Commentaries

Now raising intellectual capital

Forecasting takedown

-

It’s a wonder that anyone has any faith in forecasting anymore. The failure of ratings agencies to see the storm brewing in subprime and economists to fully grasp the vulnerability of the financial system should be making cynics out of all of us. Paul Krugman devoted 8 page screens over at the New York Times explaining what went wrong with economists. I must admit, I stopped reading after this line:

As I see it, the economics profession went astray because economists, as a group, mistook beauty, clad in impressive-looking mathematics, for truth.

Bank of America Merrill Lynch analysts devoted a portion of their research to a glitch they see in forecasting corporate default rates. For high-yield bond and loan investors, default rates are a key component in trying to figure out whether it’s time to snap up that incredibly risky CCC debt or exit quickly. If they’re looking at S&P and Moody’s forecasts it could be both.

Moody’s forecasts defaults to peak at 12.6% in November 2009, and then
improve rapidly over the next 9 months, reaching 4.3% by next year, a level which
is below historical average of 4.8%. This puts the two major rating agencies on
the opposite ends of default forecasting spectrum. S&P is forecasting a 13.9%
default rate in a year from now.

  •