Drivers say Honda hybrid doesn’t go that extra mile-court

January 13, 2009

Green car owners have apparently complained in such large numbers that the Honda Civic Hybrid isn’t living up to high mileage claims that the carmaker has approached U.S. government regulators about revising its mileage guidelines, according to a lawsuit by one Honda hybrid owner.

A California appellate opinion filed on Monday showed that a Honda customer service representative told Gaetano Paduano, the dissatisfied owner of a 2004 Honda hybrid, that the company had received “a high number of complaints” that the sedan achieves significantly less than its promised mileage of 47-plus miles per gallon.

The rep also told Paduano that the company and rival Toyota have approached the U.S. EPA to change the mileage rating on their hybrid cars, the opinion said.

Another Honda rep told Paduano that he probably couldn’t achieve the advertised mileage by driving the vehicle like a conventional car, despite claims to the contrary in a Honda brochure advertising the vehicle, the opinion said. 

A Honda spokesman would not comment on the pending litigation. 

Paduano’s lawsuit, filed in 2005, follows at least one other legal action over low mileage complaints for the Honda Civic Hybrid, the other filed in U.S. District Court and decided last year.

The San Diego based appeals court ruled that Paduano can go ahead with his false advertising lawsuit against Honda in a California state court.


We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see

Why are there no articles on Agent Orange causing Parkinsons Disease?

Posted by Gary Boss | Report as abusive

This mileage problem has already been proven on all gasoline type cars. The mileage is determined by the companies on a closed course, not in the real world that’s the problem.

Posted by ran | Report as abusive

I purchased a Honda hybrid last summer and I’ve been very disappointed as well. The mpg is still a lot better than comparable sedans but I do feel a bit mislead. Was expecting a lot better mileage.

My next purchase will be a hybrid. But not a Honda.

Posted by Michael Harvey | Report as abusive

[…] Environment » Blog Archive » Drivers say Honda hybrid doesn’t go … […]

Posted by How hybrid cars works | | Report as abusive

[…] Environment » Blog Archive » Drivers say Honda hybrid doesn’t go … […]

Posted by 2010 Toyota Prius | | Report as abusive

Bought a 2009 Civic Hybrid in 4/09. My digital dash gauge consistently reads that I’m getting 40+ MPG, but when I gas up and compare the real numbers, I’m only getting 25 MPG.

Posted by Mike | Report as abusive

I always look to the site they give real world MPG numbers and will adjust their published figures accordingly.

Posted by Thomas | Report as abusive