Pius XII biographer raps rabbi for recalling Holocaust role

October 7, 2008

Cover of Tornielli’s book Pius XII, Eugenio Pacelli, A Man on the Throne of PeterA leading Italian biographer of Pope Pius XII has sharply criticised Rabbi Shear-Yashuv Cohen for recalling the controversy about the pope’s role in the Holocaust during an unprecedented address to a synod of Roman Catholic bishops at the Vatican. Andrea Tornielli, the Vatican correspondent of the newspaper Il Giornale who has written four books defending the wartime pope, said no cardinal could have ever spoken that way at a major Jewish forum in Jerusalem.

Cohen, the chief rabbi of Haifa in Israel, was the first Jew to address such a synod. In unscripted remarks, he told the bishops that Jews “cannot forget the sad and painful fact of how many, including great religious leaders, didn’t raise their voice in the effort to save our brethren but chose to keep silent and helped secretly.” Defenders of Pius, who was pope from 1939 to 1958, say he did he did his utmost to help Jews during the Holocaust; Pope Benedict repeated this recently in his first public statement on his predecessor. But his critics fault Pius for not publicly challenging the Nazis by denouncing the Holocaust.

Tornielli focused special attention on Cohen’s statement in a Reuters interview prior to his Andrea Torniellisynod speech. The 80-year old rabbi told our Vatican correspondent Phil Pullella that he might not have attended the synod if he had known in advance that Pius would be honoured there. The synod will mark the 50th anniversary of his death in 1958 with a special mass on Thursday at which Benedict may announce that Pius will soon be beatified. Tornielli wrote on his blog Sacri Palazzi (Sacred Palaces):

“Apart from the fact that the date of Pius XII’s death is not exactly a secret of the Mossad and can be found in all encyclopedias, and apart from the fact that the 50th anniversary represents an important milestone, I find it totally inappropriate that a Jewish leader invited to speak Catholic bishops uses the occasion to embarrass the Pope, and on the basis of black legends to boot. I leave to your imagination what would have happened if a cardinal of the Roman curia had been invited to speak at a major Jewish religious forum in Jerusalem and then, on his way out, had made statements of a similar tenor to journalists. Let me simply remind Rabbi Cohen of the words spoken by a distinguished colleague, the Grand Rabbi of Jerusalem Isaac Herzog, in 1944: ‘The people of Israel will never forget what His Holiness and his illustrious delegates, inspired by the eternal principles of religion which are the foundations of genuine civilization, are doing for our Cover of Hitler’s Priestsunfortunate brothers and sisters at the most tragic hour in our history. (This is) living proof of Divine Providence in this world.’ After the death of Pope Pacelli, the same Herzog declared: “The death of Pius XII is a great loss for the entire free world. Catholics are not the only ones to regret his death.”

The Pius controversy doesn’t split neatly along Catholic-Jewish lines. Only last month, the mixed Jewish-Catholic group Pave The Way from the United States visited Pope Benedict and held a conference in Rome giving a positive assessment of the pope’s record. And an American Catholic priest, Kevin Spicer, has just published a critical study entitled Hitler’s Priests.

The issue of the Catholic Church and the Third Reich is not going away anytime soon.


We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/

Rabbi Shear-Yashuv Cohen’s main problem with the Catholic Church is that he believes that the church did not do enough for the victims of the holocaust. He admits that the Catholic Church and Pope Pius XII were instrumental in helping many Jews. But he wishes that they did more. I say to Rabbi Shear-Yashuv Cohen that the Pope Pius XII did more than any other religious leader of his day and I challenge anyone to show me a religious leader who did more (including Jewish leaders). That is why the Grand Rabbi of Jerusalem Isaac Herzog chose to honor the Pontiff.

Posted by Daniel Bishop | Report as abusive

The Head of the Catholic Church is Jesus Christ. When He was put to death by the insistance of the Jews, His response while hanging on the cross was “Father forgive them, they know not what they do”.

Posted by Maryellen Ortiz | Report as abusive

Well, the Grand Rabbi of Jerusalem, Isaac Herzog, in 1944 was certainly grateful for what Pope Pius XII did for the Jews so why isn’t that enough to satisfy Rabbi Shear-Yashuv Cohen? I find it sad indeed that this Rabbi doesn’t even appreciate anything the Pope did for the Jews. This Rabbi will not stop Pope Pius XII from becoming a saint with his unjust remarks and I pray very soon that he is beatified. God’s will be done!

Posted by Dolorosa | Report as abusive

attacs against Pius XII originated in Germany with Hochhut´s calomnious play. In 1963 most Jewish Communities have been defending Pope and church strongly und Jewisch Theatre Directors, against leftist and protestant media pressure, denied presenting the play on stage,s.a. Hirschfeld in Zuerich. Old Jewish Survivors in Italy still today s how greatest gratitude and love for the Pacelli Pope. That´s what counts and not Rabbi Cohen´s words.

Posted by gottstein juerg | Report as abusive