UK fracking revolution calls for national thinking

August 12, 2016

The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist.  The opinions expressed are his own.

British Prime Minister Theresa May probably has the right idea trying to encourage a shale gas fracking industry. But she may have the wrong strategy to implement it. Instead of doling out handouts to persuade disgruntled communities there is a tangible benefit to having a gas well in their back yard, or even generous tax breaks for investors, a better policy could be to cut out the middle man and create a national energy titan to drill the first holes and share the profits.

North Sea oil in the 1970s came with similar issues to shale. Keen to secure a home-made energy supply, Britain and Norway created national oil companies, of which only one now remains. Norway’s Statoil has since bloomed into one of the world’s biggest offshore producers, while the defunct British National Oil Corporation (BNOC) was folded into Britoil and eventually sold to BP in the 1980s.

Britain has relied on the private sector since then. The government wants to offer tax breaks to investors to frack along with handouts to local communities and land owners. May said on Aug. 7 that 10 percent of taxes siphoned into a Shale Wealth Fund could be given directly to households affected by drilling. Neither tax breaks nor handouts offer many long-term benefits.

Even with these payments and subsidies shale gas extraction may not be that profitable for companies that do the fracking. Although deliveries from overseas are up by about a quarter since 2008, prices over the same period have actually fallen. Wholesale prices for same-day delivery gas have halved in value to around 31 pence per thermal unit over the same period even as production has fallen. In any case, technically recoverable reserves may be just a fifth of those in the United States, according to estimates from the Energy Information Administration.

All that makes it hard to justify fracking based on normal market forces. That could make luring private sector participants prohibitively expensive. Look at the controversy over a planned nuclear plant at Hinkley Point, where the UK government has had to offer exorbitant prices to French energy group EDF. Given the challenges, a better strategy to get Britain fracking could be to reprise BNOC, take the risk and reward through the public purse. That way if there is a profitable future for shale, the benefit can be more widely spread instead of just the risk.

2 comments

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/

BNOC is sooo last century. The Fossil Fuel Age is over.
UK Shale Oil & Gas Fracking is not financially viable, not sustainable, not environmentally responsible, not safe, not wanted by a majority of the population and alternative renewable sources of energy generation readily available or being built.
Alternative products will have to be trialed to replace oil & gas derivatives.
(Fracking Revolution conjures up visions of a bloody battle to the death, which is bad news)

Posted by VanDutchman | Report as abusive

Unending nightmare in Ohio River Valley…the deaths, illnesses and contamination and the unspeakable lack of concern by the drilling companies should serve as a warning. Weatherford was asked to leave Switzerland following clash with corporate responsibility laws. The companies echo Enron in the removal of monies from corporation at the top of a pyramid structure. Greed and speed has destroyed so much here including water sources. Toxic and radioactive wastes are a major concern. From Stories of the Harmed you can find accounts of real families here. This is a tragic and dark horror….total denial of human rights and the dishonest manipulation of public opinion by hired academics and pr flacks. Save what is left and stop corporate abuses and devastation in the name of short term gain, long term pain.MK Hunt

Posted by mkhunt | Report as abusive