If Apple becomes Microsoft, investors should cheer
By Robert Cyran and Richard Beales
The authors are Reuters Breakingviews columnists. The opinions expressed are their own.
If Apple becomes Microsoft, investors should cheer. At least, that is, for their wallets. Middle age for technology stocks can hurt as shareholders looking for rapid growth lose interest and value-oriented owners await stability. But Apple has already made the transition – before its growth has slowed much. Even if its next decade echoes Microsoftâs last, the company is worth over $1 trillion.
First, consider Microsoft, worth $220 billion as of Fridayâs market close. The software behemoth churns out more than twice as much profit as it did a decade ago. The company traded at 30 times estimated earnings in 2002. As investors realized its future was more Clark Kent than Superman, they paid less and less for the prospect of future expansion. Annual percentage revenue increases of late have at best been in single digits. Strip out its $67 billion of cash, and the business trades at about 6.5 times estimated earnings, according to Thomson Reuters.
Now look at Apple. In the fiscal year to September, its top line surged 45 percent. That was less than the year before, and there are reasons to expect a more pedestrian future: the company lost part of its creative soul when Steve Jobs died in October 2011; itâs a big ask for Apple to come up with another product like the iPod, iPhone or iPad; and competition in mobile devices is becoming tough. But analysts still expect revenue to increase 24 percent this year. And after taking out Appleâs whopping $121 billion cash pile, the underlying business on Friday traded at a price-to-expected earnings ratio of some 7.9 times, scarcely richer than Microsoftâs.
Suppose Apple Chief Executive Tim Cook turns out to match his Microsoft counterpart Steve Ballmer, and that Appleâs earnings increase at an 8 percent annual rate for the next 10 years, roughly what Ballmer has coaxed out of Microsoft since 2002. Appleâs profit would then be about $90 billion in 2022. On the software companyâs multiple, that would make Appleâs business, excluding cash, worth $585 billion. Start with last fiscal yearâs cash accumulation of about $40 billion and assume the same rate of growth, and in a decade the company will have added another $625 billion to its cash pile or to dividends. Add back all the cash, and the iPhone maker would be worth $1.3 trillion – approaching three times more than now, or a 10 percent annual gain.
Of course, the technology industry is littered with fallen tech giants. Competition, for instance, could depress Appleâs margins, though in fact they have widened in recent years – and Microsoftâs have held up. But if Apple turning into a sluggish Microsoft lookalike is all that it takes to more than double investorsâ money, that seems a safe bet.