Carlos Slim offers escape route to KPN investors
By Chris Hughes
The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions expressed are his own.
Carlos Slim has offered an escape route to KPN investors. The Mexican tycoonâs America Movil says it intends to make a 7.2 billion euro offer for the 70 percent of the Dutch telecoms group it doesnât already own. Itâs the start of a saga that could end in a substantially higher offer. But investors should be realistic – thatâs a big âcouldâ.
KPN is in turnaround mode and Slimâs approach is opportunistic. America Movil already has 29.8 percent of the company. It recently terminated a partnership pact after KPN agreed the 8.1 billion euro partial sale of its German unit, E-Plus, to Telefonica Deutschland. That in turn made it possible for Slim to bid for all of KPN.
But will a real offer materialise and how high could it go? KPN has a duty to try to push for more money. Slimâs existing stake almost precludes the entry of a competitive bidder. But KPN has options.
The board could try to persuade the market that the offer is too low. First step: talk up the benefits of the E-Plus deal. The disposal is likely to secure the required 50 percent shareholder acceptances even if Slim – who has been silent on his merits – votes no.
Selling E-Plus is shareholder-friendly. The cash-and-shares transaction strengthens KPNâs balance sheet while leaving some exposure to Germany. Factor in the proceeds and a re-rating of the KPN rump, and KPN shares could rise back to 3 euros, the price less than a year ago. While Movilâs putative 2.40 euros per share offer is 35 percent above KPNâs 30-day average, it is below the share price of just over six months ago.
The snag for the board is that the shares could easily fall back. For example, Slim might make an actual offer conditional on shareholders blocking the E-Plus deal. Indeed, under Dutch takeover law, Movil isnât obliged to follow his statement of intentions with any actual offer.
Then there is governance. Movil set a low acceptance threshold – 50 percent plus one share. But KPNâs rules would deprive Slim of board seats unless the offer is recommended. At worst, a Dutch political backlash could tempt the shareholder foundation, which is independent of KPNâs board, to use its power to veto any offer deemed to be against the companyâs interest.
For investors who bought into the rights issue at 1.06 euros a share in May, the current 2.31 euro share price offers a substantial and certain payback.