Tech guru may be best hope for News Corp holders

July 11, 2011

By Jeffrey Goldfarb
The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions expressed are his own.

NEW YORK –The best hope for News Corp shareholders may be Thomas Perkins. The renowned American venture capitalist is the closest thing to a truly independent director amid the roster of Rupert Murdoch cronies. Perkins also has some relevant experience: he quit the board of Hewlett-Packard five years ago over a phone-hacking scandal. That makes him a prime candidate to lead the charge for a badly needed overhaul of News Corp’s governance.

News Corp shares have tumbled 14 percent over the last week, as phone-hacking and other malfeasance at the News of the World brought the abrupt closure of the UK tabloid paper and then raised the specter of News Corp losing its grip on BSkyB, the British satellite TV group. Though shareholders bought in knowing that Murdoch calls the shots, they’re still entitled to expect independent directors to fight their corner.

The company needs a fully independent inquiry into what happened, a critical assessment of its current businesses and strategy and an objective review of governance, among other things. Yet there isn’t much non-partisan thinking to be found on the News Corp board. Though nine of the 15 directors up for election last August met Nasdaq’s standards for independence, they mostly don’t really reflect the word’s meaning.

Kenneth Cowley ran a News Corp division for years and has served on the board for over three decades. Andrew Knight was chairman of News International, the division now under scrutiny, before becoming a director in 1994. John Thornton, now a professor in China, helped win business from Murdoch when he was president of Goldman Sachs. Few of the supposed independents lack a history with News Corp or its boss. Jose Maria Aznar, a former prime minister of Spain, hardly seems likely to take a stand, either.

So the responsibility may fall on Perkins’ shoulders. His own phone records were hacked when Patricia Dunn, then chairman of HP, hired investigators to uncover board leaks. He resigned, later talking of “the questionable ethics and the dubious legality” of the methods used. Perkins, a founder of Kleiner Perkins Caufield & Byers, also used the episode as a platform to rail against tick-the-box corporate governance, which he said was increasingly substituting for judgment. News Corp’s mess provides him a perfect opportunity to lead his fellow independent directors in practicing what he preached.


We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see

News Corp is an evil empire. It got too much power. It got to be dismantled. Now is the time to do it.

Posted by d_evil | Report as abusive

Interesting you didn’t mention the two directors heading up the internal inquiry, Viet Dihn and Joel Klein per  /09/phone-hacking-scandal-rupert-murdoc h. Per Wikipedia, Dihn worked with Perkins on the HP affair; and Klein, while an NWS exec now also, does have some independent credential I’d think, as a lawyer and Bloomberg’s former long-time school chancellor.

Posted by Swliv | Report as abusive

yes, viet dinh, who wrote the patriot act while in the infinitely corrupt bush DOJ, who sits at the very worst confluence of government and corporate power, who is the paradigm of everything that is sick and wrong in our ever burgeoning oligarchy, let’s have him do it! he’ll overturn every rock, and he’ll make sure to get rid of any fingerprints he may find. great idea.

Posted by robertogreen | Report as abusive

[…] the full scale of the tabloid’s phone hacking came to light in July, one columnist called Perkins “the closest thing to a truly independent director” on News […]

Posted by Jim Breyer Joins News Corp. Board as Tom Perkins Departs – Forbes | Report as abusive