Contingent capital and the black horse’s head

November 3, 2009

Lloyds seems to be taking a leaf out of Vito Corleone’s book: if you need someone to do something that they don’t want to, you have to make them an offer they can’t refuse. For the mafia boss in The Godfather, that meant decapitating a horse. For Lloyds, the UK bank whose logo is a black horse, it means threatening to cut off interest payments on your own debt.

Lloyds’ plan is to convert subordinated debt into 7.5 billion pounds of contingent capital. These new-fangled securities pay out fixed coupons, but can be converted into shares in times of need. The exchange is part of Lloyds’ efforts to avoid the government’s asset protection scheme. Lloyds is likely to pull off this deal, but the jury is still out on whether this kind of capital will be widely used by other banks.

Regulators like the idea of contingent capital because it is better able to absorb losses than subordinated debt. The new Lloyds bonds are classified as lower tier two capital, but the Financial Services Authority includes them as part of the bank’s core capital when conducting stress tests.

However, contingent capital is untested. It is not clear what price investors will demand to hold debt that carries a risk of turning into equity if things go wrong. The proposed exchange could also be problematic. Many fixed income investors aren’t allowed to buy equity-linked debt.

As a result, Lloyds is paying up to get investors on board. They get to switch out of their existing debt into the new contingent capital at par, and get a coupon that is up to 2.5 percent higher than the one they’re getting at the moment. For investors who bought the debt below par — some Lloyds bonds traded as low as 15 percent of face value last March — this means a healthy pay day.

The sweeter coupon alone probably wouldn’t clinch it. Many investors would rather stick with what they have rather than accept an untested instrument which may trade poorly and could be forcibly converted into shares at a later date.

Enter the European Commission, with which Lloyds has been negotiating over state aid. The Commission is compelling Lloyds to cut off coupon payments for up to two years on bonds where it has the right to defer interest. This should help investors with any lingering doubts to make up their minds.

A healthy appetite for the bonds will be a boon for Lloyds, but it doesn’t necessarily mean contingent capital will catch on. For one, it is very expensive: Lloyds is paying interest of up to 16 percent on its bonds. Not every bank will want to pay that.

The capital has other advantages: interest payments are likely to be tax-deductible, and is less dilutive to shareholders than issuing ordinary shares. Moreover, as regulators push banks to improve the quantity and quality of their capital, they will need to explore every possible source of funding.

Still, not every bank is in as dire a situation as Lloyds. Without mafia-style coercion, these kind of large-scale debt exchanges will be harder to pull off.

One comment

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see

[…] Neil Unmack points out that this is a coercive exchange: However, contingent capital is untested. It is not clear what price investors will demand to hold […]

Posted by PrefBlog » Blog Archive » Lloyds Issues Contingent Capital | Report as abusive

I am lost, you write about capital, debt and bonds in one breath.

Anyhow, Lloyds is a syndicate of members (similar to an ‘association’), they can do what they want to, as long as they don’t break laws.

Maybe now a Dark Horse ?

Posted by Casper | Report as abusive

[…] which would turn into equity if the bank’s tier one capital drops below a certain trigger. This has the disadvantage of costing Lloyds a lot, as Neil Unmack points out: the coupon is up to 16 per cent. It is also, as […]

Posted by | FTdotcomment | CoCo farming shows the true value of government guarantees | Report as abusive