Opinion

Felix Salmon

The evolution of prepaid debit

By Felix Salmon
March 30, 2012

Maybe it’s a function of the Durbin act, which explicitly excluded prepaid debit cards from the massive decrease in debit interchange fees that it imposed on all other debit cards. But whatever the reason, prepaid debit cards are huge right now. One panel at today’s conference — a panel which wasn’t even meant to be about prepaid debit, but rather much more broadly about “Ensuring Consumer Access to the Payments System in the Connected Age” — had four people sitting next to each other, three of whom talked with great excitement about their prepaid debit cards.

One of them, Green Dot, was understandable — prepaid is what Green Dot does. The second, US Bank, was more interesting. Banks tend not to go in for prepaid debit cards very much: they’re not as profitable as checking accounts, and they’re worried about cannibalization. But US Bank’s Convenient Cash card is a notable development in the world of prepaid debit cards, because it’s very easy, if you’re near a US Bank branch, to reload the card for free.

Nearly all prepaid debit cards allow people to top it up using direct deposit — but of course we all end up with money from various different sources, not just the place which sends us a regular paycheck. And if you want to put some cash onto, say, Suze Orman’s Approved Card, then that’ll cost you upwards of $3.50 a pop. (And that’s a charge, by the way, which doesn’t appear anywhere on the card’s official list of fees.)

If you’re looking to get a prepaid debit card as a checking-account replacement, then, and you regularly deposit money into your checking account, then the US Bank offering is particularly attractive. The monthly fees for prepaid debit cards are usually very obvious; the amount you’re likely to end up spending just by reloading it, by contrast, is less clear ex ante.

So it’s encouraging to me that US Bank is offering a product where you can just walk into any branch and reload your card for free, just as you could your checking account. This, it seems to me, is a significant competitive advantage — so it’s weird that the feature isn’t mentioned anywhere, as far as I can tell, on the card’s website. As a result, I don’t know whether you need to go to a teller during bank opening hours to take advantage of this feature, or whether you can use any US Bank ATM which accepts deposits 24 hours a day. In any case, I’m quite sure that other banks are going to follow suit and issue other free-to-reload cards, which should in turn add some healthy competition to the space.

Most exciting of all, however, was the revelation that the US Treasury has been quietly running a pilot program where it issues tax refunds in the form of a reloadable prepaid debit card. It’s called My Account Card, and is a great step forwards in comparison to the non-reloadable cards used for things like benefits payments. Treasury has tried My Account Card in various permutations, and it’s clear that the one with no monthly fee is the most popular. What’s more, you can elect to get not only your tax refund but also your benefits payments on the same card — which means there’s no need at all for any other card.

If Treasury starts sending tax refunds and benefits payments straight to prepaid debit cards around the country, that will be a huge boost to the reputation of an industry which is still often dismissed as the kiddy slopes of banking.

And then, at some point, Simple will start sending its cards out en masse — and the world will see just how powerful and fully-featured such things can really be. Simple’s sales pitch is aligned with that of prepaid debit cards: no surprising fees, lots of predictability. And it’s aimed at a decidedly affluent demographic: you’re not even allowed to join if you don’t have an iPhone or Android phone. The web interface is state-of-the-art, and the card will allow you to do things that other prepaid debit cards don’t even dream of, like peer-to-peer payments and international wire transfers.

You won’t find the word “prepaid” anywhere on Simple’s website: the company is positioning the card as a fully-featured bank account, not as a gussied-up prepaid debit card. But increasingly it’s a distinction without a difference. I just wonder how much those cash reloads deposits are going to cost.

Comments
10 comments so far | RSS Comments RSS

Felix also make note of the PNC Smart Access account here:

http://bit.ly/H2cYn4

Also of note is Green Dot rolling out a remote check deposit that they are calling ‘mobile deposit program’. This was talked about in their 3rd quarter earnings call but they are hiring personnel right now:

http://bit.ly/H2klO1

Regions also has a prepaid account as does BB&T, OneWest, and BBVA Compass. None are as good as US Bank or PNC products. Regions and BB&T will deny their prepaid account to anyone in EWS so they are not true prepaid products.

You do realize that the ‘MyAccount’ card is a GreenDot card.

I hear rumors that Bank of America is rolling something out soon.

Bravo for putting out the word that not all prepaids are lousy ripoffs.

Posted by OuterLimits | Report as abusive
 

“…powerful and fully-featured”! Whenever I hear those words, I know a scam is in the works.

Posted by silliness | Report as abusive
 

“…powerful and fully-featured”! Whenever I hear those words, I know a scam is in the works.

Posted by silliness | Report as abusive
 

Look at that – It’s almost like I paid twice! I hope these smart phone payment schemes are more secure than the commenting system! Can I get my second comment back?

Posted by silliness | Report as abusive
 

Debit cards offer weaker consumer protections. If somebody screws up a charge, your money is gone until you can get the bank to reverse the error. No?

You could say the same of credit cards, I suppose. An erroneous charge may eat up your credit limit. But that isn’t money that I was carrying in the account — it just means I need to find another way to pay.

Still plenty of free checking accounts around here with very reasonable terms… No need to abandon traditional banking yet.

Posted by TFF | Report as abusive
 

“Still plenty of free checking accounts around here with very reasonable terms… No need to abandon traditional banking yet.” (TFF, last above)

*pleads “guilty” to being one of those lawyers who likes to have ink on paper signatures on checks to prove payments*

Color me weird – never have used an ATM or a debit card. Dislike the former in principal, and the latter is just a weak version of a credit card. Why bother? I’m with TFF on this one.

Posted by MrRFox | Report as abusive
 

TFF and MrRFox, you aren’t the primary target market for prepaid debit cards, the unbanked and members of the lumpenproletariat are.

When I was fresh out of college and lived in the grittier part of the city, I had a neighbor who worked as a low-end, er…escort, and she couldn’t get a credit card due to a ruined credit rating, using a pre-paid debit card at least gave her some of the protections that people like you take for granted.

The same held true for the neighborhood corner drug dealer who stood on the corner outside of the liquor store for hours and hours on end hoping to make a sale (this is how I know he sold drugs like crystal meth and marijuana; he tried to sell me some). When he got hungry or thirsty he could go into the store and buy something or reduce the amount of cash he was holding by putting it on the prepaid debit card using green dot if he was having a particularly good sales day.

Bank of America isn’t going to grant people like these a MasterCard.

Posted by Strych09 | Report as abusive
 

These cards are for people who have been temporarily banned from the banking system for too many overdrafts. Banks screen customers through Chex Systems and EWS. If you are placed onto one of those lists you are banned for 5-7 years from obtaining a bank account.

It doesn’t necessarily mean you are poor or have bad credit either. It’s about the overdrafts.

Posted by OuterLimits | Report as abusive
 

I don’t think some of you read the whole post…

“And it’s aimed at a decidedly affluent demographic: you’re not even allowed to join if you don’t have an iPhone or Android phone.”

This isn’t about helping the unbanked or those with bad credit.

Posted by silliness | Report as abusive
 

I read the whole post did you?

That part of the post specifically is about Simple, which despite being prepaid is not aimed at the unbanked.

https://www.simple.com/

The other products mentioned are for the unbanked.

Posted by OuterLimits | Report as abusive
 

Post Your Comment

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/
  •