Bo Xilai trial says little about China rule of law

August 21, 2013
asia | China | law

By John Foley

The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions expressed are his own.

The trial of Bo Xilai is a test of China’s political tolerance, not its rule of law. For foreign capitalists, the latter matters more. It’s almost unthinkable the ousted Chongqing party chief will receive anything other than a guilty verdict. Yet it’s still possible to hope that disputes over investment and contracts will be resolved in a more transparent way.

The charges against Bo – bribery, graft and abuse of power – have all the hallmarks of a political fix. The defendant hasn’t been seen since March 2012. Bo’s populism and Maoist stylings while running China’s biggest western city were a threat to the Communist Party’s modern identity, which strives for historical legitimacy while resisting personality cults.

Chinese justice is most elusive at the top and bottom of the system. Political trials are too important to be left to chance in a one-party state. Meanwhile in China’s 3,117 district-level courts corruption is hard to root out. The courts rely on local governments for funding, exposing China’s 146,000 small-time judges to undue pressure from local officials.

Yet it’s the middle bit that matters most to foreign investors. In China’s “intermediate” and “higher” courts, the process is somewhat clearer. Recent probes into bribery and price-fixing are testing whether the legal system can deliver outcomes that are seen as logical and fair. Decisions like the one handed down against Johnson & Johnson for price-fixing on Aug. 1, which emphasised the need for proof of wrongdoing, look encouraging.

Progress comes in fits and starts. Judges are still bound by the “three supremes” of party, people and constitutional law. Dissidents are cruelly suppressed. And while the courts are getting better at handling commercial disputes, it’s not clear how they would handle a huge increase in bad debts and bankruptcies if China’s economy continues to slow.

For now, half-baked laws are a nuisance rather than a real drag. Wages, credit growth and the exchange rate seem to exert more influence on capital flows. It may be too much to hope that the legal training of Chinese president Xi Jinping and premier Li Keqiang will encourage an era of law, but judging the system by Bo’s fate would be equally unwise.

 

Post Your Comment

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/