Is Wal-Mart pulling a Circuit City on Best Buy?

December 14, 2010

The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions expressed are his own.

Is Wal-Mart pulling a Circuit City on Best Buy? Two years ago, the mega-retailer’s electronics push helped send Circuit City into bankruptcy and eventual liquidation. Best Buy thrived for a time on its rival’s misfortunes. But its own falling same-store sales suggest it may be the next weak link in the retail food chain.

Sales fell 3 percent in the quarter compared to the same period last year. Yet domestic same-store sales fell 5 percent. The company said TVs, laptops and video games did particularly poorly. It could be that many wealthier consumers have recently stocked up on such higher-end devices, so the sector is missing out on healthy holiday spending. U.S. spending on retail and food rose an estimated 7.6 percent in November in seasonally adjusted terms. Sales at electronic and appliance stores rose just 0.9 percent.

But the retailer admitted price wars are doing particular damage to its business. It pinned most of its shortfall on discount retailers selling no-name brands for cheap. That should be read as Wal-Mart, which has been making a concerted effort to increase electronics sales, not least to get shoppers into its giant stores where it can sell them a broader array of products. Best Buy estimates its market share fell by more than 1 percent.

Internet rivals are also playing a part. Best Buy’s online sales in the quarter grew 7 percent compared to last year. Amazon’s North American “electronics and other general merchandise” sales is grew 80 percent last quarter. Sure, the figures aren’t directly comparable. But it’s notable that Best Buy’s online efforts are growing slower than retail sales as a whole, while Amazon is growing at an incredibly robust pace.

While this may be just a one-quarter hiccup, investors should be wary. Wal-Mart’s scale means it can continue to offer lower prices. Best Buy claims it has an edge with its more knowledgeable sales staff. That’s not always apparent to shoppers. If the company has to improve its efforts in this regard, by hiring more sales help, margins may be pressured. Best Buy’s stock may appear reasonably cheap at nine times estimated earnings for next year. But Wal-Mart’s nibbling on its business may just presage a bigger bite to come.


We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see

Are there any federal or state regulations that can stop this monopoly. All they really have to do is compare prices of Wal-Marts in area’s that they have killed off the majority of their competition to the prices of Great Wall-Marts that are moving in and it should be no surprise to see that their everyday low prices are competition specific. No matter since the Waltons will probably get lots of tax breaks and give graciously to the peasants since keeping their political influence and relatives on the boards of these charities while they support foreign scab labor and companies that pollute the environment seems to be what we call capitalism these days.

Posted by ROWnine | Report as abusive

One way they can stop Wal-mart is to stop subsidizing them…Wal-Mart stores receive sales tax breaks and huge sums for constructing their buildings from state and local govts.

Posted by sdwilk | Report as abusive