Merkel down not out after Super Sunday defeat

March 14, 2016

The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions expressed are his own.

The big winner from Germany’s Super Sunday was populism. The right-wing Alternative fuer Deutschland (AfD) won double-digit results in all three states that held polls on March 13, even if it won’t actually run any of them as a result. Moreover, support for Angela Merkel’s governing coalition is waning quickly. That looks, on the face of it, like a strike against Merkel’s hitherto tolerant approach to the huge influx of migrants who have entered Germany from Syria and beyond.

Yet dig deeper and there are some more comforting messages. First, credible and determined mainstream leaders still woo voters. In Baden-Wuerttemberg, the Greens became the biggest party in a regional parliament for the first time in German history, even though their regional leader Winfried Kretschmann backs Merkel’s migrant policy. In Rhineland-Palatinate, the popular Social Democratic Party (SPD) governor Malu Dreyer – also supportive of Merkel’s stance – expanded her lead over a less migration-friendly challenger from Merkel’s own party, the Christian Democratic Union (CDU).

The populist AfD has gone from zero to political pariah in just three years, and is increasing the pressure on Merkel and her coalition with the SPD to change their handling of the migrant crisis. But it’s easy to exaggerate their impact. In recent decades, right-wing parties time and again scored successes in regional elections but then collapsed quickly due to internal bickering, German voters’ general distaste for extreme positions and a lack of credible political leaders.

For most voters in Germany, personalities rather than party affiliations matter most. That may actually help Angela Merkel to keep her inner-party critics at bay. The CDU lacks any credible alternative to the chancellor. She has time, too: federal elections aren’t due until the second half of 2017.

Moreover, recent opinion polls indicated that voters’ satisfaction with the chancellor is starting to improve again. Merkel still possesses a lot of political capital that will be enhanced if she can bring down the numbers of refugees entering Germany – either by closing the deal with Turkey that was outlined on March 7, or should that fail, eventually by closing the country’s border. After the painful defeat on Germany’s Super Sunday, Merkel is down but not out.


We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see

German voters would be wise to dump Merkel. She has almost totally destroyed Germany and the rest of Europe. It is impossible to imagine a more inept leader than Merkel.

Posted by upyourssideways | Report as abusive

Merkel’s thumping is the salvation of Europe. Not that she is evil, but her arrogant approach to distributing refugees was destroying the EU. Democracy prevailed, and the voice of the people actually lets her off the hook from following thru on a failed policy. Orban was the big winner – he kept the subsidies (for now), and didn’t keep the refugees (for now).

Posted by DavidHume | Report as abusive