Antonin Scalia’s death challenges U.S. leadership

February 14, 2016

The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions expressed are her own.

The death of Antonin Scalia disrupts the Supreme Court’s balance and electrifies an already charged presidential race. The longest-serving member of the panel also leaves behind a vacancy just as the highest U.S. court is considering important cases on immigration, abortion and unions. Leading Republicans are already threatening to block any Barack Obama nominee to replace Scalia, hinting at a destabilizing stalemate.

Slumping oil prices, slower growth in China and negative interest-rate policies out of the European and Japanese central banks have made for a volatile year. The S&P 500 Index has tumbled by 9 percent to start 2016, while shares in European banks have fallen by more than 25 percent. In its fragile state, the world is seeking leadership from the United States. Restoring the Supreme Court to nine members in the few months it generally takes to do would be a strong showing that American politicians can govern on some matters despite the dysfunction witnessed over the last few years.

With Scalia, a Ronald Reagan appointee, there was a five-to-four conservative majority. A White House nominee to replace Scalia – which Obama said he would do just hours after Scalia’s death – requires approval from the Republican-controlled Senate. Conservative presidential candidate Ted Cruz, a former Supreme Court clerk, said Scalia’s replacement should be left to Obama’s successor and Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell concurred. That would leave the seat empty for at least a year.

At eight members, the court is at risk of being deadlocked. That could upend issues such as the president’s executive action allowing 5 million illegal immigrants to stay in the country. If the Supreme Court can’t reach a majority opinion, the lower court’s ruling halting the order would be affirmed.

In January, the court also seemed like it might decide that workers don’t have to join public-sector unions, and therefore not pay dues, which would be a major blow to the labor movement. That decision also now hangs in the balance, as does the court’s first major abortion case in almost a decade.

With so much at stake, a compromise on a centrist candidate would be an ideal outcome, both for the country and as a show of leadership around the world. The U.S. political realities, however, threaten to rattle already shaky global investors and economies.


We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see

IMHO, if the Republicans don’t approve Obama’s Supreme Court nominee by this Fall, they are at even bigger risk to lose in November.

Posted by UauS | Report as abusive

Republicans are showing that their intent is entirely contrary to the Constitution. The President in office is the one to appoint the replacement. The Senate is to advise and consent on individual nominees, but to issue a blanket statement that ANY nominee from Obama will be blocked is contrary to the Constitution.

Posted by QuietThinker | Report as abusive

Time to move forward. He was a dark spot on American history, but hopefully he is in a better place now. Condolences to his family and loved ones, regardless of his sins and vanity.

Posted by Solidar | Report as abusive

At a minimal Senator’s salary of $174,000 per year this citizen would appreciate them “getting to work” – No way should that seat go unfilled for two Supreme Court terms, regardless of the historical handshakes. Do your job Senators, get to work or go home, and save us all some money.
I can only imagine my boss’ reaction if I told them I’d like to wait for the new boss before I take action on his request, or disregard my responsibilities to others.

Posted by TheBaboon | Report as abusive