Bond jitters shouldn’t delay Japan pension reform
By Andy Mukherjee
(The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions¬†expressed are his own)
By reforming Japan‚Äôs public pension system, Prime Minister Shinzo Abe is taking a calculated risk. Asking state funds to buy fewer government bonds may look like an own goal at a time when the central bank is struggling to control yields. But the payoff to both the government and Japan‚Äôs fast-ageing society could be worth it.
Abe‚Äôs administration wants the Government Pension Investment Fund and smaller state funds that together hold 8 percent of Japan‚Äôs government bonds to reduce their exposure to Japanese sovereign debt, Reuters reported on June 4. Instead, they will be urged to buy riskier securities at home and overseas.
On the surface, the move seems mistimed. Despite the Bank of Japan‚Äôs promise of massive purchases, yields on 10-year Japanese government bonds have doubled in just two months. Expectations of higher inflation in Japan and the demise of cheap global money are to blame. Though 10-year yields are still less than 1 percent, volatility in the government bond market has undermined confidence in the BOJ‚Äôs policy. In such circumstances, why turn away a captive bond buyer?
Yet Abe‚Äôs gambit makes sense for three reasons. First, if the public pension system can boost returns by increasing its exposure to riskier assets, the government‚Äôs bill for basic old-age payouts could fall: these currently cost it 2 percent of GDP a year. At the very least, the burden on taxpayers of supporting Japan‚Äôs growing band of retirees will be kept in check. That should help Tokyo‚Äôs creditworthiness, which will shore up faith in its debt.
The second benefit is a cheaper yen. The BOJ‚Äôs goal is to weaken the yen so that exporters invest more, pulling up stagnant wages and ending entrenched deflation. For the plan to work, either Japan‚Äôs Mrs Watanabes – or their money managers – must take more newly printed yen abroad. Public pension funds seem the perfect courier.
Finally, patient pension money is just the kind of financing that developing economies in Asia need to build infrastructure. With local savings inadequate and bond markets inefficient, Japan can step into the breach. Short-term bond jitters shouldn‚Äôt delay the country‚Äôs pension reform.