Fan Fare

Entertainment behind the scenes

Idols do it their way. But they’re no Sinatra

May 5, 2010

                                                     mike lynch                                                     

 Frank Sinatra is a tall order for any singer. 

Add Harry Connick Jr. accompanying on stage, Sinatra’s two daughters Tina and Nancy in the audience and possibly the weakest  “American Idol”  top five for a number of years, and  you’re in for an uphill climb.sinatra

 Only Michael Lynche and Lee DeWyze came anywhere near pulling it off on a night of songs made famous by ‘Ol Blue Eyes.  Lynche, who was “saved” by the judges four weeks ago, looked most at ease and had the best natural fit with Sinatra’s singing style.  He even had the hat!

  But just when Big Mike looked to have won the night with “The Way You Look Tonight”,   Lee came out with an up tempo, rock-style version of  “That’s Life” that Simon Cowell deemed to be by far thge best performance of the night.lee dewyze

But the biggest questions posed by Tuesday night’s “Idol” show were:

1) Is Crystal “in it to win it” or will her laid-back performances of the last two weeks come back to haunt her?

2) Does Lee have the self-belief  to win?

3)  Can Mike cause a finale upset?.

 But after a tight race last week, the obvious candidate for elimination this week must be Casey James.  Slammed by the judges for a stiff, pitchy performance of “Blue Skies”, James must surely have suffered a knock-out punch when Kara told him that his long notes “sound like a lamb.”  (Ouch!)

Post Your Comment

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see