Impossible trinity gives China a difficult choice

August 26, 2015

The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions expressed are his own.

Beijing can bend the laws of economics, but it can’t break them. The central bank’s impressive foreign currency war chest gives China the room to muddle through between three objectives: lower interest rates, a stable yuan, and a reasonably open capital account. But reconciling what economists have dubbed the “impossible trinity” is beyond the grasp of even the People’s Republic.

On Aug. 26, Chinese stock market investors seemed incapable of deciding whether the People’s Bank of China’s rate cut the previous evening was a pill or poison. The anxiety shows the tough road ahead. If investors conclude that lower mainland interest rates and more relaxed lending norms signal an increase in the money supply, they might take more capital out of China.

The “impossible trinity” theorises that countries cannot simultaneously control monetary policy and the exchange rate while letting capital flow freely. In practice, this gives China’s authorities very little choice. If they want to set interest rates lower and yet keep Premier Li Keqiang’s promise to keep the currency stable they will have to consider locking up capital. Macau police raids to prevent illegal cash leaks from the mainland suggest a renewed determination to restrict unauthorised cross-border flows. But any reversal of China’s gradual loosening of its capital account would undermine the country’s bid to add the yuan to the International Monetary Fund’s elite quasi-currency club this November.

A revival in economic growth might reverse the outflows. But the lackluster global economy, and the mainland’s twin problems of excess capacity and excessive debt, makes that hard to achieve. In the short term, China’s best hope may be that its economic woes continue to reverberate through world markets so that the Federal Reserve refrains from raising U.S. interest rates.

In the meantime, the only way Beijing can maintain the semblance of a stable currency against a resurgent U.S. dollar is to defend the yuan by selling down its reserves. That won’t help confidence either. At $3.65 trillion at the end of June, the kitty is sufficiently large to help China muddle through the impossible trinity for a while, but not large enough to reverse capital outflows if they become self-fulfilling.


We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see

China uses a HUGE chunk of the world’s resources; and does only a tiny bit of the world’s international work. When is the last time you heard of a Chinese health clinic in Africa. Or a Chinese Peace Corps doing good work in South America? Or Chinese rescue boats helping refugees. China does almost NOTHING for other peoople. They send very little foreign aid, very few doctors, stingy with their engineers. Yet they want the goods from everywhere. Time for China to do more. They still want to act like kids, but eat like adults.

Posted by Solidar | Report as abusive

How would you know if the People’s Republic needs stupid western logic to solve its problems?

And do western stock market bettors really know what a fall or rise signifies?

If you are so smart then why aren’t you rich from your firm logical deduction of merely western stock markets?

Posted by ObscenelyGreat | Report as abusive