Euro bank rescue doesn’t have to shame Spain

June 11, 2012

By Pierre Briancon

The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions expressed are his own.

The case for the euro zone to step in and help recapitalise Spanish banks should have been a no-brainer. Spain is in a bind of its own making, but the challenge of turning its economy around has been magnified by the crisis. As for the euro zone, it has the instruments and the money to help Madrid recapitalise the country’s banks, leaving the government to tend to its own business.

This weekend’s possible mini-bailout could and should have been a simple, straightforward, shock-and-awe intervention weeks ago. Instead, time was wasted because of Spanish Prime Minister Mariano Rajoy’s misplaced pride, and because the dysfunctional euro family has been unable to put its own bailout fund to use.

Rajoy says he doesn’t know how much money the banks need, so there’s no point in tapping the bailout fund. But the specific number isn’t the central issue for now. Spanish banks may need anything between 40 billion and 100 billion euros. What matters is that the European Financial Stability Facility steps in, in principle. And if the first round isn’t enough, there will always be time to add more later.

The sticking point has been for too long whether the EFSF or its successor, the European Stability Mechanism, should be allowed to rescue banks directly, or indirectly through governments. Rajoy has been adamant that Spain doesn’t need a full bailout a-la-Greece, and he may be right. But obsessing about the stigma of aid has done nothing to calm markets.

Germany’s symmetric obsession – conditionality – has also been a major impediment to a deal. Rajoy wasn’t ready to accept humiliating conditions forced upon his government, which is already doing a lot to get out of the morass.

Too much energy has been spent on trying to spare everyone’s feelings. Fig leaves can always be found. The EFSF could for example lend to Spain’s FROB bank fund, if direct bank recapitalisation remains a no-no. In any case the “conditionality” should be limited to the government’s supervision of the banking sector. Any attempt at forcing Spain into extra austerity wouldn’t square with the European Commission’s own proposal to give the country more time to meet its deficit-reduction targets.

It looks like the parties are getting closer to a rescue. Better planned, it could have been almost unremarkable. Now it can’t avoid being a big deal.


We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see

In the age of the handout, they can hold their tin cup high, just like the rest of the global financial elite.

Posted by williambanazi7 | Report as abusive

It’s not about shame. It’s all about irresponsible unethical lazy Southern Europeans who refuse to pay what they owe for thirty years running.

Posted by mulholland | Report as abusive