Eli Broad’s art model

By Felix Salmon
April 29, 2009

I had a brief conversation with Eli Broad at the Milken Global Conference, and asked him about my idea that his foundation is well placed to be a home to many different art collections, not just his own.

Broad first explained his art-lending policy: if a museum wants any work of art in his collection, they can have it for as long as they like, so long as they have it on show. But if they take it down for any reason other than on-lending or restoration — if they feel like just putting it in storage for an indefinite amount of time — then Broad will ask for it back.

Would Broad accept a bequest of art from another collector? Yes: “If it’s worked that fit,” he said, “we’d love to have it, lend it, pay for the insurance” and generally add it to the collection. He has a staff doing all that already, and if collectors didn’t feel like reinventing the model themselves, they could outsource it to the Broad Foundation, just like Warren Buffett outsourced his philanthropy to the Gates Foundation.

As for the art market, Broad said that “a big bubble was created, and we’re in the midst of a major correction. It was up 500%, it’s now up 250%, it could fall further.” He seemed to think that the Old Master arbitrage made sense: “Why should Richard Prince sell for more than a great Old Master? Because people don’t want to have on Old Master on their walls.”

I’m sympathetic. But at the same time, Prince is an interesting example to use, since he’s so clearly bubblicious. Broad told me that a Nurse painting which sold for $8 million a year or so ago would be worth $2.5 million now, and I suspect that you can extrapolate that decline pretty much all the way to zero. People might not particularly want to have an Old Master on their walls, but there could easily come a time, in the none too distant future, when absolutely no one has any desire to have a massive joke painting on their walls, either: it would just look dated and embarrassing. Now’s a bad time to sell a Richard Prince, to be sure. But it might well be better, financially speaking, to sell the painting now, when it’s “merely” at parity with an Old Master, rather than to have any hope that it will soar to multiples of Old Master prices ever again. Because that, frankly, seems improbable.

More From Felix Salmon
Post Felix
The Piketty pessimist
The most expensive lottery ticket in the world
The problems of HFT, Joe Stiglitz edition
Private equity math, Nuveen edition
Five explanations for Greece’s bond yield
Comments
2 comments so far

There are Old Masters I’d love to have on my walls. And there is contemporary art I’d love to have on my walls. Desire of the two isn’t mutually exclusive.

Perhaps something happens to taste when you can afford to put a $2.5 million painting on the wall. All of a sudden you think, “Yes to Prince, no to Titian.”

I would not have a Richard Prince in my collection. some are interesting, but not that interesting. My art is an accumulation, not a collection about my life exploring art and reflects my long term visual interests. the financial aspect is Peripheral to my pleasure in owning and living with my art. This is probably why i do not have big investment art nor do i need it. Most of my art has appreciated. it is part of art history.

There are collections that not promoted. Shouldn’t we be discover why they exist and what art they collect? what value they have and how it holds up.

Good and great art will always prevail. As one of my clients, I have 2) said. I am a value advisor. He undrstands that better tha i do.

Posted by joyce pomeroy schwartz | Report as abusive
Post Your Comment

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/