Oh no he didn’t. Unfortunately, oh yes he did.
Rocker David Cook bombed on “American Idol” Tuesday night with an unfamiliar song and cocky performance that made it seem like he believed he had already wrapped up the competition.
Cook chose “Innocent,” a song by Canadian alternative rock band Our Lady Peace, to sing on a night when contestants were told to choose music that inspires them. The night’s theme was intended as a preview for “Idol Gives Back,” the show’s charity special that airs on Wednesday.
Cook, wearing a white military-style jacket, strutted around without his signature guitar, finally sauntering through the audience while he sang. But judges Randy Jackson and Simon Cowell were decidedly uninspired, with Cowell calling it “a teensy weensy bit pompous.” Only Paula Abdul liked it.
To make a bad performance even worse — cringe-worthy, in fact – Cook ended it by raising a palm scrawled with the words “give back” up to the cameras. The judges praised him for that move, but Cook already appeared completely deflated after their criticisms of the performance.
It was clearly a rude awakening for Cook, who has become a favorite with the show’s fans in the last few weeks.
Another weak performance was Irish diva Carly Smithson’s take on Queen’s “The Show Must Go On.”
Smithson, who had a stellar run on the show at the beginning of the season, is clearly struggling. Cowell, who called her performance “angry,” said she may even be vulnerable to elimination this week. If that does happen, Smithson would be going home before Kristy Lee Cook, the leggy blonde country singer who has narrowly escaped the hatchet for several weeks running.
Trackback
116 comments so far
David Cook is beyond arrogant. I used to like him, but forget it! He did himself in tonight.
- Posted by JaneYou can hardly call someone that you know nothing about arrogant. Just because they appear to be one way on a stage, doesn’t always reflect how the person is in real life. Give this guy a break with an open mind. If you feel so strongly that he is so arrogant, go search and learn more about him. You might be suprised on what information you find.
- Posted by Sophie~*i love david cook*~
- Posted by mariahe is sooo hot and the best singer idol has had..apart from his vocal ability its his daring song choice and arrangment that sets him apart..and that smirky smile..i love u david!
I actually like it!
- Posted by FantasienWhat arrogance are you guys talking about? Other than the choir drowning him out, it was a good performance (although admittedly not his best). In no way have i seen arrogance from David. What, because some stylist put him in a white jacket (nice change from the all black ensembles he usually wears). What, because he wrote give back on his palm. His performance is the only one that actually moved me to actually donate.
- Posted by DanutaSometimes I think people just mimic what the judges say.The judges influence the voters,which shouldn’t happen. David Archuleta obviously has the best singing voice,however this is about reaching the masses.I don’t understand how David Cook’s performance can be called “arrogant”. And who is SImon Cowell to criticize David Cook’s white jacket? What does that have to do with anything? What is pompous or arrogant about having “give back” on the palm of your hand? Have we become so jaded and cynical that this gesture cannot be seen as a sincere one? We have lost our way. And thankfully,David Cook doesn’t get into verbal back and forths when he doesn’t agree with what the judges say. He is at LEAST,gracious. I don’t see him as arrogant at ALL! Michael Johns fits that bill,if anyone of the eight,or Kristy Lee Cook.
- Posted by Karen McCulloughThis is becomeing another David Archuleta issue! He has a bad night where people are thinking, “WHAT IS GOING THROUGH HIS HEAD?”, and so is he. He is not going to be eliminated, and he will bump it up next week. Im predicting Archuleta and D.Cook in the final 2.
- Posted by MattDavid Cook is a brilliant singer and performer, undeniably sexy and there is strong evidence that he has a good heart. Let’s not forget that “Since top 12 week he has also been wearing an orange wristband to support a 7-year-old fan with leukemia.”- Wikipedia and that last week his “heart was palpitating at a high rate and his blood pressure was high” yet he fought through the show and gave another great performance of “Little Sparrow” and last but not least - his brother is battling cancer. These are indicators that he is not only under stress, but a good person, not arrogant. I think it is clear also from his demeanor after his performance that he knew he did not do well, and if he had the chance would have changed it up. He seemed disappointed even before the judges spoke. Everyone has their weak moments, and it seems to me that other “idols” have had comparatively far more weak performances than David Cook has. For every weak performance by David Cook every other idol has a single strong performance. I stand beside him. And I have to say I have watched 3-4 seasons of Idol, and he is the first singer that I can say I would actually buy his album, and the first that I have cared enough to post any comment about on the internet. Good job, David. Strength to you, and to your family, and especially your brother Adam. Have faith that your futures are blessed.
- Posted by JessicaI find him completely pompous. I was so glad he bombed.
- Posted by BKI completely agree, David is far from arrogant I really don’t understand how somebody could say he is. With all of the things that he is going through in his life and to be able to do what he does week in and week out to me is absolutely phenomenal. He has an amazing voice and gets people excited to watch Idol each week. Everyone else has had a bad week this is his first, although personally I rather enjoyed it. Archuleta had a terrible week (butchering a great Beatles song and forgetting the lyrics 3 TIMES!) and he was not even in the bottom three as will David this week. People are so quick to criticize don’t forget this is the same guy who did “Hello” “Eleanor Rigby” “Billy Jean” “Little Sparrow”. They guy is a star win or lose he will be great mark my words
- Posted by JimDavid Cook is the most talented performer that has been on Idol EVER! He is not arrogant - I don’t know how anyone could ever say that. Maybe because he is of few words people say that - but I don’t see that as arrogance I see that as being polite - he listens - he does not wait to talk. Since the beginning he has not had one bad performance. Maybe some were better than others but they have all been great! I look forward to his performances and he is the main reason I’m watching this year. I can’t wait for him to put out an album because I’ll be buying it!! My heart and prayers go out to him and his family. DAVID - YOU HAVE MY VOTES!
- Posted by JackieDavid Cook is the most talented performer on the stage. He is better than Archuleta and David Cook will be the only contestant to sell records and get radio play like Daughtrey. This show is turning into one big joke. This guy is the most humble guy and most giving person. This show is beginning to disgust me. Everyone has a bad night, all the contestants did, and they are still there and they have less talent than David. How quickley we all forget Billie Jean.
- Posted by MareI used to be a BIG FAN!! of David C but when all the “copies of copies” thing came out I got soooooo turned off by him, I know they all do it, but he did it WEEK AFTER WEEK and it was really disappointing cause I thought he was original, that’s what I loved about him. Now that he has to do his own arrangements he’s a complete mess.
- Posted by Mandy AllanDavid Cook is the first person I’ve seen on Idol who could make an album of his performances and it would be a best seller. He is great! And he seems like a sweetheart. Its obvious that his family is number one to him and they adore him too. But he doesn’t seem pompous. Confident yes, but that is a good thing! Keep on rockin’ David. You have many fans and we will but your albums when they are out there. We already buy your itunes!
- Posted by EvieWhat do you mean David Cook bombed? He was fantastic, as usual. He is the most talented contestant, and is defintely not pompous - he is kindhearted and humble. Where do you get this stuff from?
- Posted by Jane EyreDavid Cook is clearly balding; his ugly haircut isn’t fooling anyone. Embrace your baldness, David. Oh, sidebar, the hand stunt will go down as one of the LAMEST in Idol’s history, you loser.
- Posted by jillIt wasn’t his best, but I don’t see how it was arrogant. He’s still an amazing performer. He is easily the most talented this year. He has proven that he should be the one to beat. This was one ok week compared to the rest of his GREAT weeks. He hasn’t had a real bad week unlike the rest.
And tell me one thing…how is it an pompous performance when he had “give back” on his hand to honor what was going on this week with American Idol?
- Posted by DanielleDear Danielle,
- Posted by jillNo one can coach you on how to detect arrogance. Either you can, or you can’t. And as someone who can detect pompousness from a mile away, let me assure you, HE WAS ARROGANT…
prancing around the stage and scampering through the crowd, with smarmy looks on his face and cheesy crooked grins. Please. I didn’t know if he was performing or trying to sell me a used car. He needs to go home.
Thank you to all the people defending David Cook! I just have to laugh at all the people who get bent out of shape when a singer on this show (David Cook) comes off cocky, arrogant or as like to call it comfortable in his skin. Say it’s true for the sake of argument, that he acts cocky or arrogant. Name some front men who are not perceived this way. You can rule out Bono, Mick Jagger, Axel Rose, Sebastian Bach, Steven Tyler, Scott Wylan, Freddie Mercury…. on and on. It’s part of the show! No one want to see some plane dude on stage that could be the guy next door just singing the song note for note. They want a “Rock Star”. I know Cook personally and he anything but cocky and arrogant. He is just all about music. I think the mix last night did him in. When I played it back and listened more closely I thought he did an excellent job. True it wasn’t the best but not bad by any means. As far as the “give back” on his hand, that was sincere.
- Posted by Ben HostermanI really enjoy David Cook and would definitely buy his album. I don’t find him arrogant or pompous, just confident. Last night, you could tell he was unhappy with his performance. Perhaps he couldn’t even hear himself over the background singers and the band…I surely couldn’t! I don’t think any of the contestants had a good night last night with the exception of MAYBE Kristy Lee. She was good but she wasn’t great.
- Posted by LindaI don’t see why people found him arrogant. He looked really unconnected and stressed, like he was struggling with something. The difference of opinions is interesting.
- Posted by MaryThe only people I know who are incapable of seeing through his arrogance, and who actually like David Cook, are over 40. Maybe that’s the problem - you’re just old and out of touch. Perhaps.
If you think the “give back” was sincere, you need a reality check. It was a desperate attempt to win votes and be edgy. To the person who said “All front men are cocky” - yes, but they are cocky without being LAME about it.
David Cook REEKS of having no self confidence, and his FAUX ARROGANCE shines through. That’s the problem. There’s nothing genuine about him and many of us can see that.
- Posted by jillJill, I am NOT over 40 and I find YOU arrogant. If you don’t like David, stop trying to convince us that you are right. You know what opinions are like…everyone has one…but YOU ARE ONE!
You must be 12.
- Posted by LindaOk, I had to put in my two cents here. I knew David Cook peripherally back in highscool, and I promise you he IS NOT arrogant. Last night it looked to me like he was tired, stressed, and a tad depressed. To be honest I’m a little worried about him. True, it wasn’t his best performance by far, but as so many of you have said, everyone has bad nights.
It dissappoints me how quickly the media jumps to tear down someone for showing the littlest bit of human frailty, and how easily people are swayed to join in on the burn-fest. These people you’re bad mouthing are PEOPLE. How can you judge them so quickly when all you know of them is what you are fed by the media?
Anyway… David is a great musician, a wonderful performer, and an all around nice guy. He always has been, and I’ll be rooting for him. Go ahead and judge his performances however you like, but don’t talk about his personality, motivations, or character unless you actually know him.
- Posted by AmandaBravo Linda. Jill, what are you so angry about? Did you not make the cut on AI or something like that? He has no FAUX ARROGANCE. He’s just doing what he does best and that is singing the hell out of songs. If you don’t like him vote for someone else! I would ask any one of you David Cook haters to put yourself in the same spotlight and imagine how people would judge you. He is dealing with a lot more than just trying to win over the general public from week to week. He has real family troubles and I’m impressed that he has held up as well as he has. It’s real sad seeing how so many people make crude and completely of the mark judgments about people they don’t know anything about except what the editors of AI want you to see. Do some research. Dave Cook is a sincere guy. I can say that with personal experience. You rock Cookie!
- Posted by Ben HostermanI think Jill is transferring her feelings for a former cocky boyfriend (who probably dumped her because when she opens her mouth her brains fall out) when she speaks so ugly about David C. who is an amazing rock singer. I suppose she thinks that David should sing and lick his lips over and over again (david a) and bore us to tears with his sweetness. What’s the comment about being over 40?????
- Posted by Ann JonesWhat a “special” girl she seems to be.
I love his personality. He comes across as competitive and very cerebral—- a real thinker. As someone who has gone through grad school I find his mind and approach very attractive. That aside, I did not like his performance last night. That song did not suit his voice at all. I still voted for him feverishly because I want him to stay in as I still really believe in him. Hopefully he will learn from this experience and go back to what he was doing before and pick music that better suits his voice.
- Posted by SarahThis is the FIRST time that I have ever posted anything on the net. The main reason I am doing so now is to say to Jill, GET OVER YOURSELF!!!!!!!!! YOU are the one coming off like a pompous know-it-all. Whether Cook was cocky or not is simply a matter of opinion. And making snide comments about his lack of hair is just petty and rude.
- Posted by Rene macleodYou sound like a spoiled self-centered egotistical BRAT!! Do you have NO LIFE that you have to respond back to anyone & everyone who disagrees W/ you? Someone who has to ram their opinion down others throats and make statements that passive aggressively put others down REEKS OF NO SELF CONFIDENCE!!
I am not over 40( which has absolutely nothing to do W/ the matter by the way, except in showing us how immature YOU are).You are not the only person alive W/ a corner on determining whether or not someone is arrogant. Then again, you probably have quite a handle on it since you see it reflected so clearly within yourself.
It is people like you that ruin these sites.
While this performance was not my favorite for David Cook, I believe he is the most talented performer, with inspired and creative vocals and a unique, memorable style. I will listen to his music after Idol is over and will look for more.
- Posted by Carldavid did fantastic, and will continue to do so. arrogance wasnt apparent last night; adamacy was. the ONLY problem with his song choice is that it was unknown. fact of the matter is “our lady peace” is an awesome, understated band and “innocent” is one of their very best songs. david, dont worry big man, whether you win or lose this competition, you’ll still have a tremendous future in music. why your better than the rest? definitive ability. and your own tste in music, where as everyone lse are somewhat minionish.
- Posted by bobbyDavid Cook is an amazing talent. I find him to be humble, gracious with the judges and sexy as heck. I don’t think he will win, but he will still be a star. I don’t think he will win because all the little girls will vote for David A. But, it is still early in the season. I have faith that David Cook will come back strong next week after this week’s less that great (but good) performance. He has set his own bar so high.
- Posted by Brett GodwinLast night’s performance was not my favorite for David C., but, as has already been said, every other night has been stellar. He is a rock star. He is talented and confident and definitely NOT arrogant. Holy cow! What a load of garbage. If anything, David looked tired and stressed and a little frustrated (maybe from trying to sing over the obnoxious back-up singers?). I applaud him for continuing on, week after week, with everything that is going on his life. It is pretty obvious to me that he is sincere, mature and very grounded. And, never once did he claim the versions of the songs he was singing as his own. The judges are guilty of crediting him with that. He just happened to do a MUCH better job of covering the remakes!
- Posted by JulieJill, your comments are rude and, frankly, quite arrogant. I think you need a hobby, or an anger management class!
All these opinions of David Cook are what they are - Opinions! No one should really listen to the judges. It is what “we” think and if we choose to vote for the one we like the best, we will. David is an amazing singer and he will be getting a record deal whether he is the American Idol or not. He has an amazing voice and does not show himself as arrogant. He shows himself as serious and creative. Also, like others said, he has personal things in his life that are on his mind, like anyone else. I personally think that this has been the best season so far and David Cook brings his own to a song and that is what makes him the great singer that he is. American Idol is not only about winning a competition, it is about these young singers being shown to the public eye and someone somewhere will approach them and offer them their dream. On that note, enjoy the rest of Idol!
- Posted by DonnaJill,
Believe it or not, not all the people that like David are over 40, as has been stated several times since you made that post. I’m actually younger than David, so I’m not over 40 by any means. But what does age matter? Not a whole heck of a lot.
And if he was so arrogant, then why did he actually look defeated after the performance before the judges even gave him comments?
And a little cockyness and arrogance honestly helps performances. It shows you at least think you know the song. It makes it a little more convincing to the audience.
- Posted by DanielleBoy, you guys sure did put me in my place. I have seen the light. I’m David Cook’s biggest fan!
Sidebar, I was seemingly only half right about your ages; you’re clearly all over FIFTY. If not in age, in mentality and senility. Happy Idol-ing!
- Posted by jillI love David Cook- he is so talented and truly “star quality”!!
Everyone has a moment where they stumble and I am eagerly waiting to see what he brings to the party next week!
Good Luck, David and our prayers are with your brother!
- Posted by ChristineKeep on Rockin’!
And Jill, you’re still 12.
- Posted by LindaJill,
I’d rather be over fifty in mentality then under twelve as you seem to be. =)
- Posted by Amandaharsh. I liked it…maybe it wasn’t HIS best but it was still pretty good compared to the crock some other contestants have been putting out there. and you don’t see them getting ripped apart like this, do you? don’t hold him to a higher standard, it’s not fair.
- Posted by LisaYou have to be confident to sing on stage. Definitely agree that it wasn’t his best performance because the choir did drown him out as he sang low. However, my 8 year old was inspired by the words of the song and hasn’t stopped singing it all day.
- Posted by hjoyalWhen was the last time that your absolutely favorite band or singer hit it out of the park on every album and every song. Plus I believe he chose that song, which had a lyric about cancer in it, as a tribute to his brother who is struggling with cancer.
Jill, we’re not telling you to change your opinion, we’re just trying to tell you that you are being immature with the way are trying to change ours.
You need to get used to the idea that not everyone will share your opinion because you seem to not get that.
- Posted by DanielleI just want to add that first the judges run them down because they don’t appear confident enough. And now the ones who have become confident (David Cook) get told they appeared “pompous”. For crying out loud make up your freakin mind. David Cook has sung on stage before, and a lot of the other haven’t. He’s going to put on a show because he knows what the audience wants! He is still a VERY good performer and I don’t think he should go home because an “off” night. There are a few others who deserve to go home before he does.
- Posted by CrystalI have never, ever, ever been so crazy about an American Idol contestant, as I am about David Cook. He is, as Paula said, the TOTAL package!!! He has got me completely hooked, and I will do all I can to help him remain in the competition. Like many have said before me, he seems to be a real thinker, very creative, and when it comes down to it, all about the music and the performance. I think being called names is really out of line and uncalled for and mean spirited. I for one do not agree with any of it.
I am listening to his music right now, a great song from his Axium Album “The Story Thus Far” (bought both Axium albums on Walmart.com mp3 downloads) called “On The Floor” — ooohhh it is sooooooooooo good. So is Pecking Order, and Holding Court, and so many more.
I love, love, love this guy (my husband is a little jealous).
- Posted by MichelleThere is a difference between arrogance and confidence! Our friend David is very confident! We love you David! The Hostermans
- Posted by DawnI am a HUGE David Cook fan… and although last nights song was not my favorite, he is still an AWESOME singer. Everyone is going to have an “off” night and I just hope all the Cook fans out there voted… The show just wouldn’t be the same without him!!!
GO DAVID COOK!!!!
- Posted by MindyBecause of David Cook’s “give back” last night, I am committed to give $5000 and I don’t typically call in to shows to give. He is heartfelt. He sang from his heart as he always does. Regardless if he chose a song many didn’t like, there are many of us who did like that song, and the way it was arranged. I enjoyed it thoroughly, even when I played it back. You go David. I will buy your album. I will buy tickets to your concerts. You are the real thing and don’t let anyone tell you otherwise. When it comes to people writing hurtful things, just remember “chew the straw and spit out the sticks”. Those with negative comments haven’t a clue. You are da bomb diggity.
- Posted by IdolI think \”arrogant\” is a poor adjective to use for David. He has been suffering from panic issues related to the poor diagnosis for his brother, who has cancer. I think, if anything, he is suffering from depression and fear. But arrogant? Not at all. I still love him.
- Posted by ReneDavid Cook is not only an inspiration to many dreamers out there, but he is a true artist. By artist, I dont mean he writes his own songs, I mean the man can sing and can PERFORM his heart out. We know he has a big heart (just by his mannerisms and him actually crying last week after the “Idol Gives Back” video aired).
David Cook, BOTTOM LINE, is the only contestant that will SELL RECORDS!
David Archuleta is ok, but he’s no David Cook. David Archuleta is popular was teenage girls, that’s about it. I know a few adults that like him, but not near as many as the people that are David Cook fans. He has heart, he’s an excellent singer, and he deserves to win this competition.
He’s also replaced Justin Timberlake as my “baby daddy”.
Yowza!
- Posted by RachelI realy think David Cook was trying to make a point, he cares, he care for all, there isn’t much els to say. I feel he would like to help make this world bertter..
- Posted by Teresa S.S.Everyone entitled to a mistake, last night was not his best night for sure…..but come on, he is awesome
- Posted by Richard SaraivaI am a Canadian fan who, unfortunately, does not have the privelege of voting every week. I can’t tell you what a thrill it was to hear David cover an Our Lady Peace song. The song couldn’t have been more appropriate or sincere. Every week David brings it and last night was no exception. He’s not only the most talented contestant on AI EVER, but he seems to have a lot of integrity. I will support his career in music whether he wins or not.
- Posted by AdrienneFor those of you who are dumb enough not to understand why he picked this song: The lyrics in the song go something like this,”He wished he’d never heard of cancer, and that god would give him some answers,… Anyone not know this song was for his brother who has cancer. Listen some Canadian bands like Our Lady Peace, Big Wreck, Nickelback, … these bands inspire this lad.
- Posted by chadCanada Loves David Cook
David Cook did not come off as cocky, and whether or not the song was un-recongnized, he still did a fabulous job. The “Give back” on his hand was NOT cringe worthy, and his jacket looked very nice on him. Do any of you people know about music and talent, or are you all just battling the popularity contest, really?
- Posted by Brittani RobbinsThis absolutely was not his best performance, but all great artists take a small step back and then move right back in to forward motion.
As for David’s “signature guitar” - what the hell are you talking about… he’s used it…. hm, maybe twice.. If anyone can’t get their stupid guitar off stage it’s Jason Castro, who has little talent, a pretty voice and is only still on the show because a bunch of teeny boppers want in his pants. As for Kristy Lee Cook, she should’ve been gone long ago too, little talent, very attractive. REDICULOUS!!
Even if David were cocky, he’s got a reason to be, he’s amazing. He’s a fully rounded musician, amazing vocals, great style, he plays an instrument which only few on this season can do, and he knows his stuff. David Cook is the real deal.
I have been a fan of David Cook since the very beginning. He is an amazing singer and musician!! I believe he is the whole package for American Idol. His family should be extremely PROUD of him. What an OUTSTANDING individual!!! I look forward to following him in his career, listening to his music and hopefully meeting him one day.
- Posted by Janie StashI thought David did a good job of the song “innocent”. Also, by performing a song from a Canadian band, he gained more fans in Canada. Many Americans fail to see that there are many great Canadian artists. Thank-you David for acknowledging our Canadian talent!!
- Posted by jennHe is not arrogant and he wasn’t playing his guitar
- Posted by VkDavid Cook has incredible talent and I agree with many comments posted here (all the positive ones)!! Last night was not his best but I’m sure he’ll be around for many weeks to come.
I predict Archuleta vs. David Cook in the final 2.
- Posted by SandraI think that people really need to just keep some comments to themselves. They need to just like shut their mouths and quit bad talking other people.
- Posted by SamanthaUnsurprisingly, the critics of David Cook on this thread actually sound educated and intelligent; the David Cook fans have literally to offer but internet lingo (”OMG I LUV HIM) and childish insults.
If you’re a perceptive person, it’s obvious that David Cook is a pompous douchebag. He’s utterly transparent. Fortunately for him, the majority of Americans are dense and easy to manipulate.
- Posted by MegI definitely think that David C. is the best singer on Idol this season. As far as him being pompous, I’ve never noticed him being anything but gracious. As said before, at least he doesn’t argue with the judges. And let’s face it, there have been people in the past who have sucked and stayed on the show until near the end. Also, I have no interest in David A., and will be sorely disappointed if he wins.
- Posted by Laurencalling this song unfamiliar is just rediculous…it’s always been one of my favorite songs and it has a great message, which is why he didn’t. i think he is the least arrogant of them all.
- Posted by saraDavid Cook has been amazing from the very start. He’s not cocky and arrogant as Simon says… its called confidence folks! He’s the WHOLE package, his jacket looked awesome, maybe not his best performance but certainly good. Idol is starting to sound rigged! And who has not heard of that song he sung?? Are you kidding me? What, do you Americans only listen to American artists on the radio?? Gimme a break, its a popular song. David Cook has had my vote since the very beginning. Archuletta can ONLY sing a certain way and style and has no charisma and uniqueness at all. And he forgot his words. If he wins because of a popularity vote instead of unique talent I’m off Idol for sure! Either way David Cook will be another Daughtry!
GO DAVID GO!! You sexy thang!!
- Posted by Kathy MacIntoshI was so impressed to hear David Cook sing a great song from a great Canadian band (being that I am a proud Canadian myself). Liked Cook before, like him more now. Thanks David from your fans to the north. Rock on!
- Posted by AnnetteWow MEG, if you hadn’t noticed, 90% of the people backing david didn’t use internet lingo and “OMG I LUV HIM” was not something at all that I read. He’s not arrogant, but you certainly are… You must be used to rejection.
- Posted by Brittani RobbinsI never watched Idol until I accidentally caught David Cook’s performance of Billy Jean while channel surfing. I was blown away by his voice. I went to youtube and watched his past performances and then went to iTunes and purchased a few of his recordings. I’ve now been following Idol and I sincerely hope David Cook wins just so I don’t have to wait 2 years to buy his records. I donated to Idol Gives Back and that would never have happened if not for my being reeled in by David’s talent. I’ve never been motivated to post comments online but I just can’t get over the nasty things being said about him as a person. You don’t have to like his music style or his voice or his song choice - make fun of those all you want - that’s within the limits. But what’s beyond the limits is publicly posting nasty comments about him as a person - especially when you’ve never met the man. Do you ever stop to think that David himself would read your comments? And be hurt by them? Would you say these things to his face if he were standing in front of you? I truly doubt it as I’ve yet to meet anyone who is that mean-spirited. I don’t know David Cook but I do know he has one of the most amazing voices I’ve heard in a long time. All the contestants are good but, in my opinion, David Cook is better and I can’t wait for him to hit the charts. Stick by him Ben - you’re a good friend.
- Posted by RD in ChicagoUm, Meg, I think what you meant to say was “little to offer”. And, in my humble opinion, I believe the use of the word douchebag is reserved for the “dense and easy to manipulate of the world”. Where does that leave you?
Maybe a little fiber would help…
- Posted by JulieModerator, I apologize. I am all about David Cook. If anyone needs to ask why..I am glad they don’t know. A filter. For fools.
- Posted by AlysabethAnyone who describes David Cook as ‘pompous, arrogant and manipulative’ needs to Windex their television screen. Can you not see that David Cook is an intelligent guy - a self-described ‘word-nerd’ - and an amazingly talented musician?
I actually liked his performance the other night. If nay-sayers look past the white blazer (most likely recommended by the show’s stylist) and the lack of guitar, they’ll see a sincere guy who walked into the audience for no other reason that to connect.
I felt bad for him when he was shot down by Simon and Randy. They are so unpredictable that it makes one wonder about the integrity of the show and the voting tabulations.
Was I the only one who felt that David was channeling Bono when he opened the palm of his hand to reveal the ‘give back’ message? I thought it was wonderful. Afterall, the theme of the show was ‘inspiration’ in order to motivate the public to donate for the charity show.
David Cook will be a huge star (like Daughtry) whether or not he wins American Idol.
- Posted by LauraPompous, arrogant = David Cook? I think not. I have been a fan of his since day one, and I pride myself on seeing his potential and demeanor since then (I even predicted that he would sing a Michael Jackson song, and lo! he did). Thank you to the people who know David personally and came to his defense as you are the best to give an opinion. Perhaps viewers should really observe a little more closely that he has never spoken about his family problems, he wore his orange band silently, he held back his tears at the end of his performance of Eleanor Rigby, he downplayed his hospital visit, the song “Innocent” spoke of cancer, he was crying during the clip about the orphaned African sisters last week, he came through the crowd so that he could be close to the camera to show his hand, he made fans take his brother’s autograph along with his in tribute to him, he is always so serious on elimination nights, but claps with his hands raised high in salute to every other performer. Tell us Jill, who do you like? And what have you cried for other than the series end of the Simple Plan with Paris Hilton? When I look at David I see someone who is soo passionate about music, he looks like he wants to cry when he does not get a good review. On the other hand when he does well and looks happy, confident and relaxed, he is somehow smug? I don’t get it. I would be too if I gave up my college career to be a bartender to follow my dream. His family backing alone speaks for itself what a nice guy he is. Simon is such a hypocrite; he tells Carly she needs to start dressing like a star and when David does it, its blasphemy? Much love to you David from Canada. I feel your passion every time you sing. Hollywood can get to people’s head, but I don’t see that with you, and hopefully it will not happen.
- Posted by NazmaI personally think David Cook Rocks. I just told my daughter he is the only idol member I would actually pay to see in concert. I do not think there is anything arrogant about him. We try to teach our youth to be confident to like yourself and when someone does we call them arrogant or egotistical. No wonder the youth of today are so confused. We tell them one thing and then condemn them for it. Be Proud David Cook!!
- Posted by RondaSome might have found David C’s choice of song obscure…those of us who know of OLP know that he did a TERRIFIC job with the song (the 20-somethings in the crowd!). Simon definitely chose the wrong word when he described his performance as “pompous” and sure ate his words after he found out that David had the words “give back.” written on his LEFT hand (whose handwritting was that? we know you’re a lefty!).
Simon, after going on Larry King Live and admitting that David is his favorite to win the competition probably felt that being “impartial” meant tearing him down this week. Then there’s Randy, who has to prove himself as intelligent this year by giving negative reviews (I have read the study where people giving negative reviews, regardless of how wrong, were perceived as smarter than those giving dead-on positive reviews).
David C. is the most talented Idol contestant EVER! He is so genuine and intense.
Thank you, David, for brining music back into my life. I have bought every single one of your Idol singles as well as Analog Heart and will buy anything you release, Idol or not! However, I see how much you want to win by how you approach each of your performances and will continue to vote for you like crazy!
- Posted by AnaOk having read all the comments…I have to agree with most of them. I’m from Sri Lanka and David Cook has a lot of fans there…he’s very talented and yes everyone has their bad nights but that certainly doesn’t make them ‘pompous’ and I think Simon Cowell using the word ‘pompous’ on someone else is a bit rich! David Cook has the best stage presence and talent from any talent contest I have seen so far…his performances are as great as Leona Lewis was on X-Factor in the UK (and see how far she’s come). David Cook can go on to be a huge success and I sincerely hope he wins because I’m tired of people like David Archuleta (who have great voices but no ‘presence’) win. I hope people will remember how consistent David Cook has been before they vote. Someone who should go home should be Kirsty Lee Cooke..now that is someone who is pompous and who has no talent but is obviously kept on because of her looks.
American Idol is a sort of joke anyway…and we shouldn’t forget the greatest singers/bands of all time never got famous through talent contests…it was just hard work and publicity. David Cook is experiencing both the publicity and the hard work right now and I’m pretty sure that even if he doesn’t win he’ll go on to be a huge success like Daughtry. I, for one, would definitely buy his CD. Rock on David Cook and keep doing what you do!!
- Posted by LalinkaI am ready to buy David’s CD now. His voice stands out compared to the rest. He is gonna be a star whether he wins Idol or not. He is the main reason I even watch the show. I look forward to hearing him more than anyone else. True, his last performance wasn’t his best, but I think he was trying to do something different from everyone else. You are awesome David - looking forward to seeing what you come up with next week!
- Posted by Tara DuncanWow… this article is a great big pile of BS!
The only one coming across as arrogant (and perhaps a bit jealous) is the author of this crap!
David Cook is the only contestant who shows true talent, over and over again. He’s the only one who really gets the audience involved, the way he will when he starts to tour.
He has a slightly less-than-perfect performance and people are all over his case. How absurd!
Unfamiliar song?? That was a huge hit for Our Lady Peace… and was #1 for weeks… you need to expand your music tastes a bit.
And to insult his way of showing how much he cares about Idol Gives Back and what it means, shows that YOU have no idea about the act of ‘giving’.
Next time you decide to write an article…….. Don’t.
- Posted by EchoedMemoryI’ve seen comments on David Cook ranging from “he’s got a belly” to “he’s losing his hair”…and let’s not forget “he’s stuck on himself”. I just know that all of the people who have issued these criticisms would be just fine hearing the same thing about themselves, right? How a person who has only seen the guy on TV can assault his personality that way just amazes me…
- Posted by CarrieMaybe he is arrogant….maybe not. Point is, I can’t tell that from seeing him for 10 minutes a week on TV and neither can anyone else. He sings well, and he’s a good performer…better than most on there. I don’t invest myself so much in AI that I feel the need to pick just one person to support and then commence bashing all the rest. It’s a show, entertainment. By the time June rolls around, it’ll be over and the poor guy (who has put himself out there in a way that most people cannot) will still have thinning hair and a little thickness around the middle…but he’ll have more accomplishment than most people will ever know.
David Cook is not arrogant — how can you be arrogant or pompous singing a song! I can understand “afterwards” but “during” — all he’s doing is SINGING! yeesh. this is getting stupid.
- Posted by lisaWell, this is the FIRST time I have ever posted on the AI message boards. I actually can’t believe that so many people take the time to write such horrible things about another human being. Did you watch last night’s Idol Gives Back show? Do you realize how lucky we are to be living in a place where we can actually drink fresh water, go to bed every night without worrying about where our next meal will come from, or whether or not our parents or loved ones will die from AIDS? There are also people right here in this country homeless and struggling due to our current “recession” and you are trashing a talented person who had the guts to go for his dream? I think David Cook is a talented person, as are all of the other contestants this season. These people put it on the line every week after sometimes learning songs they don’t even know, while trying to “be original” and performing in front of millions of people watching. Talk about bravado, class, heart and talent! These individuals should be saluted for what each one of them brings to the competition. Don’t tear someone down for chasing their dream - we should all be so lucky……
- Posted by JodyFor everyone who has taken the time to post on this blog…have you taken the time to donate to “Idol Gives Back”? Even one dollar makes a difference…
- Posted by RD in ChicagoI donated to it.
- Posted by DanielleThe problem with David Cook is that he is a phony. Yes, he has talent and can deliver a good performance. His problem this week was a lousy song choice. What I don’t like about him him is that he stands there and let’s the judges shower him with compliments about his “original” versions of songs just to find out that he’s copying some one else. I think I would be compelled to admit that it wasn’t my arrangement but Cook just happily takes credit for it. He also acts like he has this competition sewn up.
- Posted by Rob S.I love reading all of your comments ( most of them ). It feels good to see all of the support that David is getting. Again,( being Canadian ) I can’t vote, so please all you posting here, vote doubly hard on our behalf. I have downloaded everything I could find by him onto my IPOD and it’s all I’m listening to. I’m obssessed!!!!!
- Posted by AdrienneI am very impressed at the way people on here have jumped to the defense of David Cook. It may not have been his best performance but the studio version has got to be his best studio from American Idol. Absolutely incredible. I am 100% positive that is how he ment the song to sound. It is not his fault that the sound crew messed up royally by having the miks of the backup singers on so loud as to drown out the singer. It happened to a few other contestants as well.
As to those of you who feel it necessary to bash his performance, I pity you. It is disgusting the way the author of this piece of garbage hung on every negative comment the judges made regarding David Cook AND Carly Smithson. Neither did a bad job performing their songs. The only crime is that they didn’t out perform themselves from past weeks. How can we expect every song to be performed perfectly?
And the worst part is that you are bashing people who are trying to do their best this week to inspire people to donate to a worthy cause. On a different forum I saw someone post that they wouldn’t donate because the performances sucked. Grow Up! What is America coming to when our acts of kindness are determined on whether we are impressed by the performances of those looking for our donations. Pitiful and disgusting.
- Posted by MountainpearlMountainpearl and Jody; Bravo! Well said!
- Posted by JulieDavid Cook did’nt give his best performance to date, but it wasn’t so bad as to deserve as all the criticism he’s been getting for it. If you listen to the words it’s clear why he chose the song and why he finds it insirational on a personal level. They were to chose songs that inspire them…what David Cook finds inspiration in is cleary different than what the Idol darling David A does…Two different styles and I’de personaly rather rock out to Mr. Cook than listen to any more david A fluff!
Rock on david…your fans got your back
- Posted by ShawnaOkay. Here I go. Batter up! I have posted this elsewhere, but I am saying it here too. There are many reasons I love David Cook. I think he is a terrific performer with an incredible voice! I have the Axium album, The Story Thus Far, and David solo project, Analog Heart. Amazing. The man has a true God-given gift. I have never been so touched by a musician. I connect with his voice, and with the heart I feel is behind it. If you doubt HIS sincerity, then you might as well doubt every one’s. It’s okay to show how much you care about a cause on the Idol gives back show, but not the night before? And on the Gives Back show, everyone there was there to boost their popularity, and advance their career? No. Of course not. But if David Cook does something, or makes a gesture of care it is not genuine? His “Give Back” on his hand, and his wearing of the orange bracelet is just a tactic to win votes? INSANITY! The man is living his dreams right now. He himself said, that he wants to enjoy the experience, not just experience it. And lately, he has been very sad and broken, but that is because of what is going on in his personal life! And the man STILL goes up on that stage, and stands up to the criticism, and possible ridicule. Simon said it right on Larry King. David Cook is fearless. I love him for many reasons, but the main reason I love him is that he is an inspiration. When my Mother was diagnosed with Breast Cancer, I put all of my dreams of being an actress on hold. I really wanted to make it happen, but the fear and the uncertainty of losing the most important person in my life just made me lose the strength and the will to try. When my Mother died, I let the will to fight for my dreams slip away. I will admit that I was a coward, and couldn’t find the strength to see my own passions realized. David Cook is living with that uncertainty and fear right now. But instead of being a coward, LIKE I WAS, and close himself off, and turn his back on the inner voice that tells you to go after your dreams, he surrenders to all the emotions that he is feeling, and he uses them! He is having a hard time of it, but he still refuses to give up. He’s fearless, and I would like to endeavor to be that strong. I will support David Cook is ALL of his creative endeavors. I think the bubble gum, pop prince and princess kids will end of winning in the end, and David Archuleta will be the American Idol. A shame, really. Don’t get me wrong, Archuleta has a beautiful voice, but I don’t “feel him” when he sings. I do feel David Cook when he sings. He said himself, he’s an open book. He wears his heart on his sleeve. He puts all of himself into every song, stands on the edge, and waits for the storm. I have much love and respect for David Cook. He’s a symbol of great talent and incredible strength. I must admit that when I first saw him, I thought he was so gorgeous that he made me forget my own name. But after listening to his amazing voice, and watching his character shine through under the pressures of the public attention, I see him as much more than a sexy man. His performances have shown that he has the talent and range to take on any song, and his actions and character have shown that he can take on the criticism as well. To you, David, you are not alone. Your family and friends will stand by your side. And as your fans, we will as well. Best of luck to you, Cookie Monster. You’re my Rockin’ Romeo!
- Posted by BethI love David Cook, he has an enormous talent! He is the one that inspired me to donate last night.
- Posted by RachelI DO NOT think he is phony or pompous, he comes across as an intelligent guy and and a deep thinker.
He puts a lot of thought and work into his song choices, the song was very inspiring. He is my favorite
to win and has my vote.
I have watched since day 1 and I totally do not understand why anyone would call DC phoney, arrogant, or pompous. He seems like a very true, real person with a heart of gold and I have never gotten any other impression other than that he is honored to be there and humbled at how much people love him. He never, ever has a pompous look about him in anyway, he looks genuine, sincere…. He has an incredible voice and stage presence. Honestly, I think some people just got it wrong and when Simon said the word pompous he was VERY WRONG. It’s one of those cases where I think Simon really stuck his foot in his mouth. GO DAVID COOK!! YOU ARE AMAZING!!
- Posted by TarraWhat are you talking about? David is the best of any season of Idol. I actually liked his performance, but he has set the bar so high that, when he’s not terrific, everyone is ready to shoot him down. The man is a great talent and I hope he wins it all.
- Posted by LaraWhat are you talking about? David is the best of any season of Idol. I actually liked his performance, but he has set the bar so high that, when he’s not terrific, everyone is ready to shoot him down. The man is a great talent and I hope he wins it all.
- Posted by Lara
- Posted by LaraWhy would someone write an article like this, except simply to be sensational (and wretched, in my opinion). I’ll gladly listen to 100 minutes of David Cook’s worst performances rather than 2 minutes of the BEST of any of the rest of them (David A. included). Pompous? Simon dares to call someone pompous? That’s just funny. “Hello, kettle, this is the pot–you’re black!” Yikes. Go, David–sing your heart out. I’ll be in line to buy whatever you put out when your AI journey is over. Oh, and I may, for the first time ever, actually go to the Idols tour–just because of you.
- Posted by JenI have been watching American Idol since the season started. David Cook is the best and he deserves to win. Everyone has a bad day or two seriously don’t talk about him I would like you to go out there and try to sing like him. Well I know nobody can sing like him so yea. I think he is AWESOME not phoney, pompous or arrogant. I totally agree with Tarra. He does have a good heart you can tell. His personality shows through his performances and he is dealing with his brother with cancer to. So give the guy a break. I love him! I think he should win!! If he doesnt I’m not sure who is good enough to beat him fairly. DAVID COOK IS THE BEST!!!!!!!
- Posted by KarleeDavid Cook was not my favorite at the beginning. Yes, I liked him, but he was not my favorite. The week he sang “Hello” was the week I absolutely fell in love with him. Week after week, he continued to be amazing. I know that some of the arrangements were not his own, but he still sang beautifully. I did not know “Innocent” very well, so I listened to Our Lady Peace’s version. When I watched David’s performance again, it sounded just as good as OLP’s. I have watched his performance about 5 times now and each time I like it more and more. I do not see how he was pompous, and I thought that David looked hot in the white jacket. The “Give Back” written on his hand was a nice gesture that, I know, inspired many people to donate. But finally, and most importantly, American Idol is a competition about SINGING. I am not naive, I know that popularity has something to do with it, but in the end, the winner has to be an amazing singer. To put it simply, David Cook can sing. He is the most talented singer there, based off of just the American Idol performances. I have also listened to his entire solo album and I have heard some songs by other bands he was in. From this I have concluded that he will get a record contract and be successful in the music industry no matter what happens on Idol. This does not mean that his fans can just sit back and relax. If you are a David Cook fan (like me), please vote. Together we can, hopefully, make him the next American Idol.
- Posted by JJDavid cook is THE best on the show, but…the rest are very talented also and he has to keep his game up. I didn’t think the problem was song choice or pompous attitude, rather the back up singers were carried away and drowned out David. thei flat sounds drowned out his beautiful full tones and ruined the song…so the problem in my opinion was “arrangement”. So not fair to David.
- Posted by JUDYTo Mandy Allen - At least David gave credit where credit was due. Chris Daughtry copied a copy with “Walk the Line” and I remember being blown away by his creativity until I learned that it was a cover of someone else’s version. Katherine McPhee knocked everyone’s socks off with her version of “Somewhere Over the Rainbow” and NEVER to the best of my knowledge acknowledged that it was a cover of Eva Cassidy’s awesome rendition. Yes, they all do it. Jason Castro did it this week too. I’d rather hear them sing a copy of a copy and do it creatively & well than have them sound like an exact copy (like Michael Johns with Bohemian Rhapsody) or do a so-so version of a Whitney Houston or Fantasia song. David can keep up the “copying of copies” as far as I’m concerned. He does it well!!
- Posted by tvnAlright - if you haven’t heard the song “Innocent” then you can’t be much of a music critic - seriously - an unfamiliar song? So unbelievably ignorant. How can you deny his talent? Before you go shooting your face off next time, you should learn a little bit about David and the heartfelt things he does - the orange bracelet that he wears for example!
- Posted by RoseThough I was pretty unimpressed with David Cooks most recent performance, I think his his history of stellar performances is so much more important than one bad week. He should absolutely make it to the top three, and in my opinion, win the whole thing. Im a huge fan of his, and I cant wait to see what he has for us next week.
- Posted by GraceI’m from India and it’s a pity that we can’t vote because pretty much everyone I know would vote for David Cook. What I find incredible is that he appeals to a completely diverse strata - both age-wise and musically. I’m a huge fan of his, as is my Mum, and my Grandma as well! In terms of my age-group (mid-twenties)… my friends and colleagues normally listen to electronica … and we love him. Proof enough that this guy could appeal to just about anyone.
- Posted by MayaMy prayers are with him and his family. My grandfather has been diagnosed with Stage 4 cancer; I understand how rough this is for him…
I enjoy David Cook’s performances. I do not want to watch on stage someone who’s not confident enough to be up there. Someone who thinks he or she owns me to be up there and who’s relying on “humbleness” to get votes. I do not watch the show to “see humble people” I watch the show because I want to see talent, and he’s got plenty of it. He’s prepared himself and knows what he’s doing and I admire that.
- Posted by LauraIs this Slam DC week? David Cook had one bad week. His voice usually cuts right through you, but was overpowered by the backup singers. If he was all that pompous he would have demanded a different mix. Jason was great last night, but like Brooke and Michael, he was born 30 years too late for his music style. Carly looked angry, as usual, although she has an incredible radio voice. Two weeks ago everyone was slamming DC for plagiarism. These people have 48 hours to select a song & arrangement, before rehearsals begin. DC is by far the best at understanding who he is and what works for him - that makes him unique and original compared to others. Yeah Jill, I’m over 12 (+50), but I know real talent when I hear it. Fergie seems arrogant but is one of the most talented performers out there today, so give DC a break. I bet you were a Sanjaya fan.
- Posted by DougI am not understanding why Simon has labeled David Cook as arrogant an pompous. He has been saying that quite often about him. As I see it David is just trying to give a good performance. Every time David has come out during vote off he has never acted like he was safe, but seems to be very nervous and relieved when he is safe. I I think Simon’s opinion of him is totally wrong. If the viewers think that I think Simon has influenced the public. Well, I like him and hope he takes it. I would like to see someone who can actually make it big from the winner of American Idol like Carrie Underwood and Kelly Clarkson. I think he could do it.
- Posted by vickiIt is utterly unbelievable to say that David Cook is arrogant. How does one measure arrogance anyway? By observing? And who has the universal set of standards to determine the levels of arrogance? The article totally sucks. David Cook is a talented singer, humble, SMART, compassionate, is a human being like all of us. The fact that he choses a song which is inspiring to him (it has deep meaning for him and it catapulted the Canadian group’s exposure). David Cook is the man to look for and to vote for. His talent is undeniable. I cannot wait to buy his CD.
- Posted by ArnitaBefore anyone calls David Cook arrogant after that song look at the background and listen to the original version of the song. If no one noticed that he screamed out the part that goes ‘and wished she never heard of cancer’ the fact that the song means a lot to him, then thats just sad. He has a lot going on in his life right now and I bet that he is really having a tough time being so far away from his brother right now. So please before you call such a talented person arrogant, think about where they are coming from and the point that they are trying to make. David Cook really is a great guy.
- Posted by SamI don’t get it… “”Give Back” those two minutes of our lives”… seriously? Have we really gotten to the point where we would use the title of a show that’s goal is to raise money for charities as a way to bash one of the contestants? That’s pretty low. And God forbid that someone show confidence when they perform. David is clearly comfortable on stage and confident in himself, he loves to perform… isn’t that part of what we would want and look for in an American Idol?! And he has an amazing voice. Then people are calling him out for balding… this is ridiculous. We see such a limited part of each contestant’s life and seeing them on stage a few minutes a week and reading tabloids does not mean we know the person. I honestly think that David appears to be a good guy who cares a lot about his family and seems to really care about his fans. I love him and am rooting for him.
- Posted by Erin TarpeyJody: Well said. Why the cruel attacks behind the anonymity of the computer? Do you feel so bad about yourselves you need to unfairly attack others?
I am and have been a David Archuleta fan and my heart was breaking for him as he and his family faced the hateful and inaccurate attacks week after week. Then David Cook came on strong and he faced the same ridiculous attacks.
Lets face it. They are the TWO MOST GIFTED in the competition, so they will receive the majority of the PASSION AND HATE. Unfortunely, it was obvious to me from the inspirational week that both of them are taking it to heart. They seemed exhausted. I would like to tell them to stay strong, they will both be there in the end. And I believe it will be a great finale.
- Posted by JanieI just don’t get why people say he is arrogant. I don’t see it. I have never seen it in him. I think he is very appreciative after every performance and every time he is found safe. I have loved every performance of his.
- Posted by AmyDavid Cook’s performance did NOT come across as pompous or insincere. But he did seem to be struggling. Oftentimes when people are struggling, they put up a facade of some sort in the hopes of covering their vulnerability. To me, that’s what seemed to be happening. Give the guy a break–he’s a human being.
The disappointing thing with his performance of “Innocent” was that he made a rookie mistake: he chose a song he loves INSTEAD of one he could sing well. The opening part was too low–yes, he can hit the notes, but he can’t put the appropriate emotion behind his low register because all the effort goes to hitting the notes. Many of the other contestants have made similar errors in judgment. So, again, give the guy a break.
You don’t have to like his voice–even though I personally find his voice amazing. That’s simply a matter of taste. But when you attack the man himself, you just make yourself look mean-spirited. And no one wants to listen to a mean-spirited person.
- Posted by mkDavid Cook is the best this season has to offer. I liked Michael Johns too, but he’s gone now. I think David Cook is very gracious and he doesn’t back-talk the judges like some other contestants do. I wasn’t crazy about the “Innocent” song, but he delivered it very well as always. He never has a pitch problem and he knows how to arrange a song. Simon calling him pompous is like the pot calling the kettle black. God bless David and I hope he wins.
- Posted by NanJill, that is called stage presence. David Cook has it and some other contestants should learn it. They look like gaulky ducks on stage. David is in it to win and good for him. I never fault a person for putting their best foot forward at all times. That’s the only way a person can get ahead in life. Good luck to David. You go dude!!!
- Posted by NanI’m thinking David Cook might actually have set the bar too high for himself, after a long string of terrific rush-right-out-to-itunes-to-buy-it-the-n ext-day performances. Really, he turned in a good performance of a poor song choice (one that was chosen from his heart without regard to how it would further him in the competition). Would anyone have even noticed if, say, Michael Johns had picked the wrong song and gave a not-quite-fantastic rendition of it? Michael after all has been doing so poorly for weeks that we only take notice when he finally turns in one good performance (the blues number he did on country night). Even the fan favorite David A has set the bar fairly low for himself, continually only doing the same kind of song well and having some major stumbles along the way. Yet David C. has one performance that isn’t up to his usual sky-high-makes-headlines-the-next-day in his whole run and guess what? It makes headlines the next day. Why? Because it’s a shock. And I actually really love him all the more for this little stumble. It proves he’s human enough to sometimes make the wrong choice when following his heart. Our Lady Peace isn’t my favorite band by a long stretch, but there’s something about this guy choosing to sing his favorite song by his favorite artist in spite of the fact it was not the smart choice that really resonates with me. I think the reason that so many people are shocked at David C’s off-night is evidence of how brilliant an artist this guy really is. At the beginning of this season a lot of people were saying ‘He’s good, but David Cook is no Chris Daughtry’. Well more and more I’m beginning to think maybe Chris Daughtry is no David Cook (Actually I’m kidding; they’re both brilliant and would love to see them on tour together… hopefully it will happen soon after David C. wins Idol).
I also think he got unfairly tagged as ‘arrogant’ early on by a comment from Simon and now that reputation has somehow stuck to him despite ample evidence to the contrary. The guy is obviously a humble and genuinely nice guy (he doesn’t even try to self promote his good deeds to get points with the audience; I stumbled across an article online that explained the orange wristband he wears and why). He just is not afraid to take charge of the stage when he’s performing and fearlessly performs with passion. That kind of confidence and true heart is intimidating to petty people who are afraid to live their own lives with passion and so spitefully and jealously cry out ‘how dare he!’ I feel sad for people like that, and I hope David C. continues to ignore the petty insults and pour his heart and soul into every performance.
Also for Jill and her malicious, spiteful and hateful anti-David comments: I honestly don’t see David C. as balding (maybe I’m just not looking close enough? I swear I really don’t see evidence) but really I don’t care and I don’t see how it matters. The dude is awesome, looks terrific on stage and his brilliance shines through on every performance. I don’t see how his hair plays into it, and your comments reflect very poorly on YOU, not on him. You sound like a very ugly, miserable and unhappy person, and I pity you.
- Posted by DanielOh dear god… Never thought I’d say it, but you people that support, or defend, David Cook sound like your straight out of a southern baptist cult. You can cry all you want that he is not arrogant or pompous, but your just lying to yourself because you don’t want to believe that you’ve been suckered by an egomaniac with no self confidence… sound like an oxy moron? Unfortunately, there are David Cooks EVERYWHERE! Just go into any hipster/Emo hangout in your town. Same attitude, same clothes, same style, same vocal inflections… just another eddie vedder wannabee… and above all, same haircut!! With the exception of David Cooks artful balding combover. PATHETIC!
- Posted by Get ReadIf you have any brains or even just a little common sense, you’ll see that he has lived in that world for a very long time… obviously he’s gotten very good at hiding his lack of self confidence and getting you all to believe he’s a talented, unique, and sensitive artist.
Any self respecting rocker wouldn’t be caught DEAD on American Idol. They could win this pathetic show a million times over, but they’ll never get any respect. Not from real music fans… just from radio listeners. There’s a HUGE difference.
Pathetic…
Wow, there’s some hating going on here. Caring and love have nothing to do with cults. Cults are controlling and full of greed and malice. I mean, if you don’t like him, y do you even care so much? Is it your goal to get everyone else to hate him? Just because you don’t like him, no one else can?
- Posted by ShawnaYou act like you know him front to back, but you’re just making judgements (hmm religion?). Oh and saying that he has no confidence isn’t enough? you have to make fun of his appearance “balding combover.” Do you have the right to make fun of someone else? Are you perfect? It’s much easier to knock someone down than it is to pick them up.
Though not a fan of much of the generic musical talent showcased by AI (save a select few), I feel truly grateful for the opportunity to witness a real star in the making -David Cook! What an amazing, engaging performer with the most beautiful voice and tone. I’ll be looking out for this fellow. From what I have read he is also a down to earth, good man. Makes me proud.
- Posted by PepperThose of you who think David Cook is arrogant are so off-base. In high school and beyond, he has excelled at many things: forensics, performing in musicals, and playing baseball come to mind. I have NEVER seen him behave in a cocky way. Whatever you see in him on American Idol that makes you think he is arrogant is a misconception and a misperception. David is personable, humorous, and friendly. The only arrogance I see is your harsh judgment and insistence that you alone have insight into David’s personality from a few hours of television viewing!
- Posted by kathyI am just Cook’s fan, watching him since audition, far from his country. We should admit, in the very very beginning, he is a bit snob. (like many people with brain). Most of the time people will say the same thing about me. LOL LOL. But after those “alright Now” moment, when he claimed himself as a “wordnerd’, and he with simon who shot him with amck “having no kharisma”, He changed. He becomes very humble, never argue back, and admit that he is like going into a rock school with AI. He confessed that he didn’t know a lot of things he thought he did before AI. I guess, he is very human after all. Need to go through things and that makes me even like him. So you guys in US, vote for David Cook!! He is a real “music” it is. He is the only contestant in 7 season, who always think ‘what can I do to please and surprise the audience’. He has fan base in many countries in Asia too, including where I am
- Posted by RachelI like David Cook. I like his outlook on things, and the way he remains open to whatever may come. I love the way he said that he may be like Bice or Daughtry, but he doesn’t really know ‘coz people may see him as Fantasia and such, which kind of shows how much substance he has. ^^ I’m happy that the Idol title was handed to him, even if it’s just a title.
On his being a “self-respecting rocker”, though… I doubt we really need stereotypes to listen to music. I would worship anyone who can tell me what “real music” is… What’s a “rocker”, anyway? And why wouldn’t it be “caught DEAD on American Idol”?
I believe Cook’s business is his own. Whatever his musical style is will either be bought or not bought, but really… How can anyone not deserve respect?
On musical styles and “copies of copies”… I think everyone has influences. The world is really old; whatever you find “original” is probably already an innovation you probably never thought someone already put into realization. If Cook sounds like someone else, then think, “Why do we have genres?”. Of course, he will sound like someone else. He sings in a particular style someone already thought of naming so we can “classify” these things and “define” it. Like someone talking about “real rockers” and such stereotypes and definitions that lead to othering. At least, Cook was decent enough to try and look for non-popular versions of a version that would keep things interesting and, most likely, spotlight the art and the artist that realized it.
Besides, I think what he did is “research” and not just “copy”. There’s a difference. Researching allows you several options and thus, several bases. Copying is criminal if you don’t give rightful credit to a work’s master.
- Posted by Colejune 7,2008
- Posted by leonieThe finale was a long time ago but still reading about DC. I have to wait for his cd’s to come out. I hope for his long career in music and that his God-given talents will be shared by many.