Commentaries

Now raising intellectual capital

Not the final word in GM’s Magnum Opel

September 10, 2009

GM-OPEL/So German Chancellor Angela Merkel has got her way. After months of pressure from the German government, General Motors has finally caved in and agreed to sell a majority stake in Opel to Canadian car parts maker Magna and Russian backer Sberbank.

It isn’t all over yet — GM is still attaching conditions to the sale of a 55 percent stake in “new” Opel — but the timing of the announcement and the apparently good news for Opel’s 25,000 German employees will be music to Merkel’s ears with just over two weeks to go before a Sept 27. general election.

Merkel says she doesn’t think the GM board’s decision is a delaying tactic, which says a lot about the way the talks have been conducted. But while GM and its chief negotiator John Smith have led Berlin and the various bidders a merry dance, the reality is that the once great U.S. car giant doesn’t really have much of a negotiating position: Opel needs 3.3 billion euros in loan guarantees to keep going. Only Germany is willing to come up with that kind of money.

So for now at least, GM has little choice but to keep Berlin and Opel’s unions happy by opting for Magna rather than Belgium-based financial buyer RHJ International’s bid.

But the fact that GM has not revealed any substantive details about the deal with Magna shows that all is not yet settled. The carmaker says several “key issues” will be finalised over the next few weeks.

Among these are bound to be GM’s deep-seated misgivings about the sanctity of its intellectual property rights under the Magna/Sberbank offer and the nitty-gritty of job cuts.

GM says it has the support of Opel’s unions for a restructuring and now expects a definitive agreement to be signed within a few weeks, with a deal closed in months.

That, of course, will all be after the German elections, when the issue will be less politically sensitive. GM’s Magnum Opel is far from finished.

Comments

“Among these are bound to be GM’s deep-seated misgivings about the sanctity of its intellectual property rights under the Magna/Sberbank offer…”

Yes. But this is what one has to give up when one screws up big time. So GM sells key patents to the new Opel owners, and indeed have to pay royalty to them.

Selling the ‘crown jewels’ is never easy. Back in the 80′s when US consumer electronics makers started screwing up they sold their most innovative patents to the Japanese, who proceeded to take over the world’s consumer electronics market. Will Magna, and the Russian auto makers repeat the Japanese achievement? Probably not globally, but likely so in Russia and parts of the European market. And thus the birth of a major competitor to the US auto makers. This is the price of failure.

Note to US business schools: Add this case study to your fancy MBA programs, teachers of worship of quick & easy short-term over long-term, and maybe some good will come out of it.

Posted by The Real Deal | Report as abusive
 

Post Your Comment

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
  •