Barofsky audit a Fed, not Geithner, problem

November 17, 2009

Sure, Timothy Geithner led the negotiations with AIG counterparties when he headed the New York Fed last year, but TARP special inspector Neil Barofsky’s audit is damning where it really hurts the Fed. It raises the question of whether the central bank is a tough enough regulator at a time when Senator Christopher Dodd is calling for the Fed to be stripped of such power over big banks.

Big Picture has posted the report in its entirety.

It’s one thing to be a bad regulator during the boom years when, let’s face it, there were bad regulators everywhere. But to shrink from tough negotiations with banks during the height of the crisis when those banks were already benefiting from billion of dollars in state aid will be harder to explain away, though the New York Fed has tried.

From the report:

FRBNY’s decision to treat all counterparties equally (which FRBNY officials described as a “core value” of their organization), for example gave each of the major counterparties (including the French banks) effective veto power over the possibility of a concession from any other party…

It also arguably did not account for significant differences among counterparties, including that some of them had received very substantial benefits from FRBNY and other Government agencies through various other bailout programs (including billions of dollars of taxpayer funds through TARP), a benefit not available to some of the other counterparties (including French banks)…

…the refusal of FRBNY and the Federal Reserve to use their considerable leverage as the primary regulators for several of the counterparties, including the emphasis that their participation in the negotiations was purely “voluntary,” made the possibility of obtaining concessions from those counterparties extremely remote.

Sure, it’s a fine line of when to use such leverage, but the report goes on to note that the Fed didn’t shy away from using it when, for example, it and Treasury compelled banks to take TARP funds. Similarly, the government played hard core with General Motors and Chrysler creditors when the automakers barreled toward bankruptcy.

The conspiracy theorists are sure to jump on the below.

There is no question that the effect of the FRBNY’s decisions – indeed, the very design of the federal assistance to AIG – was that tens of billions of Government money was funneled inexorably and directly to AIG’s counterparties.

I don’t think the Fed and Geithner set out intentionally to save AIG so banks would get paid,  but their unwillingness to play hardball is damning and undermines the argument that the Fed is tough enough to regulate the now even bigger, and more powerful Wall Street banks.

The Fed did an incredible job navigating the credit crisis. It may have come late to the game, but it moved quickly to soften the blow of the financial markets’ implosion. But if it wants to continue being regulator-in-chief of the bank holding companies, it better show that it has the chops and fast.


We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see

I think the Fed is pretty much done. You can thank them for this huge financial bubble that we’ve been in for the past decade. I say end the Fed and return us back to honest money that can’t be inflated away..

Posted by Iman American | Report as abusive

I think Dodd’s “legislation” is just a political tool he’s using for his re-election. He’s in big trouble and he’s trying to change his image by touting this fed bill. We’ll see soon enough how far it goes.

Posted by jason | Report as abusive

By now, everyone knows that the leader of Isreal is one of the strongest leaders in the world and that the president of the U.S is a very weak leader. There is no surprise that the leader of Isreal will do what he thinks is right for his country, no matter what other leaders think. He must protect his own people and his own country and he will!

Posted by hankster6 | Report as abusive

[...] Reuters: Barofsky audit a Fed, not Geithner, problem [...]

[...] → Geithner may have led the negotiations with AIG counterparties when he headed the New York Fed last year, but TARP special inspector Neil Barofsky’s audit is damning where it really hurts. [via Reuters] [...]

One of the most corrupt institutions the world has ever known

The following statement was made by Louis T. McFadden, Chairman of the House Banking Committee-Congressional Record, House pages 1295 and 1296 on June 10, 1932

Mr. Chairman, we have in this country one of the most corrupt institutions the world has ever known. I refer to the Federal Reserve Board and the Federal reserve banks. The Federal Reserve Board, a Government Board, has cheated the Government of the United States and the people of the United States out of enough money to pay the national debt. The depredations and the iniquities of the Federal Reserve Board and the Federal reserve banks acting together have cost this country enough money to pay the national debt several times over. This evil institution has impoverished and ruined the people of the United States; has bankrupted itself, and has practically bankrupted our Government. It has done this through the maladministration of that law by which the Federal Reserve Board, and through the corrupt practices of the moneyed vultures who control it.

Posted by Christopher W.Walker | Report as abusive

Remarks by Governor Ben S. Bernanke
At the Conference to Honor Milton Friedman, University of Chicago, Chicago, Illinois November 8, 2002
On Milton Friedman’s Ninetieth Birthday –Bernanke admits the Fed engineered the great depression of 1929-1933-
“Let me end my talk by abusing slightly my status as an official representative of the Federal Reserve. I would like to say to Milton and Anna: Regarding the Great Depression. You’re right, we did it. We’re very sorry. But thanks to you, we won’t do it again.”

Posted by Christopher W.Walker | Report as abusive