From soccer pitch, lessons on Chinese tycoon risks
By Una Galani
The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions expressed are her own.
Chinese investors are setting their sights on trophy assets in the West, and soccer teams look like fair game. The case of English football club Birmingham City, whose main shareholder and former president just sold a stake to an obscure Chinese company, offers a cautionary tale. Big personalities make risky shareholders, but China brings extra anxieties.
Birmingham had already experienced the rise and fall of a wealthy patron. Hong Kong hairdresser-turned-businessman Carson Yeung led a buyout of the soccer group between 2007 and 2009. But after facing money laundering charges, he stepped down as chairman of the listed holding company on Feb. 4. On Feb. 12 the indebted Birmingham International Holdings said it was selling a 12 percent share in its UK subsidiary for HK$45 million ($5.8 million).
The cash is welcome – Birmingham’s parent turned loss-making following the club’s relegation from the Premier League in 2011. But the buyer is mysterious. Beijing Liangzhu International Media and Advertising Company is listed by a Chinese local government company registration website as a “design, manufacturing and advertising” company, founded in 2005 with capital equivalent to just $250,000. Beijing Liangzhu will get two seats on the club’s existing four member board as part of the deal. Its influence may grow more if plans to sell a 24 percent stake are followed through.
China is flush with cash, but capital controls and opaque legal systems make it hard to follow the money trail. That might explain why Birmingham’s holding group has demanded a 22 percent deposit from Beijing Liangzhu. Insurer American International Group agreed to sell its aircraft leasing business to a Chinese consortium, only to find payment hadn’t come a year later. It eventually found a Dutch buyer, Aercap, in December.
Chinese investors have been circling everything from property development projects in the United Kingdom to Forbes Magazine and the New York Times. Those with deep pockets can make welcome owners of financially fragile assets, and more cash-strapped companies will find that China provides welcome liquidity. The cost may be that the targets know less than they’d like about who’s watching over them from the stands.