Arab revolts set to transform Middle East

April 4, 2011

(Bahraini anti-government protesters in central Manama, February 16, 2011/Hamad I Mohammed)

The astonishing popular protests against Arab autocrats that have churned the region for three months are the authentic birth pangs of a new Middle East. Israel’s American-backed attempts to bomb Hezbollah and south Lebanon into submission in 2006 did not change the region, as Condoleezza Rice predicted it would. Nor did the U.S.-led invasion of Iraq three years earlier, which former President George W. Bush touted as introducing democracy to the Arab world, have much effect.

The change now is coming from within — and from below. Ordinary people taking to the streets swept away the presidents of Egypt and Tunisia. The leaders of Libya and Yemen are fighting for survival. Arab leaders almost everywhere else are trying to fend off real or potential challenges with a mix of repression and concessions.

“The rulers are running scared, with good reason — the people have terrified them,” said Rashid Khalidi, professor of Arab studies at Columbia University in New York. “The spectre of popular power haunts the dictators and monarchs.”

The region’s mostly Muslim citizens are at last proving they are no exception to the democratic trends that have transformed eastern Europe, Latin America and much of Africa and Asia in recent decades. The pro-democracy movement will reshape the Arab world as powerfully as the ideologies of Arab nationalism, socialism, communism and political Islam in the last 150 years, argues Paul Salem, director of the Carnegie Endowment’s Middle East Center in Beirut.

“It is a sea change,” he said. “The change is profound. It hits people’s identities, their core. “Islam is still the most powerful current, but this paradigm has in a way superseded and absorbed it, creating the democratic, pluralist, human rights value system as the dominant one.”

But ousting authoritarian rulers is one thing, installing stable systems of representative government quite another. Turkey’s mixed experiences suggest a possible partnership between the government and the military in Egypt that could promote stability, if not full civilian rule for now. Turkey’s AK party, which combines Islamist roots with a modern outlook, has gradually forced the military to retreat from politics, an achievement admired by Arab reformers.

Khalidi said the Turkish model was attractive “in the sense of keeping the military out of politics, having an independent foreign policy, accepting the idea that Islam plays a role within politics, but in an essentially secular system”.

Read the full analysis here.


Follow FaithWorld on Twitter at RTRFaithWorld

rss buttonSubscribe to all posts via RSS


We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see

a report released recently shows that the prince of Saudi Arabia plans to pay US$ 4 billion to avoid a trial of former President Mubarak and his family. The report is here: -tycoon-offers-us4-billion-to-rescue-mub arak/

Posted by Wajc | Report as abusive

[…] FaithWorld […]

Posted by » Blog Archive » Arab revolts set to transform Middle East | Report as abusive

I appreaciate the upbeat assessment, but discounting efforts by Pres. Bush to promote democracy within the region is shortsighted. Whether or not Iraq, in particular, has been a success can be debated, but the message contained within the Freedom Agenda corresponds well with the demands being made of the region’s governments. One could just as easily claim that the protesters are clinging to the promise of the Freedom Agenda before it disappears entirely under the current US President.

Posted by mheld45 | Report as abusive