Brazil vs the global carry trade

By Felix Salmon
November 25, 2009
powerless in the face of the global carry trade:

" data-share-img="" data-share="twitter,facebook,linkedin,reddit,google" data-share-count="true">

Even capital controls, it seems, are powerless in the face of the global carry trade:

Brazil’s real is the “most overvalued” currency as a “wall of money” coming into Latin America’s biggest economy may overwhelm government efforts to curb its rally, said Goldman Sachs…

“After some initial success with capital controls, real appreciation appears to be on the rise again,” Stolper wrote in a note to clients.

The real has gained 34 percent this year, making it the second-best performer in the world after the Seychelles rupee…

A quickening economic recovery and the nation’s link to growing demand for commodities from emerging markets such as China have led to “unprecedented amounts” of overseas capital flowing into the country, Stolper wrote. Inflows reached $17.6 billion in October, compared with $6 billion to $8 billion in previous months, he wrote.

Yes, Brazil has a lot of commodities, but I can assure you that it’s not exporting $17.6 billion of commodities every month. This is hot money, plain and simple, the tool of speculators who fund themselves at near-zero rates in dollars and invest in an appreciating currency paying an interest rate of 8.75% and rising. The influx does no good for Brazil whatsoever (exporters hate overvalued currencies) while feeding huge dividends to hedge funds and others with little long-term stake in Brazil’s future.

The Brazilian central bank is saying that the current capital controls are “adequate”, and that it’s not targeting exchange rates. But it’s surely well aware that this is the kind of story which tends to end in tears. And that there’s not much it can do to stop the carry trade, without endangering the economy in other ways. Brazil’s technocrats have no desire to wall the country off from international trade and capital flows. Suffering this kind of problem is a natural, if unpleasant, consequence of their decision to open the country up.


We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see

These inflows are a sort of debt attack* to mute various advantages (real and imagined) that os Brasilieros have at present.

*Sweet, sweet molasses, scrumptious and sticky…

Posted by MRegan | Report as abusive

Petrobras Workers Reject Wage Proposal on Suspensions (Update2) 0601086&sid=a8Pn1jpvOxYI

May be of interest.

Posted by MRegan | Report as abusive

But it’s surely well aware that this is the kind of story which tends to end in tears. And that there’s not much it can do to stop the carry trade, without endangering the economy in other ways

maaaaaaaaaaate. Come on. You know, and have written long stories about it, that this isn’t true. If the lesson of 1997-2003 is that “there’s nothing that emerging market countries can or should do about large distorting hot-money capital flows”, then why shouldn’t the lesson of 2005-2008 be “aggressive selling of subprime mortgages is just part of the system and neither it nor the packaging of them into CDOs can be regulated”.

Posted by dsquared | Report as abusive

I do not see the problem; just increase the tax progressively until inflows slow down.

This carry trade thing appears to be a growing problem. Even the Fed mentioned it in the Fed minutes report released yesterday. Reality is that until Messrs Bernanke & Co. start raising the Fed Funds rate, and aggressively, the USD carry trade is a no-brainer for any hedge fund out there. What WILL be scary is when the markets convince themselves that the Fed is about to raise rates and all these hedge funds, short USD and long everything else, all head for the exits at the same time. Can you say squeeze?

Posted by gotthardbahn | Report as abusive

I thought dsquared would bring up Paul Davidson’s international money clearing unit idea. I would do it, but I don’t think I’m qualified.

Posted by chrismealy | Report as abusive