The $1.2 billion fraud alleged at Russia’s largest bank

January 22, 2010

Tucked away on page 4 of the Moscow Times today there is a remarkable article which made me wonder whether I wasn’t hallucinating.

The report states matter-of-factly that several branch managers are being investigated for defrauding $1.2 billion from Sberbank, Russia’s largest bank. That’s according to comments made by Sberbank’s regional manager for Moscow. The Moscow Times translated the article from Thursday’s edition of the Russian newspaper Vedomosti, where it appears on page 7.

According to this article, Sberbank suspects managers at three Moscow branches of doling out “thieving” loans, on the basis of “fictitious” documents, to “dubious” companies. The scale of the resulting losses at these three branches? “More than 35 billion roubles” ($1.2 billion).

When you include similar goings-on at other branches, the total figure for Sberbank’s “dubious” loans appears to be even higher still: 46.1 billion roubles, or some $1.6 billion. That it is more than double Sberbank’s total profits for last year.

This isn’t the first time that I have seen reports about fishy goings-on at the Sberbank. The fraud allegations first trickled out last summer (back then the allegations concerned just a single branch, and the figure for the losses was a mere $180 million). The news attracted so little attention it was hard to know what to make of it.

Welcome to the often surreal nature of modern Russia. The muted reaction brings to mind several other major fraud scandals over recent months that have been treated in an equally off-hand fashion.

Last April, for instance, a Moscow court convicted a certain Viktor Markelov for stealing 5.4 billion roubles ($180 million) from the Russian budget. Yet it wasn’t until December – seven months after Markelov’s conviction – that Russia’s state news agency RIA-Novosti reported on the case. It wouldn’t have attracted any attention at all, but for the scandalous death in prison in November of Sergei Magnitsky, a lawyer for the hedge fund Hermitage Capital, who had accused several police officers of complicity in the fraud.

Then there were disturbing reports last year of at least two attempts to steal tens of millions of dollars from Russia’s State Pensions Fund. These faded from the news just as quickly as they came.

And these are just the frauds which we know about. What else, one wonders, have Sberbank’s 250,000 employees been up to at the bank’s sprawling network of 20,000 branches? And what else is going on inside the other vast Russian companies and government agencies, each handling billions of dollars? In a recent survey, PricewaterhouseCoopers claimed that corporate fraud was more prevalent in Russia than in any other country.

One can’t help but wonder whether Sberbank’s extraordinary allegations don’t represent the tip of a very large iceberg.


We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see

Excellent post. I was checking continuously this blog and I am impressed! Extremely useful info specially the last part I care for such information much. I was seeking this particular information for a very long time. Thank you and best of luck.

Kimree is a world-leading e-cigarette company. According to Frost & Sullivan, Kimree was the second largest e-cigarette designer and manufacturer in the world in terms of both revenues and production volume in 2013. The Company designs and produces a broad range of e-cigarette products, including disposable e-cigarettes, rechargeable e-cigarettes and e-cigarette accessories. Visit for more.

Carry out stop by my site Freekaamaal plus share ideas and also opinion of the following.

Most people don’t simply impart magnificent codes while offering nevertheless additionally we present you with on the internet where you may write about your ideas.

It seems that quite a few very problem on to kelly felix, Attempting transform i would say some sort of football landscape designs and many types of, And i also stated the Philadelphia masses isn’t the most sufferer most typically associated with contingents. But when he considers heat comes to an end from now on, Choose he provides the actual their environment while you are their own better player sets. To make neo error in judgment, This item some kind of so if perhaps, Probably and never which, McCoy comes in contact with damage.

Color Color preference largely affect your choice of a wallet. Hence, you’re going to get full usage of all its ports and operations without the need to get rid of the case out of your phone. Regardless of the brilliance with the artwork and constructive public reception, the exhibit encountered criticism in Ny, in which its presence in Central Park was considered a cynical use of public room for a business interest. Adidas Skateboarding are the shoes that are specifically made for skateboarding. IPads are for consuming and interacting with a wide amount of content. IRG focuses on event driven and special situations including Mergers and Acquisitions, Recapitalizations and Restructurings, Management Buyouts, Late Stage Private Equity Capital Raisings, and Asia Market Entry Strategies. A humidor adds humidity to the cigars’ environment. The ultimate fashion trend image, Paris Hilton’s design is mostly flawless, although there have actually been several occasions where she has actually been apprehended by the style police for committing fashion trend artificial pas of the greatest order.

Whoa, be considered a glorious little bit of article which I have see in the prolonged number of years. Do likewise excursion the actual web.

2 Louis Vuitton Purses YyB Louis Vuitton Outlet EqB Louis Vuitton Backpack Tso Louis Vuitton Outlet Store EuU Louis Vuitton Purses EdU Louis Vuitton Speedy TcX Louis Vuitton Outlet YdX Louis Vuitton Outlet N Coach Outlet Online FOhG Coach Outlet Online FEhG Coach Factory Outlet GLsZ Coach Purses FEdD Coach Factory FLeS Lululemon Outlet GOsZ Lululemon Yoga Pants GGhS Lululemon Sale DEhN Cheap Lululemon FLdD lululemon VKeW Michael Kors Handbags GGsF Michael Kors Outlet FRsW Michael Kors Factory Outlet DKhA Michael Kors Handbags DLdA Michael Kors Handbags FEhN Coach Factory Outlet GShD Coach Outlet Online RSeZ Coach Factory Outlet REbW Coach Handbags DSwE Coach Outlet Online VLhZ Michael Kors Outlet FRhW Michael Kors Handbags FShA