Europe returns to Franco-German axis of neurosis

January 2, 2015

By Pierre Briançon

The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions expressed are his own.

Europe’s economic stagnation has a lot to do with its political paralysis. In 2014, the emphasis was on what governments should have done – and could still do – to boost the continent’s potential after two years of EU economic contraction. In 2015, the crisis at the heart of Europe’s malaise, the breakdown of the French-German partnership, will take centre stage.

Either Paris and Berlin make the case for a rejuvenated, reformed Europe and justify the hopes of the many countries which still want to join, or they fail and the European project is at risk of sinking slowly, from crisis to crisis, into oblivion. The EU has always been first and foremost a political project, kept in check by economic and financial market realities. If its two main architects lose interest, or are too focused on their own problems to work on their relationship, the undertaking can fast turn sour.

Europe’s economic disputes are fading, despite dramatic headlines. A broad consensus has emerged on the need for both fiscal discipline and structural reforms to boost GDP growth, forecast by the IMF to be an anaemic 0.8 percent in 2014 and 1.3 percent in 2015. The disagreement is on timing.

“Austerity now” partisans – among them German Chancellor Angela Merkel, looking increasingly isolated – say only fiscal rigour can foster sustainable growth. Growth advocates, including France under President François Hollande, don’t disagree but insist on stimulus first to counter the short-term cost of reforms.

Another problem is trust, or the lack of it. Berlin doesn’t believe France is committed to sound economic policies. The Germans remember that Europe’s pre-euro history was marked by repeated French franc devaluations. Meanwhile the French worry that ageing Germany has lost interest in the European project since the Cold War ended.

But cracks are beginning to show in the German economic model and France seems at last to have a government that means business. Both countries have to deal with challenges such as the rise of radical parties and the crisis in Ukraine, a reminder that peace on the continent is not a given. These are opportunities for leaders on both sides of the Rhine to remember why they built Europe in the first place.


We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see

The European Union is not about nations joining together to foster peace, or fairness, or efficiency.

The European Union was created – is being created – by the wealthy elite to more effectively prey upon the people of the European nations.

Not that long ago the nations of Europe had busy factories and vibrant cultures. Now all the goods on the store shelves in Europe are made in China. The middle classes have been destroyed. The wealthy elite, on the other hand, are seeing their profits and wealth skyrocket. That is what drove, and continues to drive, the creation of the EU.

Posted by AdamSmith | Report as abusive

European Union increasingly became a bloc dominated by Germany and auxilliaries as the Netherlands, Belgium, Austria and other rich nations. France looks has been increasingly pushed to sides. The enlargemenet of the Union became a unique opportunity for Germany and its smaller allies to drain enormous wealth from the new, weak, or uncompetitive members, and to check these countries under the political and economic influence of the wealthy elite from the West. For that reason, the Union allocates funds to these conutries to satisfy some of the folks in the stagnating countries, but actually suffocates their economies. Western governments also promote immigration of both skilled professionalists, and cheap labour force to sustain the domestic businesses, while adding insult to the injury of the weaker members. From the frequent appearences of Mrs Merkel on the political scene in every instance is a clear demonstration of that reality. And the constant “xenophobic” agenda keeps the newcomers in the West on check too: “if you don’t want to go back to your battered homeland, you should adopt our language and culture fast”

Posted by Levko | Report as abusive