Dexia rescue riskier than it looks for Belgium
By George Hay
The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions expressed are his own.
Belgium‚Äôs bill for bailing out Dexia could be much higher than meets the eye. After a weekend of frantic negotiations, Brussels is to pay 4 billion euros to take the Belgian assets of the vanquished lender into public ownership. If that was it, the direct costs to the state would be only 1 percent of GDP.
On first glance, it might seem Belgium is getting a bargain, as Dexia Bank Belgium‚Äôs book value was 7.9 billion euros in June. But Belgian accounting rules allow Dexia to dodge marking so-called available for sale (AFS) assets to market. Including these losses, DBB‚Äôs book value in June was 5.7 billion euros. Given the mayhem over the past three months, the current mark-to-market value could be less than what the Belgian government is paying.
Then there‚Äôs the question of whether the Dexia rump, in which the Belgian state still holds a 5.7 percent stake, has enough capital. The plan is to sell its Turkish, Luxembourg and French municipal operations. After the disposals, it would still have 60 billion euros of risk-weighted assets. That would require at least 6 billion euros of capital to create a 10 percent core Tier 1 buffer against losses.
Part of this will depend on whether Dexia can sell assets above book value. But a lot will depend on whether Belgium is allowed to keep sweeping AFS losses under the carpet. The new Basel rules say no but there‚Äôs always the possibility of fudges. If, at the end of the process, there is a capital hole, it’s unclear how Belgium and France would plug it. But, imagine for sake of argument, Brussels faces another 3 billion euro bill.
Finally, Belgium is on the hook for guaranteeing 60.5 percent of Dexia‚Äôs funding for 10 years ‚Äď- or 54 billion euros in total. Tot it all up and the total cost to the Belgian taxpayer, in a real disaster, could be 17 percent of GDP -‚Äď on top of last year‚Äôs level of 96 percent. No wonder Moody‚Äôs is examining whether to downgrade the country‚Äôs sovereign debt, and Belgian 10-year debt yields have jumped from 3.6 percent to 4.1 percent in a week.