Reuters Blogs

FaithWorld

Religion, faith and ethics

Author Archive

September 22nd, 2008

Argentina opts for family man to help patch up ties with Vatican

Posted by: Hilary Burke

Pope Benedict meets ambasadors to the Holy See, 9 January 2006/poolArgentina is making a second bid to improve relations with the Vatican after its first attempt caused a diplomatic blunder because Buenos Aires proposed a divorced Catholic with a live-in partner as its new ambassador to the Holy See. The new nominee is reported to be a safer bet. Former government minister Juan Pablo Cafiero is married and the father of four children. In a radio interview over the weekend, he defended the centre-left government as  “the first government in decades that has focused on the distribution of wealth and a preference for the poor … linked to a concept of social justice that is based on humanistic, Christian thinking.”

Local media reported earlier this year that Argentina might leave the post vacant after the Vatican gave a thumbs down to former Justice Minister Alberto Iribarne. The Vatican never actually rejected his nomination. It just never confirmed it, which was a clear message that he didn’t have a prayer. As befits a future ambassador, Cafiero made no reference to that diplomatic faux pas.

The Roman Catholic Church does not approve of divorce and Catholics who do end their marriages are required to seek an annulment from the Church before they can remarry with the Church’s blessing.

Argentina’s President Cristina Fernandez De Kirchner, 2 August 2008/Enrique MarcarianRelations with the Church were rocky under the government of Nestor Kirchner, the husband and predecessor of President Cristina Fernandez.  He criticized church complicity during the country’s brutal 1976-1983 military dictatorship. And his health minister, who favored loosening restrictions on abortion, had an ugly, public spat with the bishop that tended to the country’s military forces. That bishop was removed and never replaced, and rumors have abounded that the government wants to scrap the post of military bishop altogether as a way of retaliating against the Vatican.

Fernandez tried to patch up ties after taking office last December, meeting right away with the head of the Argentine Bishops’ Conference.  But she stumbled when the Vatican quietly rejected her nomination of Iribarne as ambassador to the Holy See.

June 13th, 2008

Debate over who’s a “real Jew” roils Argentine Jewish community

Posted by: Hilary Burke

AMIA logoThe newly elected president of Argentina’s biggest Jewish community center sparked a firestorm when he was quoted in the press as saying he wanted the group to represent “genuine Jews” who live strictly by the Torah.

Guillermo Borger is the first Orthodox Jew elected to head the AMIA (Argentine Israeli Mutual Association) center in Buenos Aires, which was founded 114 years ago. Argentina’s Jewish community is the largest in Latin America with nearly 200,000 members.

Borger was quoted last weekend by Argentina’s biggest daily newspaper Clarin as saying he planned to “reinforce AMIA’s role in representing genuine Jews.” When asked what made a Jew genuine, he said: “It’s having a life based on all the Torah’s teachings.”

Luis GrynwaldConservative and secular Jews pounced on the statement, slamming Borger’s comments as narrow and discriminatory. The outgoing president of AMIA, Luis Grynwald, said he included himself among the Jews “who are not ‘genuine,’ and don’t have a life based on what the Torah dictates,” according to the Argentina-based Agencia Judía de Noticias (Jewish News Agency).

“Being Jewish is teaching my children and grandchildren the importance of inclusion, belonging, respect and honesty … each person expresses Judaism in his own way, I do so with pride and great honor,” Grynwald said.

Argentine writer Marcos Aguinis called Borger’s remarks “a medieval step backward,” warning that AMIA could lose members if the group’s pluralistic tradition were scrapped.

Borger came out later in the week, saying he had never said anything to distinguish between genuine and “non-genuine” Jews and adding that he aimed to reinforce AMIA’s role as “the representative of all Jews, without any exclusions.”

“We want an AMIA for everyone that is open and pro-dialogue,” he said in a statement.

AMIA bombing on 18 July 1994/Enrique MarcarianNot everyone was put at ease, however, and some AMIA members led a protest against Borger’s comments on Thursday. “Now they say you’re not a Jew unless you’re Orthodox, fundamentalist and religious … that excludes 98.5 percent of the Jewish community,” a middle-aged man told local television.

The AMIA center became international news in 1994, when a bombing there killed 85 people.

April 23rd, 2008

Former bishop wins presidency of Paraguay

Posted by: Hilary Burke

Fernando Lugo, 22 April 2008/stringerFernando Lugo shed his cassock to win Paraguay’s presidential election on Sunday, ending 61 years of one-party rule in the South American country. Lugo stepped down as bishop of one of Paraguay’s neediest areas three years ago, saying he felt powerless to help the poor. A year later, he left the priesthood to launch his political career.

The Vatican responded by suspending him, but he remains a bishop under canon law because the Catholic Church views ordination as a lifelong sacrament.

Paraguay’s bishops said they recognise the mild-mannered, sandal-wearing Lugo as the new president, adding this may be the first country where a Catholic bishop has been elected leader.

It’s unclear how this might affect diplomatic relations between Paraguay and the Vatican.

“I understand this is the first time this happens and so the Pope will have to analyse this. I don’t know what measure he’ll take,” Monsignor Ignacio Gogorza, the head of Paraguay’s bishops’ conference, told local radio.

Local media reported that Lugo, 56, had expressed an interest in serving as bishop again, once his presidential term ends in 2013.

“For that to happen, he’d have to pass through a period of penitence and reflection, if the Church were to accept that. If not, he’d be a suspended bishop for life,” Gogorza said.

Bishop Adalberto Martinez, secretary-general of the bishops’ conference, said Paraguay’s bishops will continue to consider Lugo a friend after collaborating with him for 12 years.

“This is such a special and historic situation, that I think it deserves special attention from the Holy See,” Martinez was quoted as saying in Paraguayan daily La Nacion.

The Paraguayan people welcomed Lugo’s entry in politics since the Catholic Church is one of the most respected institutions in a country where corruption and nepotism abounds.

Fernando Lugo celebrates his victory, 21 April 2008/Jorge AdornoThousands of Paraguayans flocked to a central square in Paraguay’s capital, Asuncion, to celebrate Lugo’s victory on Sunday night.

Among them was Delfina Ramirez, a Catholic nun.

“This triumph is incredible, we had been waiting for it for a long time,” Ramirez said. When asked what she thought of the Vatican’s opinion, she forcefully gestured with her hands as if to say: “Who cares?”

February 15th, 2008

Diplomatic blunder hurts church-state ties in Argentina

Posted by: Hilary Burke

President Cristina Fernandez de Kirchner, 16 Jan. 2008/Marcos BrindicciArgentina’s new president, Cristina Fernandez de Kirchner, is trying to improve relations with the Roman Catholic Church, but progress doesn’t come easy. Church-state ties turned tense under her husband Nestor, who preceded her as president from 2003 to 2007, because he occasionally alluded to church complicity in the country’s brutal 1976-1983 military dictatorship. And his health minister, who favored loosening restrictions on abortion, had a public spat with the bishop assigned to tending to the country’s military forces.

So when Fernandez took office in December, she moved quickly to patch things up. One step she took was to meet the head of the Argentine Bishops’ Conference , Cardinal Jorge Mario Bergoglio, a Jesuit who ran against Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger in the 2005 papal election. However, the honeymoon didn’t last long. This time the problem was with the Vatican, which effectively rejected her new ambassador to the Holy See. The candidate, former Justice Minister Alberto Iribarne, is Catholic but divorced and living with a new partner, something the Church does not approve of.

Saint Peter’s Basilica in Vatican CityThe Vatican did not reject Iribarne’s nomination outright. It simply did not confirm him in the post, which in diplomatic terms means he hasn’t got a prayer. Local media report that Argentina is awaiting some formal response from the Vatican, but local Church sources say that is unlikely to materialise.

Argentina is expected to leave the post unfilled for now if the Vatican doesn’t unexpectedly accept Iribarne. “This issue is strictly between the Vatican and the government,” a source who works at Argentina’s Church offices said. “It’s unfortunate that this has come up now, when we were making progress toward good relations.”

The government has been reported to be considering scrapping the post of military bishop in retaliation against the Vatican. But a government source said although officials would like to eliminate the post, it was “not on the agenda” for now. All the same, the discussion was another opportunity for the Church’s critics to air their complaint that some military Christian von Wernich is led into a courtroom at his trial, 9 Sept. 2007/Enrique Marcarianchaplains used confessions to squeeze information out of torture victims during the dictatorship.

The Church’s collaboration with the dictatorship is far from forgotten here. Last October, an Argentine court handed down a life prison sentence to a priest, former police chaplain Christian Von Wernich, convicting him of involvement in torture, kidnapping and murder during the notorious “dirty war” purge of suspected leftists.

January 25th, 2008

Bolivians shrink their dreams to please Andean prosperity god Ekeko

Posted by: Hilary Burke

An Ekeko statue, 24 Jan. 2001/David MercadoBolivians are crowding the steep cobbled streets of La Paz these days to pay homage to Ekeko, the squat mustached Andean god of abundance. They load down colourful Ekeko statues with tiny items representing prosperity, something elusive in South America’s poorest country. It’s the annual festival of Alasita, the time when Bolivians like to buy trinkets representing their wishes for the new year in the hope Ekeko will make them come true.

The festival of Alasita (“buy me” in the indigenous Aymara language) combines local Aymara traditions and Roman Catholic beliefs. In keeping with its traditional roots, a shaman often blesses the trinkets with incense, flower petals and rubbing alcohol. But many participants also climb the stairs to the Roman Catholic cathedral for the blessing of Our Lady of La Paz.

Inside, men in white robes toss holy water onto people’s purchases, creating a muddy slop on the cathedral floor. The faithful throw tiny dollar bills, or bolivianos, at a flower-covered altar to the Virgin Mary. Some of them just ask that their bags of goodies be placed close to the altar for a moment, to receive her blessing.

A shaman blesses toy money at the Alasita festival, 24 Jan 1999/David MercadoThe stalls lining the streets sell everything from teensy wads of euros to miniature diplomas for industrial engineers and gynecologists. Their tables are dotted with small pots of gold, good-luck frogs and mini-SUVs. Tiny scarecrow-like figures on display are meant to represent maids.

Two giggling young women buy rooster statues to give to one another, in the hope they’ll both find boyfriends in the coming year. “That’s the tradition, that this will come true,” said Lizzette Ramos, 18.

The toy money is also used to symbolically pay off debts. Several people hand me bills, one woman to pay for life insurance, another to repay a bank loan and a third “for her trip to the United States”. After performing the ritual, an old woman in the long braids and layered skirts typical of La Paz’s indigenous population declared: “I don’t owe anything anymore!”

Bolivia’s President Evo Morales receives hen statue at Alasita festival, 24 Jan. 2008/David MercadoBolivia’s first Indian leader, President Evo Morales, opened the main Alasita street fair on Thursday calling to the crowd: “May Ekeko give prosperity and justice to all!” An artisan gave him a statue of a hen, so he can find a partner during the coming year, and handed him another for the vice president, who is also a bachelor.

He also received a tiny version of the government’s controversial new constitution, which he hopes to implement despite stiff opposition.

Cristhiam Casazola, a 26-year-old doctor, did some shopping for his whole family, buying a basket of miniature food items and a large pot of gold, representing bounty. “I also bought some bread,” he says, “because we should never be without.”