Barclays’ rights issue is worth supporting – just
By George Hay
The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions expressed are his own.
Barclays’ 5.8 billion pound rights issue is just about worth supporting. Just six months after a strategic revamp, the UK bank’s investors are facing a cash call to help address an unexpected 12.8 billion pound capital hole. They should stick around.
Looking backward, Barclays was not necessarily foolish to have excluded new shares from the February plans. Then, the regulators were fine with gradually working up to a 10.5 percent core Tier 1 ratio on a Basel III basis. After a change of tack by the Prudential Regulation Authority, the UK regulator, another measure suddenly became paramount. Equity has to be 3 percent of assets by June 2014.
The rights issue does 45 percent of the capital work. It will be complemented by deleveraging, and the issue of 2 billion pounds of near-equity contingent convertible securities. Stronger capital will reduce returns, at least in the short term. The expected date for the return on equity to hit the bank’s 11.5 percent group cost of equity has been delayed from 2015 to a year later.
Looking forward, the new capital should accelerate Barclays’ turnaround. By next June, Barclays will have a Basel III capital ratio of 9.5 percent, in line with peers. Also, it has pulled forward the target date for the dividend payout, currently 30 percent of net income, to reach 40-50 percent – from 2015 to a year earlier. Investors, who have persistently given the bank a discount for being overleveraged, could respond well.
There are two caveats. One is that Barclays’ 2015 strategy will only pay off if its operations, particularly in the investment bank, continue to motor. That means the investment bank’s flagship fixed-income arm will need to do better than the second quarter, when a 37 percent fall in revenue underperformed U.S. peers. Another 2 billion pounds of provisions for historic mis-selling is a reminder of the threat from future regulatory thwacks.
The other is Barclays’ management. Although investors may appreciate the difficulty of second-guessing an unpredictable regulator, they will also be aware that Chief Executive Antony Jenkins could have taken the issue off the table himself back in February. They will hope this is the last part of his strategy to go awry.