000, JPMorgan Chase and Goldman Sachs are reporting eye-popping gains and the economic data have been notably perkier — with the glaring exception of employment. Even Treasury yields have reversed course after months of declines.

Enjoy it while it lasts. The gains in risky markets, and to some extent, safer ones, continue to be driven by the aftershocks of government policy rather than the deep roots of a recovery.

Some of that reality may be starting to dawn on investors. Today, the Dow slipped back a bit after Goldman’s stellar results — $5.25 earnings per share — failed to top lofty, whisper numbers circulating on trading desks ahead of the release. The fact that the bulk of the earnings came from trading also gave rise to concerns that its blow-out could be a one-hit wonder.

Still, the Dow is up more than 50 percent from its low in March and the latest round of economic data may continue to fuel hopes that the hard road ahead may be easier than Fed officials suggest. New York area manufacturing activity rose to a five-year high in October, while its employment measures moved into positive territory for the first time in a year, according to the latest survey by the New York Fed. The consumer prices report, meanwhile, showed that inflation is still tame while another leg down in jobless claims lent some optimism that even the labor market could be showing some sign of improvement.

There are plenty of caveats to the data, however. One, the New York area is hardly the capital of U.S. manufacturing, so while the gains are noteworthy, they shouldn’t necessarily be extrapolated to the rest of the country. Philadelphia’s survey in fact reported a slowdown in October from the previous month.

It’s no coincidence that the rally in riskier assets started in March, a month when the Fed hit turbo drive on its already easy monetary policy. And much of the gains since then have been the result of a recalibration of funds that had leaned heavily in hyper-safe investments like Treasury bills.

The economy and financial system are still a far way from heading back to normal. As my colleague Matthew Goldstein noted on Wednesday, JP Morgan’s $28 billion in net revenues said more about the prowess of its traders than a recovery in Main Street credit.

And the jobs picture alone is enough to keep over-extended consumers cautious for some time to come.

An ultra-easy credit policy will keep markets primed for some time to come, which is sure to test the will of the Federal Reserve, especially if Treasury yields continue to rise. It’s safe to say that no one at the Fed wants to create yet more asset bubbles, but Fed officials are right to stay focused on the very real risk of the economic recovery not taking hold.

Comments

This recession will be over when the credit crunch will be over, and unemployment will go down.
We’re not anywhere near.

Posted by yr | Report as abusive
 

The market has continued to go up despite warnings from all corners of the business community. What we have witnessed in 2008 was something not experienced by anyone in the market and the insuing market recovery won’t be easily understood by most market participants for the same reason

Posted by Fadhel | Report as abusive
 

A very timely observation about a promised recovery not taking hold. It will not if U.S. economic policy continues to be guided by business-as-usual mindset. A radical and coheren change in economic policies is urgently needed since economic health of America is too vital for global economy. One should turn back to 1932 which also raised hopes of a recovery after the 1930-31 cuclical recession. But President Hoover’s administration relied more on the power of the market.So 1933 saw a deeper dip in economy,a deflation, a run on banks along with sky-rocketing unemployment. All that resulted in long depression
To-day’s America has two growth engines that may prevent a depression now around the corner (see http://www.squidoo.com/phil-stillcan). This is two MICs – military-industrial complex and medical-industrial complex, that have proved their resilience in the current recession. Along with President Obama’s stimulus package the MICs can absorb excess labor, if the growth engines are supported by relevant industrial policies.

Posted by Felix Goryunov | Report as abusive
 

Post Your Comment

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/