Ducati could rip it up with VW
By Quentin Webb
The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions expressed are his own.
Skoda cars and MAN trucks, meet your potential Volkswagen stablemates: 186-mph superbikes. No-one walks into a showroom after a cheap family car and screeches out on a blood-red Italian motorcycle. But Audi‚Äôs ambitions to buy Ducati would make some sense for VW‚Äôs luxury marque. And even with an appropriately macho price tag, the deal could pay off if Audi turbo-charges Ducati sales in emerging markets.
Motorbike valuations are in a different league to the big automakers. A deal at 875 million euros, the high end of earlier reports, would value Ducati at more than 1.8 times 2011 sales and 9.3 times EBITDA. That‚Äôs below U.S. peer Harley-Davidson, which fetches 3.1 times sales. But it‚Äôs far above VW itself, which trades at just 0.3 trailing sales and 5.5 times EBITDA.
Nor are there big cost savings. Maybe some engine know-how can be shared, and Ducati should be able to buy raw materials and borrow money more cheaply, among other things. But Audi clearly can‚Äôt reap the huge savings that come from combining carmakers – where similar-size vehicles can be built using common platforms, engines and parts. Still, Audi might persuade some dealers to stock both two- and four-wheelers, as happens with arch-rival BMW.
The sale could yet fizzle out. Ducati‚Äôs main owner, Italy‚Äôs Investindustrial, now says talks with VW are no longer exclusive, which doesn‚Äôt sound promising. But any successful deal would be tiddling for Europe‚Äôs largest carmaker, whose operating profit hit 11.3 billion euros last year.
And perhaps Ducati‚Äôs celeb-endorsed bikes are best understood as a leather-clad version of all the other luxury brands that are storming the emerging world. In that case, VW‚Äôs experience, connections and marketing nous could be a big help. In China, for example, VW is among the biggest foreign players. Audi sold a record 90,000 cars there last quarter. Ducati‚Äôs Asian sales leapt 75 percent last year, but were still just 11 percent of the total.
Volkswagen boss Ferdinand Piech may be thinking like a petrol-head as much as a financier. But most of VW‚Äôs stock is held by Porsche, Lower Saxony and Qatar. And his remaining outside investors are already accustomed to empire-building.