Counterparties: The fruits of piety

By Ben Walsh
January 25, 2013

Welcome to the Counterparties email. The sign-up page is here, it’s just a matter of checking a box if you’re already registered on the Reuters website. Send suggestions, story tips and complaints to

The world’s oldest bank is facing a very modern problem: almost $1 billion in derivatives losses which have only recently been discovered by management.

Monte dei Paschi di Siena (or Mountain of Piety of Siena, and MPS for short), founded in 1472 and Italy’s third-largest lender, says it may lose a total of $956 million on three derivatives trades. The trades, put on between 2006 and 2009, were referred to as “Alexandria”, “Santorini”, and “Nota Italia”.

Reuters’ Silvia Aloisi and Stephen Jewkes report that Alexandria was closed out in 2012, while the Santorini trade was liquidated in 2009. The Nota Italia trade was restructured and remains open. If you want to  understand the Santorini deal, the place to go is this Bloomberg story, by Elisa Martinuzzi and Nick Dunbar; it seems to have started with a complex equity derivative, and snowballed from there.

MPS received a $2.5 billion bailout last June. Now it is likely to request an additional $5.2 billion in state-backed bonds next week to shore up its capital position.

The political fallout from the disclosure of the losses has been quick: the current head of the Italian banking association, a former MPS executive, has resigned. Italian prime minister Mario Monti is being sharply criticized — as is ECB chief Mario Draghi, who was responsible for regulating MPS at the time of the trades,  as head of the Bank of Italy. The central bank says that it only found out about the existence of the trades “following the discovery of documents kept hidden from the supervisory authority and brought to light by the new management of MPS”. MPS’s board, for its part, says it didn’t review or approve at least one of the three trades.

Regulatory and criminal investigations are now reportedly underway. That’s helpful, because there’s still a lot we don’t know about a story that already reads like a fevered collaboration between Dan Brown, Matt Taibbi, and Larry Summers. — Ben Walsh

On to today’s links:

Rollergirl who met Herbalife distributor in online knitting forum hits back at short-sellers – Planet Money

AIG put a lot of thought into its obvious decision not to sue the government – Matt Levine

An extended exit interview with Tim Geithner – Liaquat Ahamed

EU Mess
On the bright side, it’s “too early to tell” if the UK economy will enter a triple-dip recession – WSJ

The Davos hive mind says the financial crisis is over, but a credit market bubble may be coming – Businessweek
A handy guide to Davos-speak – Ryan McCarthy
The Davos phrase generator – Heidi Moore
“Azerbaijan, Land of the Future.”: Advertising in Davos – Frank Tantillo

Awful job made bearable by dinosaur socks – Business Insider

J.J. Abhrams will direct the new Star Wars movie – Deadline

The challenges of conversational journalism – Jason Kottke

Two charts on unions and income inequality – Mother Jones


We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see

“Mountain of Piety of Siena”?

That would have been “Monte della Pieta di Siena”, if there was any such place, which there isn’t. “Monte dei Paschi” means “Mountain of the Pastures” – ie the grazing land near Siena, the ownership of which was the original capital of the bank – it was a land bank.

A “Monte di Pieta” in Italian is a pawnshop, but that’s not got anything to do with BMPS.

Posted by dsquared | Report as abusive

This institution apparently had its origin as a “mountain of piety” but was given its new name when Siena was incorporated into the Grand Duchy of Tuscany in 1624.

Posted by Christofurio | Report as abusive