Strong yen is not Japan’s main problem

August 30, 2010

You wouldn’t know it to hear officials talk, but the strong yen is not Japan’s main problem. The Bank of Japan’s latest moves on Monday didn’t weaken the currency — though that is one broad objective of fiscal and monetary stimulus. In any case, the trade-weighted yen is weaker than its real 1990-2010 average and Japanese exports are still rising. Export lobbies may have the government’s ear, but intervention could make Japan’s domestic predicament worse.

When the Democratic Party of Japan took office last year, its leaders talked about putting more emphasis on Japan’s domestic economy rather than the needs of major exporters, which had been favored by Liberal Democratic Party administrations since 1955. The DPJ’s first finance minister, Hirohisa Fujii, said at his introductory press conference last September that he was opposed in principle to currency intervention because it could distort the economy.

Fujii was, however, forced out after less than four months, and some officials have reverted to blaming the rising yen for Japan’s problems. Direct currency intervention, though not yet tried by the DPJ, looks more likely than ever, too. Yet the yen’s trade-weighted exchange rate, corrected for differences in inflation, remains about 6 percent below the average of the last 20 years. True, the yen did last week hit a 15-year peak of less than 84 against the dollar and remains far stronger than its 20-year average of around 100. But the comparison with the trade-weighted figure underlines the extent to which that reflects the dollar’s overall weakness.

Meanwhile, exports are hardly suffering badly from the strengthening yen. In July, they were up 2 percent on the month and 23.5 percent from the previous year. Japan also continues to run a large current account surplus.

Even deflation shouldn’t be the Japanese government’s biggest worry. Consumer prices have, in fact, fluctuated within a 5 percentage point range since 1992. Rather, the number one challenge is excessive government spending, which has brought continuing fiscal deficits and government debt amounting to more than 200 percent of GDP.

By skating over this and majoring on the yen — particularly against the dollar — Japanese policymakers risk retaliatory currency interventions. Those beggar-my-neighbor battles worsened global economic conditions in the 1930s and would do so again now.

Comments

If Japan runs a trade surplus but has large fiscal deficits caused by huge welfare spending, all it has to do is cut public spending, right?
I can’t believe it’s that easy. The UK & US have large govt spending and large trade deficits, but they’re not experiencing what Japan has.
And why is a currency in (intrinsic) danger from debt default regarded as a safe haven by investors? Surely if the country is making tons of money but spending even more, that’s a bad investment?
These and about 437 other things make up the too-easily rationalised nonsense that is national accounting and the global financing of capitalism. I’m a capitalist born and bred but too much capital in 2010 is notional rather than practical.
We need reform and we need it now.
http://nbyslog.blogspot.com/2010/08/bern anke-in-wyoming-blind-mans-bluff.html

Posted by nbywardslog | Report as abusive
 

Gee, politicians spending too much. Is that what the problem is? Ya think?

Posted by Gotthardbahn | Report as abusive
 

It’s not that easy for Japan to cut spending. Their citizens demand a certain amount of services from the government and it will be political suicide to trim it even slightly. I have faith in Japan; they’ll figure something out.

Posted by franwex | Report as abusive
 

Atually the politicians of Japan are useless, they have no ideas how to handle the situation. Just by leanding more money the market wont change anything as no big or medium size company are asking for the money right now, everyone wants stability, the government has huge public debt and they have to think about it, by cutting public debt and wasteful expences.
But right now they should intervene the currency market and try to get the yen around 95 to 100 level, which will help the exporters and the economy and help japan to finish the deflation which is every important for Japan recovery and stability.
We need the things to fix up right now or it will be end to a great country and their very helpful & hard working people.

Posted by bothra | Report as abusive
 

Post Your Comment

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/