Dutch self-image shaken by “Black Pete” debate

November 13, 2013

(A woman dressed as “Zwarte Piet” (Black Pete), the helper of Saint Nicholas (C), takes part in a traditional parade in central Brussels, where the Dutch Christmas tradition is also observed. December 1, 2012. REUTERS/Francois Lenoir)

The Dutch see themselves as tolerant pragmatists, especially adaptable if social harmony or commercial interests demand it.

But that self-image has taken a battering in recent weeks as a growing chorus of voices inside and outside the country protest against a Christmas tradition that many Dutch see as harmless fun but critics say is racist.

According to the folklore, Saint Nicholas arrives in the Netherlands in mid-November accompanied by his servant Black Pete – a part usually played by a white man in “blackface” with a curly wig and large, red-painted mouth.

Now the Dutch are being forced to confront the possibility that their enormously popular Christmas tradition might point to a latent racism which many thought was anathema to their culture.

Few debates have stirred such emotion among the cool-headed Dutch. Millions flocked to “like” a Facebook page backing Black Pete after an independent expert who reports to the U.N. Human Rights Council criticized the tradition.

(A woman dressed as “Zwarte Piet” (Black Pete), the helper of Saint Nicholas, throws candy from the balcony of the City Hall at Brussels’ Grand Place December 1, 2012. REUTERS/Francois Lenoir )

Prime Minister Mark Rutte has rejected depictions of the Netherlands as insular and xenophobic.

“I do not recognize ourselves in that portrayal,” he told reporters last week when asked whether the Netherlands no longer tolerated outsiders.

But that is the point that has been exposed by the debate, according to Quinsy Gario, an artist who has campaigned against the Black Pete tradition for years.

“We’ve lied to ourselves about our tolerance for so long that we don’t recognize discrimination anymore,” he said. “There has been structural exclusion of minorities for decades.”

He said the children of the many immigrants to the Netherlands were becoming increasingly vocal about confronting signs of racism that their parents may have chosen to ignore.

“You have third- and fourth- generation people who see it as their own country and they want to take responsibility for their own and their kids’ sake,” he said.

The furor over the revered tradition, which some art historians say has its roots in a 17th century fashion for well-to-do Amsterdam families keeping a black house slave, has exposed the sensitivity of race in the Netherlands.

Wealthy and fast-growing in the years after World War Two, the Netherlands was a major destination for economic migrants from southern Europe, Turkey and Morocco in the 1950s and 1960s.

(Two young women dressed as Black Pete, in Zoetermeer, Netherlands, Nov 14, 2009/Archibald  Ballentine)

In 2010, around 11 percent of the population was foreign-born, according to Eurostat. Most have acquired Dutch citizenship, a sign of the country’s successful integration policies.

Out of a population of around 16 million people, more than 3.5 million are foreign-born Dutch citizens or the children of non-Dutch immigrants, according to the official statistics agency. The largest immigrant populations include those from Turkey, the former Dutch colony of Suriname and Morocco.

Some Dutch blame the influence of outsiders, from Muslims to interfering European Union bureaucrats, for the erosion of Dutch culture and social benefits, particularly at a time when many Dutch are feeling the pinch of the economic slowdown.

“Many Dutch people feel fundamentally threatened,” said Laurens Buijs, a sociologist at the University of Amsterdam.¬† “As if they feel Brussels, or the UN, want to take away who we are, our identity.”

Such fears have boosted support for Geert Wilders, the populist anti-Islam politician who wants to stop immigration by Muslims as well as eastern Europeans, and wants the Netherlands to leave the euro and claw back powers from Brussels. He has even set up a website where people could file complaints about eastern Europeans.

Andre Krouwel, a political scientist at Amsterdam’s VU University, agreed an intolerant streak has been exposed. “It’s evidenced by the strength of anti-Muslim parties compared to other countries like Germany,” he said. The Dutch record in fighting discrimination has been criticized in recent months by Amnesty International and the Council of Europe, the continent’s human rights watchdog.

(A woman dressed as “Zwarte Piet” (Black Pete), the helper of Saint Nicholas (C), offers fruits to children during a traditional parade in central Brussels December 1, 2012. REUTERS/Francois Lenoir )

Most big-circulation Dutch newspapers leapt to the Netherlands’ defense when Verene Shepherd, a Jamaican academic who heads a U.N. working group of independent experts on discrimination against people of African descent, said in late October that the tradition of Black Pete was racist.

On Tuesday, U.N. High Commissioner for Human Rights Navi Pillay made clear that Shepherd was speaking in her own capacity and not for the Geneva-based office.

The daily Algemeen Dagblad gave over its front page to a montage of portraits of black and Asian Dutch citizens, all of whom said they supported the tradition.

But in an opinion piece for the Volkskrant newspaper, Roomyla Choenni, a Dutch consultant of Surinamese descent at IT outsourcer Capgemini, said Black Pete “keeps alive an atmosphere of everyday racism.”

“In many people’s eyes, the Netherlands is meant for white people, preferably with blue eyes and rosy cheeks,” he wrote.

Many of the Africans who work at the international courts in The Hague as judges, prosecutors, lawyers and court officers – services which contribute to the region’s economic growth – privately admit that they have experienced racism.

When one African judge told a taxi driver she worked at one of the international courts, he asked her if she was the cleaner, the judge told Reuters. Another senior court official said she spent months trying to find a place to live when she first arrived.

“Each time they saw it was an African, I was told the apartment was not available any more,” she said.

Polls show that the main opposition in the Netherlands to the tradition of Black Pete is in cosmopolitan Amsterdam. The local council in the southeast part of the city, where many immigrants live, voted to ban the festivities this year.

But the majority still want Black Pete. In a survey by pollster Maurice De Hond last month, 91 percent of a representative sample of Dutch people said the tradition should not be changed to suit the tastes of a minority, and 81 percent thought it would be unacceptable to turn Pete another color.

Rutte said the debate was inevitable and healthy given the number of immigrants now in the Netherlands.

“It’s unavoidable that when you have a huge inflow of people then you get tensions,” he said. “Initial reactions from society are for no big changes at the moment … (but) traditions can change over time.”

But many Dutch eyes have been opened, Gario said.

“People are starting to realize that some people here are staunchly, obtusely racist.”

via Dutch self-image shaken by Black Pete debate by Thomas Escritt.


We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/

If you write an article about a tradition and you want to be taken seriously, please make sure you get it all right. You start off by saying several times that Sinterklaas is a Christmas tradition. It has absolutely nothing to do with Christmas other than the fact that Coca Cola based its Santa Claus on the Dutch Sinterklaas. But saying Sinterklaas is a Christmas tradition is like saying Halloween is a Christmas tradition.

Zwarte Pieten also don’t have ‘big red lips’, like the pictures clearly show. They just have red lipstick on their regular sized lips.

Finally this debate is not so much between native Dutch and immigrants, or between white people and people with darker skins, but more between people, regardless of colour, who think that a society should get rid of anything that is considered offensive by anyone on the one hand, and people who think there are always going to be things that certain people will feel offended by in a free society and that it’s up to those people to not make such a big deal out of it on the other hand. Because otherwise nothing will be possible any more and all a society will be doing is avoiding stepping on overly sensitive people’s toes.

Posted by Openup | Report as abusive

Only the Dutch & Flemish Belgians don’t see their own racism. I remember being shocked to see my first blackface Zwarte Piet (Black Pete) and even more shocked at how adamantly the locals defended this as their righteous age-old tradition.

Posted by euro-yank | Report as abusive