Berkshire buyback a move best left to Buffett

September 26, 2011

By Agnes T. Crane and Robert Cyran
The authors are Reuters Breakingviews columnists. The opinions expressed are their own.

Warren Buffett isn’t too old to try something new. His Berkshire Hathaway conglomerate is buying back an unlimited amount of both classes of shares, at up to a 10 percent premium over book value. Investors like to copy what Buffett does, but stock repurchases are best left to the Oracle of Omaha. If shares of other companies were truly undervalued, Berkshire probably wouldn’t be buying its own.

The moment seems right for Berkshire. Its shares have suffered badly this year, falling 17 percent before Monday’s announcement. For a company that prides itself on beating the S&P 500, small wonder Buffett pulled the trigger on an option he has, at least in theory, supported for years.

Shareholders liked the decision, pushing Berkshire shares up 6 percent. What’s good for Buffett, though, might not be so for other corporate bosses. Along with his hunting companion Charlie Munger, Buffett has been touting an M&A quest for an elephant. Yet Berkshire’s $165 billion market value has made it tough to bag one big enough to help the company’s returns.

In recent years, Berkshire has found smaller but satisfying game in finance. Fat dividends from preferred stock in Goldman Sachs, General Electric and most recently Bank of America have proven appetizing. And although Berkshire will keep at least $20 billion of cash on hand, the decision to turn inward for rewards suggests the herd might be starting to look thin.

It’s something investors would be wise to keep in mind. The view that stocks are undervalued remains entrenched on Wall Street and in boardrooms. Companies are buying back stock in droves, and sometimes borrowing to do so, without giving investors objective measures to justify the decisions.

But there may yet be a strategy to mimic from Berkshire’s buyback. Since Buffett has put a price on what’s undervalued, and given his history of well-timed investments compared to the appalling track record of most corporate share buybacks, maybe other companies should consider buying Berkshire stock instead of their own.

One comment

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see

I don’t really understand what makes Mr Buffett so great. He missed out on dotcom shares because he didn t understand it??.

Under performing is just not good enough. Tell me about succesfull investors not has beens.

Seems Mr Buffet just skims a bit off other peoples investment money to make the money he gives away. He certainly isn t making enough for his investors to be giving away billions.

Posted by keepmeout16 | Report as abusive