Alibaba’s big reveal: high growth, odd governance
By John Foley
The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions expressed are his own.
There are two things to know about Alibaba, which filed for an initial public offering in New York on May 6. First, China’s dominant e-commerce company is huge, and could be even bigger. Second, new investors will have little say in how it is run – the founders are keeping a firm grip.
Last year, Alibaba processed 11.3 billion orders with a value of $248 billion through its main sites, Taobao and Tmall. That’s two-thirds more than Amazon and Ebay combined, and a staggering 84 percent of China’s total online shopping haul. Unlike most online retailers, Alibaba doesn’t sell or deliver goods itself. Instead, it acts as a shop-front, charging sellers for advertising and taking some commissions.
Growth will come from two sources: increased online shopping, and Alibaba extracting more money from sellers. Its revenue of $7.8 billion in calendar year 2013 amounted to just 3 percent of goods sold. By comparison, Ebay’s take is 10 percent. Alibaba’s orders tend to be small – averaging around $22 apiece versus $64 for rival online retailer JD.com. But its dominance should enable it to keep a bigger share.
Governance is the sticking point. A group of 28 partners, led by chairman Jack Ma and his number two Joseph Tsai, will nominate the majority of Alibaba’s board of directors. Big shareholders Yahoo and Softbank have pledged to back the partners’ choice, ensuring that a majority of shares will vote in favour.
The theory is that this structure is more democratic than the super-voting shares used by the founders of rival tech companies like Facebook and Google. But it’s also less transparent, and therefore harder to value. Alibaba’s partnership will remain in place unless 95 percent of shareholders vote to dissolve it. Though Ma and Tsai can be removed by a simple majority of the partners, the chances of that happening seem remote.
It’s understandable that Alibaba wants to preserve the culture that contributed to its extraordinary success. New shareholders can have no doubt about who calls the shots. But business conditions and cultures change. Alibaba has been rapidly expanding into new areas, from internet TV to mapping and online video, where the founders may be less expert. Growth without good governance is like an online retailer without a returns policy.