Fan Fare

Entertainment behind the scenes

Paula Abdul views her “Idol” role as irreplaceable

April 21, 2009

“American Idol” judge Paula Abdul is on the bubble at the show. Her contract ends after this season, and it remains unclear if she will come back next year.paula-abdul

Abdul, who is widely considered “Idol’s” least harsh judge, was asked by ABC News show “Nightline” whether Kara DioGuardi, who joined the show this season as the new fourth judge, could replace her on the show.

“I don’t think anyone (can),” Abdul told “Nightline,” in an interview airing on Thursday night. ”First of all, Kara says, ‘I could never replace you.’ And I said whenever there is change, it’s not about replacing anybody, it’s about possibly moving on.”

A video clip of the interview can be found at

So will Abdul move on? She did not say exactly, telling “Nightline” only that she is having more fun on the show this season than ever before. And Abdul said that she and DioGuardi are friends.

Despite that, the two exchanged dueling statements in the media a couple months ago, when Abdul told a celebrity magazine that having four judges instead of three is not the best fit for the show, and DioGuardi responded that she was “disappointed” in the comment.

The four-judge format does not appear to be working perfectly this season. Last Tuesday, a time crunch forced the show’s producers to decree that only two judges would evaluate each performance that night, because the show ran long the week before. So if the show sometimes cannot squeeze in all the judges’ comments – especially the acerbic jibes from alpha judge Simon Cowell that tickle so many viewers – will it continue with four judges next season? And if not, who will go?


Paula’s leaving ? YAY!!!

Posted by moony | Report as abusive

No one is irreplaceable or expendable no one person is bigger than the team/show


It’s unfortunate that so many people feel the need to evaluate everyone else without knowing what they are talking about in the first place. People with chronic pain go through so much as it is. I also have rsd and the pain is unbelievable – the disease has been around forever but yet hardly anyone knows anything about it. I give Paula a lot of credit just to be able to function at all. Knowing her lifestyle with always being on the go with multiple diseases explains it all. As to fulfill all commitments in your daily schedule while being in so much pain but try and present yourself as if your not……… KOODOS TO HER! Everyone deserves making a living. I as many others hope she stays on Idol.

Posted by amy | Report as abusive

Post Your Comment

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see