Procrastination is not a virtue, except when it involves billions of dollars of debt.
The war between Continental and Schaeffler rumbles on. Karl-Thomas Neumann has got board assent for the capital increase he wants to pay down Continental’s heavy debts, a hard-fought for move that is likely to dilute the company’s largest shareholder Schaeffler.
But it is only a partial victory for the chief executive of the German auto parts group — and one that may yet turn out to be Pyrrhic. Neumann may yet be ejected from Conti for resisting Maria-Elisabeth Schaeffler and her right-hand man Juergen Geissinger (CEO of the privately-owned ball-bearing maker).
Schaeffler has already seen off several former Conti bosses — Manfred Wennemer left in August last year and CFO Alan Hippe has since quit. If it succeeds in pushing out Neumann and replacing him with its own candidate, Elmar Degenhart — at a meeting scheduled for August 12 — Schaeffler will then certainly push ahead with the sale of Conti’s well-known rubber business as a way of reducing its 11 billion euro debt.
Conti and Schaeffler have been deadlocked since the private group took a majority stake last year after an acrimonious takeover battle. Schaeffler’s ability to exercise control is constrained by its own heavy borrowings, much of which are against Conti stock which has lost two-thirds of its value.
Meanwhile, Conti is also labouring under massive borrowings, which its banks would like it to reduce. Both groups are at odds over how to reconcile their differing interests. Schaeffler, which has entered into a standstill agreement which prevents it from taking over Conti till 2012, does not want the target to issue more equity because it doesn’t have the cash to follow its money. Nor does it want to merge with Conti because it fears the exchange ratio would be disadvantageous.
What it would like is for Conti to sell assets to reduce its debt — even though this is hardly an ideal moment to do this. Shares in Michelin <MICP.PA> are trading at less than half their mid-2007 peak, while Bridgestone <5108.T> shares are at just over half their level in May 2006 and Pirelli <PECI.MI> shares are less than a quarter of their peak.
Neumann wanted Conti to raise 1.5 billion euros in fresh equity and then to merge with Schaeffler. The board has now consented to the first of these moves. However it remains to be seen if the banks will be queuing up to underwrite the issue, especially as Conti seems keen to issue it at a very narrow discount to the market price.
If Conti goes ahead, and neither Schaeffler nor its allies follow their money, Schaeffler’s direct stake could fall to 35 percent from 49.9 percent and its total stake (including shares held by its banks) to 63 percent from nearly 90 percent.
What seems clear is that the key players in this deadlock are the banks to both companies. They may themselves have differing interests. Conti’s bankers may not be keen on a change of management at the company, especially given the rapid changes which have already taken place at the top. And Schaeffler’s bankers might not welcome capital increases at Conti that diluted their equity position.
Debt has become an albatross around the necks of both companies, which only the banks are able to remove.