Treasury Wine resistance withers under KKR assault
By Peter Thal Larsen
The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions expressed are his own.
Treasury Wine has decided that a grape is worth more in the bottle than on the vine. The maker of Lindeman‚Äôs and Penfolds agreed to open its vaults after the buyout group raised a provisional cash offer to A$3.38 billion ($3.15 billion). Though the bid could yet sour,¬†Treasury‚Äôs spell as a listed company looks like it will soon be coming to an end.
It‚Äôs unusual for private equity groups to come back after a rebuff. Treasury rejected KKR‚Äôs opening bid of A$4.70 per share in May, arguing that new chief executive Michael Clarke needed time to deliver his turnaround plan. Just over two months later, however, it has agreed to negotiate after KKR – now joined by co-investor Rhone Group ‚Äď topped up its bid by an additional 50 cents per share. The latest proposal looks hard to resist. It‚Äôs at a 41 percent premium to Treasury‚Äôs share price before the first offer, and values the company at almost 24 times forecast earnings for the year to next June, according to Eikon.
There are risks to negotiating in public. Treasury will suffer if KKR finds something it does not like in due diligence and walks away. By keeping its discussions with KKR non-exclusive, Treasury can try to squeeze out a competing bid. But rival suitors have had plenty of opportunity to come forward since beer maker Foster‚Äôs decided to spin off the business in 2011.
KKR‚Äôs interest is more puzzling. However, the group has had some success turning around booze businesses, most recently with South Korea‚Äôs Oriental Brewery. Private ownership may also allow Treasury to accelerate its restructuring away from the scrutiny of public markets. Growing demand for wine from China‚Äôs expanding middle class should help in the longer run.
Treasury‚Äôs share price jumped 4 percent to A$5.15 on Aug. 4. The small discount is justified, since KKR‚Äôs conditional offer will take several months to harvest. Given the buyout group‚Äôs persistence, however, it is not surprising that Treasury‚Äôs determination to remain independent withered so quickly.