The reality of Google PowerMeter

By Felix Salmon
May 22, 2009


Kevin Drum is getting a bit ahead of himself, I fear, in his embrace of Google PowerMeter. He reproduces this chart, and says that the

PowerMeter app can be embedded on your iGoogle home page. Open it up and you can see exactly how much power you’re using every time you turn an appliance on or off. Neat.

In reality, however, we’re not remotely there yet. You see all those nice smooth lines and little wiggles in the Google chart? That’s not what you’re going to see when you combine PowerMeter with San Diego Gas & Electric’s smart meters. Instead, you’re going to see something much blockier: it’ll only show you total energy consumption on an hour-by-hour basis. So you’ll know how much energy use there was in the hour between 7am and 8am, say, but you won’t be able to see obvious spikes like the one for the dryer in the chart above.

And what’s more, if you turn on your dryer and then run to iGoogle to see what’s going on, you’ll see no change: the data on iGoogle will be for yesterday, not today.

More generally, the information you get from PowerMeter will be a subset, not a superset, of the information you can get directly from SDG&E. PowerMeter, at least in this case, is no more than an information delivery device: there’s no inside-the-home hardware involved, or anything like that. And if you get the information directly from SDG&E rather than from Google, you’ll be able to see not only how much electricity you’re using but also how much that electricity is costing you.

So the dream is great, and the reality is cool, but let’s not confuse the two.


We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see

Well, I guess it is a step forward, but not nearly as cool as Kevin described. I would see no technological reason why it could not eventually be made more real time.

Posted by scott | Report as abusive

Considering one can compute how much anything will cost them, with the exception of thermostatically controlled devices that cycle irregularly, this seems much ado about nothing.
100W/(1000W/KW-HR)*24 HR/DA*30 DA/MO*$0.15/KW-HR = $10.80/MO

Posted by Lord | Report as abusive

There is a much simpler solution to this, and it was part of every Norwegian kitchen decor at least until the mid seventies; the watt meter. The black needle showing you how much power you used at any time and the red mark showing where you crossed into the high wattage tariff. No need for a computer, no need for Google. Instant feedback. But unfortunately no graphs to ponder over for a few hours every evening. I love these retro innovations.

Posted by Gaute | Report as abusive

Well this is a contractual requirement that SDG&E (and all other California investor owned utilities (IOUs)) own & control the data.

Customer data is jealously guarded by the IOU’s in California, you should see the contract language they have.

Normal damages are insufficient to compensate them from damages of customers owning and posting their use profiles, blah, blah, blah.

Posted by sunsetbeachguy | Report as abusive