Stock return chart of the day

By Felix Salmon
April 11, 2009


Nick Gogerty has a great post using this chart to explain why mutual fund managers are doomed to underperform the stock market. Yes, stocks as a whole do rather well — but only if you include the really spectacular winners. If you buy the market and a whole and make money doing so, you’re basically following a strategy of making sure that you include the spectacular winners by making sure that you’re including pretty much everything.

Nick explains that while the mean return for the stock market is quite good (or at least was between 1983 and 2007, which was the dataset for this graph), that isn’t true for other kinds of average:

The median and mode for shares returns is actually well below the cap weighted index which is closer to the mean. The charts above indicate 64% of shares under perform the index. This means that managers who “tilt” or weight their portfolio to their best ideas are statistically taking a random sample and doing bad things, increasing the odds of picking sub-index performance and in so doing also diminishing the allocations to the potentially significantly positive outliers that help deliver the mean performance.

Any good fund manager will tell you that, in hindsight, his best stock picks weren’t his best ideas. But it’s really hard to find a fund manager who won’t overweight his portfolio to the stocks he most believes in. And that’s one of the reasons that I’m suspicious of value investing: it’s full of investors who have done so much homework that they’ve convinced themselves they’re right — and they just won’t let go. This results in great stories, but it doesn’t necessarily result in great returns. Quite the opposite.


We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see

Do you know TradeMax? a tax software designed for active investors or traders to manage their trade data maximize their gain/loss strategy, prepare their Schedule D. More detailed by google NoloSoft TradeMax.

May be you can have a try.

Hope can help you.

Posted by nolosoft | Report as abusive

Thursday April 9 everybody was happy:

Stock prices and averages rising, better than expected earnings announcements, the Dow move back above 8000 !

BUT, the charts and several indicators show the start of a big decline.

This means we have now in our hands an opportunity to sell stocks at a better price. Thats all.

Remain focused: Its your money

Chaim Kimelblat aka
Listen with your Brain

Posted by Chaim Kimelblat | Report as abusive