Catalonian independence isn’t worth the pain

November 23, 2012

By Pierre Briançon

The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions expressed are his own.

The politicians who are arguing for Catalonia’s independence from Madrid can make a seemingly convincing case that the region would be economically viable as a standalone, sovereign nation. Except that they miss the point. The relative wealth and prosperity Catalonia currently enjoys depends on its links to Spain, the euro zone and the wider European Union. A unilateral breakup would leave Catalonia stranded, and considerably poorer. It would take years before it could become “viable” again.

Forget for a moment the constitutional and political obstacles to independence, and the consequences it would have for others – notably for what would remain of Spain, deprived of its richest region, and whose GDP per capita would be relegated to that of Greece or Portugal. Catalonia has more people than Ireland or Finland, its area is equivalent to Belgium’s, and its GDP per capita is higher than Italy’s, notes Credit Suisse. Furthermore, its economy is diversified and accounts for a big chunk of Spain’s exports. There is no doubt that, in a fictitious world, it could thrive independently.

But there is also no doubt that it cannot afford the cost of a breakup that would never be consensual. It may export more goods to the rest of the world than to other Spanish regions, but its trade balance is only positive thanks to Spain. Furthermore, Catalonia would have to devise a new currency that no one would trust while its current debt was still denominated in euros. Exiting the EU and the euro zone would also encourage businesses to relocate, shrinking the new country’s industrial base. Altogether the region’s GDP could decline by up to 20 percent, aligning it with the rest of Spain, according to some estimates.

The chances that Catalonia will ever move to full-fledged independence are next to zero, and the region’s politicians are mostly using the threat to renegotiate the terms of its financial relations with Madrid. This is a political crisis for Spain that will hopefully never degenerate into an economic nightmare. But the populists in Barcelona keep pretending that Catalonia would be spared austerity if it severs its ties with Madrid. Catalonian voters must decide whether they would prefer poverty instead.

One comment

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see

OK Pierre Briançon, so

1- You are suggesting that after the catalan independence, all trades from catalonia to spain would be blocked??? That makes no sense!! if Spain buys catalan products it is because they win on the trade, not because Catalonia is part of the same state.

2- You also suggest that Catalonia would be kicked out the EU and the euro currency, which would interest none, Catalonia or Europe. This might happen in your imaginary world, but political (i.e. Spani’s revenge against Catalonia) interests won’t be over global economical interests. This assumption of yours is completelly false and imaginary, also most Catalans want to be part of the EU, and if that’s not possible, there is no argument to assume that Catalonia would have its own currency, many non-Eruopean states have euro as a currency, such as Swiss.

3- The only populist here is you. The majority of catalans want to vote wisely, we will vote for a better world, for a richer european union, we will vote in favor of Catalonia’s independence.

In case of independence, Catalonia would be richer, and so Spain as a whole, as the inefficient, corrupt, repressive and centralised model of Spain would end.

Posted by ROBERT_Catalan | Report as abusive