Mutual fund fee datapoint of the day
What happened to mutual-fund fees and expenses in the wake of the financial crisis? Lipper has crunched the numbers, and it seems that the tumble in the stock market didn’t have much effect on expenses:
Surprisingly, the median management expense for most asset classes was largely unchanged from 2008 levels; most exhibited changes of +/- a few tenths of a basis point.
Fees, on the other hand, are a different kettle of fish entirely:
70% of equity funds realized increases in total expense ratios from their most-recent annual report to their most recent semiannual report. Of those funds with increases, the average increase was +8.2 bps, while for the funds with expense decreases the average decrease was only -2.4 bps.
There’s even a helpful chart:
The reason for the fee hike becomes clear at the end: it’s being implemented in a desperate attempt to keep income from plunging along with the stock market.
Despite the increase in management fee ratios for many asset classes, the revenue derived from those fees has plummeted. We estimate that total revenue over the period examined by this report is down more than 40%…
The total dollar amount of fees collected by open-end funds appears to have declined by approximately 31% over the period examined by this report. This value is in spite of increases in realized expense ratios for many funds.
The lesson here is simple: Stop trying to beat the market, and move to index funds or ETFs instead. (Index funds weren’t included in the Lipper survey.) Mutual funds are moving away from being a mass-market product, and becoming more of a niche product aimed at elderly investors who don’t know any better and who don’t worry much about total expense ratios. The smart money’s moving out of mutual funds, to the extent that it was ever invested in those funds in the first place, and the dumb money that’s left over is largely price-insensitive. Expect these fees to continue to rise for years to come.